Why won't my surgeon do a peer to peer review?

I'm sorry to hear you are having trouble with your insurance. You are not alone most tummy tuck surgery is performed outside of insurance. If you have been denied then the problem is with your insurance not with your PS. There is really nothing more to add. These companies don't want to pay for this and the doctor is often ignored. Patients have a mightier voice and you are best to advocate for yourself or consider having your tummy tuck as a cosmetic procedure.Good luck

Body lifting surgery is considered cosmetic and insurance companies do not want to pay for it in the majority of cases.

Even though you consider this a necessary procedure, most of us consider it cosmetic in nature. To that end, insurance companies deny it, even if you have a pannus of skin from weight loss. Most of the time my patients have to pay out of pocket for an abdominoplasty , either fleur de lis or standard incision. It is not a matter of fair, insurance companies consider it cosmetic and it is up to you to fight them, not the doctor. 

Thank you for your questions - often when an insurance company denies coverage of a procedure, they provide a list of reasons.  If these reasons include prerequisites that you have not fulfilled (documentation of conservative management from your primary care for a certain duration of time for example, or a certain number of episodes of infection/cellulitis which required antibiotics), then having a peer-to-peer phone call will not help.  The only time a peer-to-peer is useful is when you have demonstrated compliance with all listed prerequisites and requirements and the insurance company is still denying pre-authorization.  I suggest calling your surgeon's office to understand what additional information is required so that you can ensure that is complete before resubmission.  Best of luck!

If the insurance company referenced a mandatory prerequisite that you have not fulfilled, there would be no reason to go through the peer to peer review.  If they require 6 months of documented dermatology treatment, for example, then if you want to have surgery now, it would be fee for service.  If you are willing to wait and try to comply with the criteria, then start the conservative management and reschedule the procedure. Also, you should have received a copy of the denial letter containing appeal rights.  Read it because appeals are typically required within 30 days, not after 6 months.