Your photos show breast ptosis with the nipple position sitting lower than ideal and some deflation of the upper breast. If the goal is a lifted, better-shaped breast, some type of breast lift incision is usually needed. Implants alone can add volume, but they generally do not move the nipple/areola high enough when there is this degree of sagging, and they can sometimes make the breast look heavier. The scar pattern depends on how much lifting and reshaping is required. A periareolar scar can help only a small amount and may widen the areola or flatten the breast if asked to do too much. A vertical/lollipop lift often gives more reliable shaping with less scar than an anchor lift, while an anchor pattern may be needed for more significant skin excess. Based on the photos, a vertical lift with or without an implant would commonly be discussed, but an exam is needed to confirm. Scars cannot be avoided with a true lift, but they can often be managed well with careful closure, silicone gel or sheets, sun protection, and time. The best plan is the shortest scar pattern that still gives the shape you want, because choosing too little incision can lead to a disappointing breast shape.