In a question posted on Realself asking if it is possible to get a rhinoplasty for under $1000, a plastic surgeon suggested that it is possible to get rhinoplasty and other plastic surgery procedures at a lower cost at a major university such as UCLA or USC by a resident under the guidance of an experienced plastic surgeon. I just wanted to confirm if this is a possibility.
Get Plastic Surgery at a Lower Cost by a Resident at a University?
Doctor Answers (16)
Rhinoplasty by resident
The learning curve on rhinoplasty is very gradual and it easily takes 10+ years to reach a level of mastery to produce consistently good results. I would rank rhinoplasty as the LAST cosmetic procedure you would want to have done by a resident
Lower fee for rhinoplasty by a resident
Though the price of $1000 is very low, even for a resident-performed rhinoplasty, it is possible. That being said, you need to be aware of exactly what that means. Although the low cost is very tempting, you usually get what you pay for. Even in experienced hands, rhinoplasty is a challenging operation and there is always a risk of a result that des not fully meet your expectations. When you are having it performed by an inexperienced surgeon, this risk is greatly amplified. In my experience, patients who focused on price and went for a "bargain" procedure regretted it and ended up requiring secondary complex procedures, which were very expensive, to repair the damage caused during the initial surgery. Best to save and research to find the surgeon in your area most experienced with the procedure.
Lower Cost by a Resident at a University
Yes, it is possible to receive savings by utililizing a resident through an university affiliated teaching hospital. However, rhinoplasty is complex procedure that a surgeon will gain better results with experience. Rhinoplasty has the potential for many complications, and is difficult to revise. Therefore, it is best to choose an experienced and expert surgeon for rhinoplasty. The risk is not worth the minor savings that you might recieve.
You might also like...
Resident Plastic Surgeon
I trained at UCLA and did cosmetic surgery in the resident clinic. You can obtain very good results through the residents. They are supervised by an attending surgeon for these cases. Donald R. Nunn MD Atlanta Plastic Surgeon.
Get Plastic Surgery at a Lower Cost by a Resident at a University?
Yes, it is or at least it used to be when I was training and later the head of Facial Plastic Surgery at one of those institutions. However, things have changed and it might not be so easy to pay and have a Rhinoplasty as a day surgery anymore. The other thing to consider is that Rhinoplasty is perhaps the most technologically difficult plastic and cosmetic surgery procedure and may not be the best one to be a training case. At the end, of the day however, only you can decide if the risk outweighs the potential gain.
IMHO, the most important thing in selecting your Rhinoplasty Surgeon is their ability to understand and follow the proper aesthetics of facial (and nasal) beauty for the creation of a naturally, more attractive nose.
Lower cost surgeries at a University.
It is a great idea to contact a University for the cost of surgery by a resident under the guidance of an experienced plastic surgeon. The cost can be signifincatly lower.
Rhinoplasty can certainly be performed at a university with a plastic surgery residency training program. Residents will be supervised by an experienced professor in almost every case. I would not expect that any university would be able to perform the procedure for under $1000, and your fees may also include not only the surgeon's fee, but also fees for the anesthesiologist and fee for the time in the operating room. Some of the most accomplished rhinoplasty surgeons in the country operate in university settings with plastic surgery residency training programs, and most procedures performed by these professors would also incorporate some portion of the procedure being performed by residents, in accordance with their training and skill level.
All the best,
Plastic surgery for less with a trainee
It's possible to have plastic surgery for a little less with residents or fellows but for it to be less than $1,000 is very unlikely. No harm in asking that's for sure. To answer your question, yes you can get it for a little less and yes the attending surgeon is present taking the trainee through the case. Also understand a couple of things: 1. It's not someone's hands but the decision making that makes a difference so having a resident perform the operation is usually just fine. 2. The "trainee" is most likely a very experienced and skilled surgeon with anywhere from 700 to 1500 procedures under their belt. They're not going to let somebody fresh in the program touch you.
Chase Lay, MD
Cheap Rhinoplasty and Plastic Surgery at Teaching Hospitals
Yes, it is likely that cosmetic surgery can be done for significant less money at a university affiliated teaching hospital via the "residents clinic" than a private practice Plastic Surgeon.. .At some point every plastic surgeon in training needs to practice and learn how to do all procedures both cosmetic and reconstructive. You are trading the potential risk of inexperience and therefore less predictable outcome for cost savings. On the other hand as a former tenured professor at one of the universities you mentioned, I can tell you that surgeries are usually staffed by experienced and well trained professors who oversee the work being done, so the risk vs benefit question becomes hard to make sense of. I think what I would do in your circumstance is ask the resident/fellow how many of these procedures he/she has done, and the name of the Attending Doctor/Professor (look him up re: credentials) and ask if he will be present during the entire case. The other consideration is that the resident surgeon will graduate or otherwise move on to another facility and you may not have access to him/her for long term follow-up.
I run the resident clinic at Stanford University and can only speak about our program personally. Our residents are supervised by board certified plastic surgeons. These physicians are there to ensure that the surgery is done appropriately and that sound judgements are made.
Our goal is to have happy patients. The last thing we want is for a patient to be unhappy or seek a revision elsewhere. That would not make for a sustainable practice.
Sure, rhinoplasty is one of the hardest operations in plastic surgery to master. The key to having a successful result in my opinion is finding a physician whom you are comfortable with. That they understand your goals and you are confident in their abilities.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.