What's Best for Eyelid Rejuv/lift - Eyelid Ulthera Vs Eyelid Thermage Vs Madonna CO Lift?

It is impossible to make any specific comments without a photo. Restylane can be used in the tear troughs; to elevate the brows, I would recommend an initial trial of Botox. Honestly, I agree with Dr. Kabaker that none of the treatments you are considering will produce significant or lasting results.

Thank you for your question. For upper eyelid problems, if there is  loose skin, then CO2 has been very reliable.  If there is fat, and excessive skin, then get the surgery with a Board Certified Plastic Surgeon or (No Suggestions) if they feel you will benefit and are a good candidate. I hope this helps.

In order to evaluate for eyelid treatment versus brow treatment you want to take a look at the brow location.  The upper eyelids can appear aged either due to ptosis or descent of the brow or to relaxation and redundancy of the upper eyelid skin. 

 

The Ulthera can help when a small amount of lift is needed for the brow.  If lifting the brow doesn't create the refreshed appearance you are looking for or the brow is at an adequate position then direct upper eyelid treatment is necessary.  This is often done with the CO2 laser 'Madonna eyelift' for a small amount of skin tightening or surgical excision if more skin tightening is needed.