Do I Need Alar Base Reduction?

Alar base reduction is for wide nostrils. Your width is fine and you only need the tip and bridge refined,

I completely agree with the panel.  I would also note that you have a very specific request, and it is good to get perspective and feedback from discussions.

However, if you move forward with a procedure, I would recommend that you make your first priority the choosing of the best surgeon/artist with the greatest track record for rhinoplasty.  THEN, discuss specifics of what would work best for your expectations, anatomy, and goals.  Best of Luck!

A wide nasal base can be treated with an alar base reduction in rhinoplasty or nose jobs.  Based on the single photograph you provided, I believe you would benefit from refining he bulbous nature of your nasal tip, but it appears your nasal base is within normal limits.  I would leave this alone.  Good luck.