I would use an instrument known as a punch biopsy to remove your mole which takes out a small circle of skin slightly larger than the mole. One small stitch should be used so it will heal quickly. A small scar will result which usually is hard to see once the area has healed.
My recommendation would be for a punch biopsy, slightly larger than the mole. In a punch biopsy a circular instrument acts sort of like a cookie-cutter and makes a cut just outside the mole. If possible, a double layer closure, meaning there is an inner suture and an outer suture, would give you the best cosmetic result. This technique would preserve tissue which should then be sent off to pathology to be sure that the mole is benign. It is important to use something like Eucerin Aquaphor healing ointment over the healing wound to minimize the potential for a scar.