After a Donut Cut Lift, Why Does One Areola Get Larger and the Other Remain the Same?

Sorry you are unhappy.  Without pictures it is hard to comment fairly about the overall result and your expectations.  That being said, I am very selective with who is a candidate for a donut mastopexy in my practice.  If a person has poor scarring the past, I avoid the technique. In addtion, I will only perform if 1-2 cm of lifting is required.  Any greater than that leads to great stretching on the areola.  Also, did your surgeon use a permanent suture for the purse-string?  If he/she did not and a great amount of skin was removed, then stretching of the areola is definitely possible and probably expected. 

Thank you for the question.

Unfortunately, your experience is not unusual. Circumareolar mastopexy is a very limited operation with a relatively high rate of problems associated with abnormal scarring, areola asymmetry and the need for further surgery.  Although the use of permanent sutures may be helpful in preventing spreading of the areola,  the sutures also have their own share of problems.

In person examination may be helpful;  it may be that conversion to a vertical mastopexy is necessary to relieve the “stress” off the circumareolar incisions.

Best wishes

There are a number of issues here:


unequal amounts of skin removal create different amounts of tension on the scar

the scar size can be controlled by using permanent sutures

a better lift and scar control can be done with a lollipop or vertical lift

anchors lifts are old school and not needed

benelli lifts are not the same as a donut