Is the crease too high? Of course it is too high. Will it heal to look like the other side? Of course it will not. Don't let anyone blow smoke in your direction you have a problem. It is honestly hard to tell from the photographs but it very much looks like the incision of the left upper eyelid was make far too high. The other issue is that clearly, the left upper eyelid levator aponeurosis is disinserted. That means that as the upper eyelid heals, the ptosis will persist. I am not optimistic that your current surgoen is at all equipped to repair this. Let's talk about the timing of repair. Although this outcome is horrifying, it is fixable. The important thing is to let the eyelid heal so that the repair can be as accurate as possible. Generally, I recommend waiting about 6 months or more for repair. However, that time frame can be very challenging socially. For that reason, we will sometimes repair these eyelids well in advance of that 6 month mark. The more patient you can be to let the eyelid heal and let the swelling to resolve, the more accurate your revisional surgery will be. At a minimum, I would recommend waiting at least two months before having an urgent repair.