Hi there. I hope you don't consider yourself a "plastic surgery nightmare"...To answer your question can a mid face lift be redone? The answer is yes. However, depending on how long ago your procedure was, and the reason or concern for wanting it redone, many times the answer may be to proceed with a more complete facelift procedure. Particularly if something is more bothersome now then before the mid face procedure was performed. If the concerns are the same as they were before surgery then the question is whether or not the mid face lift procedure was the "best " option and /or was it technically successful? What you currently describe as not looking tight, usually is a good thing in that a natural look is usually preferred. The finding of your face and cheeks being wider also is typically a good thing following a mid face lift in that one of the goals of the mid face lift is to lift the mid face and achieve a more "heart shape" appearance of the face which is a seen in a youthful face. If the procedure was recent (< 6 months) you still may have some residual swelling which may also be a part of what you are seeing. Overall, if you have already invested in the procedure and invested in a surgeon to help you with your goals, I recommend you return to him/her and discuss your concerns.