Dermapen vs dermaroller; Which one is better among dermapen and dermaroller for acne scars?

Question

Which one is better among dermapen and dermaroller for acne scars, pore size and pigmentation problems. My skin type is Asian and is medium dark in color.

Jason Emer, MD · Answer

It can depend on the type of scarring and location. This is tough to answer without pictures. I recommend getting a formal evaluation with a cosmetic dermatologist for a formal evaluation and treatment options. All acne scars require a combination approach for improvement. I recommend lasers, microneedling/prp, subcision and fillers. See an expert. Best, Dr. Emer

Jean M. Casello, MD · Answer

Microneedling pens are more precise with the controlled channels they create, because they enter the skin perpendicularly. These "channels" are essential for resurfacing scars and collagen stimulation. Most microneedling devices are adjusted to deeper treatment depths which is more effective for treating acne scarring. For even more dramatic results we do recommend having the procedure done with PRP or some other type of  growth factor serum.  Dermarollers will most likely not give you the results you are looking for because they usually do not reach the appropriate depth in your skin and will require more treatments. They also have the potential to create small micro tears as the needle leaves the skin creating more trauma to the epidermis and possibly uneven healing.

Richard Ort, MD · Answer

We currently perform microneedling with the SkinPen.  Compared to the Dermaroller, the SkinPen hurts less, bleeds less and has an easier recovery.  Most patients prefer the SkinPen for these reasons.  Overall, we have been very pleased with the ease of use and results from the SkinPen. Regards,Dr. Ort

Steven F. Weiner, MD · Answer

The difference is the way the skin is penetrated and the number of penetrations. The Dermapen does many more penetrations with smaller needles and they are perpendicular to the surface. The dermaroller is fewer, larger holes and they are more traumatizing to the skin because they enter at an angle and exit at an angle. These facts make the Dermapen my preferred treatment over dermaroller.

Davin Lim, MBBS, FACD - Account Suspended · Answer

I personally prefer Pen over Roller, however, as specialist we use energy based 3rd or 4th generation devices. Certainly using a skin needling device at home can help, however newer ways to treat acne scars, especially combined with PRP can give faster and better results. For more on how to use skin rollers, see the video below. Dr Davin Lim

Dermapen vs dermaroller; Which one is better among dermapen and dermaroller for acne scars?

Answers (5)

More Dermapen Questions

Dermapen treatment 2mm needle: Can this needle depth cause further scarring?

What is the appropriate depth of Dermapen for laxity and wrinkles?

Is shaving bad 10-14 days (2 weeks) post Dermapen treatment for acne scars? I shave everyday and can barely get through 2 weeks.

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS