Thank you for sharing the photo and your frustration—I completely understand why this feels discouraging. What you’re describing is very common, especially on the nose, and you’re not alone in feeling like topicals just aren’t cutting it. What this actually is Based on your description and the image, this is most consistent with a dilated pore / enlarged follicle that repeatedly fills with sebum and keratin. Many people call this a “persistent blackhead,” but it’s really a pore that has become structurally enlarged over time. Once a pore is stretched, topical products cannot permanently shrink it. They can help keep it cleaner, but they won’t change the pore’s architecture. Why it keeps coming back The pore is structurally widened Sebaceous glands in the nose are very active When the plug is removed, the empty space simply refills This is not due to poor skincare or lack of effort So if you’ve tried retinoids, acids, salicylic acid, or extractions without lasting success—that makes sense. Is there a permanent fix? To be very honest and realistic: ➡️ There is no truly permanent cure, but there are treatments that can significantly improve it and reduce how often it refills. Options that actually address the root of the problem include: Prescription-strength retinoids (best long-term maintenance, not a cure) In-office procedures that stimulate collagen around the pore so it tightens: Chemical reconstruction (like TCA-based techniques) Targeted resurfacing treatments In select cases, oral isotretinoin (Accutane) can dramatically reduce oil production and recurrence, even when used at low doses What does not work long-term Repeated manual extractions Pore strips Over-exfoliating (this often worsens oil rebound) Expecting over-the-counter products to “close” the pore My honest takeaway This is not a hygiene issue, and it’s not something you’re failing to treat correctly. It’s a structural pore problem, and that’s why it’s stubborn. The goal is control and improvement, not perfection: Reduce how often it fills Make it less noticeable Prevent inflammation or scarring With the right approach, most patients can get this to a point where it’s far less bothersome and doesn’t constantly demand attention.