Face Mole Removal- Excision or Shave? (Photo)

I have a mole on my face (glabella) and have received two different recommendations from two plastic surgeons. One recommended full excision, while the other advised against excision due to the potential for scarring in such a visible area and suggested a shave removal instead. My dermatologist isn't concerned about the mole from a medical standpoint and is leaving the decision up to me based on my preference. I understand that shave removal can carry a higher risk of regrowth, but I’m also concerned about the potential scarring from a full excision. Since this is on my face, cosmetic outcome is really important to me. I’d love to hear any insights regarding which option is best from a cosmetic perspective.