Hairs that are grown from minoxidil are usually not the genetically impacted hairs but these hairs are dependent upon minoxidil so stopping it could be a real problem because of the dependency that is developed. If you feel that minoxidil is not good for you, then don't use it
IMO the liquid is a better choice but I see no contraindication. Both forms are popular. In my practice I use Formula 82 which seems to be well tolerated.
Finasteride blocks about 60% of circulating DHT by blocking 1 of the 3 DHT receptors. Most people taking finasteride do see some results and about 10% of those taking it experience side effects. If you are interested in seeing better results with lower incidence of side effects I...