These were placed in a primary. I asked the doctor to narrow my tip & he indicated he'd use a cephalic trim and dome sutures. However, I received these uncomfortable struts bc he felt my cartilage was "weak". 5 yrs later I still find them uncomfortable and I have significant tip asymmetry and alar retraction. I want a revision but docs seem scared of these grafts. I also have a columellar strut which is awkward when kissing. Is there any way to undo this?
November 12, 2011
Answer: Removing grafts from a previous rhinoplasty
A seasoned revision rhinoplasty surgeon is rarely scared of previous graft placement; almost any graft can be removed, but with caution and meticulous dissection so as not to cause injury to other structures. Most grafts do not feel uncomfortable, but may look too full or visible. Alar retraction is rarely caused by the placement of a graft, but is more likely due to too much resection of the cephalic margin of the lower lateral cartilages or the vestibular skin underneath them, or by filling out the columella so much that the alae look retracted. Your tip asymmetry could be secondary to many possibilities, such as healing contraction, a migrated graft, or bossa formation. Most columellar struts go between the medial crura and should not be causing a kissing problem unless they shift. Sounds like your personal conclusions might be best analyzed by a visit or two to specialists in revision rhinoplasty; it may be that removal of the grafts alone will not solve your concerns.
Helpful
November 12, 2011
Answer: Removing grafts from a previous rhinoplasty
A seasoned revision rhinoplasty surgeon is rarely scared of previous graft placement; almost any graft can be removed, but with caution and meticulous dissection so as not to cause injury to other structures. Most grafts do not feel uncomfortable, but may look too full or visible. Alar retraction is rarely caused by the placement of a graft, but is more likely due to too much resection of the cephalic margin of the lower lateral cartilages or the vestibular skin underneath them, or by filling out the columella so much that the alae look retracted. Your tip asymmetry could be secondary to many possibilities, such as healing contraction, a migrated graft, or bossa formation. Most columellar struts go between the medial crura and should not be causing a kissing problem unless they shift. Sounds like your personal conclusions might be best analyzed by a visit or two to specialists in revision rhinoplasty; it may be that removal of the grafts alone will not solve your concerns.
Helpful
November 16, 2011
Answer: Removal of Lateral Crural and Columellar Struts
Experienced surgeons are not 'scared' of the columellar and lateral crural struts. However, be careful to select a good revision surgeon. If you do have weak cartilages you could have some nasal collapse if you remove all the support provided by the cartilage grafts. Your surgeon will need to determine if your cartilages are weak, and if the grafts need to be reduced or repositioned to correct the tip asymmetry, alar retraction, and the stiff columella.
Helpful
November 16, 2011
Answer: Removal of Lateral Crural and Columellar Struts
Experienced surgeons are not 'scared' of the columellar and lateral crural struts. However, be careful to select a good revision surgeon. If you do have weak cartilages you could have some nasal collapse if you remove all the support provided by the cartilage grafts. Your surgeon will need to determine if your cartilages are weak, and if the grafts need to be reduced or repositioned to correct the tip asymmetry, alar retraction, and the stiff columella.
Helpful