Is it common practice to not have x-rays done when a doctor has decided you need an umbilical hernia surgery?

Question

Juan Carlos Fuentes, MD · Answer

An umbilical hernia usually is diagnose during the physical examination, and  X rays or CT scans are not needed. Usually the treatment is done with a direct approach, to close the muscle defect.

Joshua Cooper, MD, FACS · Answer

It it not necessary to obtain any imaging studies to diagnose a small umbilical hernia.  In fact, it would be uncommon to get an x ray or CT scan for an umbilical hernia, as these can be diagnosed on physical examination. At the time of a tummy tuck, umbilical hernias may also be repaired.

Gilbert Lee, MD · Answer

Umbilical hernias are diagnosed by clinical exam.  Therefore, no X ray or imaging study is necessary.  The repair is simple and can often be performed under local anesthesia.  Good luck.

Vincent P. Marin, MD, FACS · Answer

A hernia is normally a physical diagnosis. If there is an extensive hernia or a suspicion for a larger problem associated with the small bowel then a scan might be indicated. Most normal hernias can be diagnosed without this. Continue to follow up with your surgeon to ensure that you progress as planned. 
Best of luck.

Andre Levesque, MD · Answer

Thank you for your question.It is uncommon to need any imaging studies to evaluate and treat a small umbilical hernia with a good history and physical exam.  If I were worried about the size of the hernia or if there was any bowel in the hernia the study that would give the best information would be a contrasted CT scan.Best Dr. L

J. Michael Morrissey, MD (in memoriam) · Answer

An umbilical hernia is a clinical diagnosis. It is diagnosed by the examining hand. An x-ray would not show an umbilical hernia. A CT scan would, but this is often unnecessary as it can be felt by the surgeon when he or she examines you. Some docs will order imaging no matter what, just to create a trail of their thought process. It is not necessary and saved you some $$ Best wishes,

Is it common practice to not have x-rays done when a doctor has decided you need an umbilical hernia surgery?

Answers (6)

More Tummy Tuck Questions

Doctor's say no for tummy tuck for plus size. But yes to panniculectomy for obesity. (photos)

I'm about to have fleur de lis tummy tuck. Will high protein diet help the process of healing? And would liquid protein be best?

Out of pocket cost for tummy tuck for diastasis recti and hernia?

Is the fluid in my stomach after tummy tuck normal?

Uncontrolled pain 2 weeks after tummy tuck, is it normal and what to take for pain?

Has my abdominal muscle repair failed? (Photo)

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS

Answers (6)

More Tummy Tuck Questions

Doctor's say no for tummy tuck for plus size. But yes to panniculectomy for obesity. (photos)

I'm about to have fleur de lis tummy tuck. Will high protein diet help the process of healing? And would liquid protein be best?

Out of pocket cost for tummy tuck for diastasis recti and hernia?

Is the fluid in my stomach after tummy tuck normal?

Uncontrolled pain 2 weeks after tummy tuck, is it normal and what to take for pain?

Has my abdominal muscle repair failed? (Photo)

WE SEND PRETTY EMAILS

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS