Is It True That Removing my Mole on my Breast Will Scar Like a Cigarette Burn? (photo)

An option would be to have the mole completely surgically excised.  I would recommend that you see a plastic surgeon or a dermatologic surgeon for an evaluation and possible treatment.

I would recommend have a large dark raised mole excised since if you only shaved it flat, then you would have a large dark age spot or if you went deeper with the shave it would look like a chicken pox  scar or cigarette burn. It is done easily and quickly under local with a multi-layer closure for roughly $350-500 and give the best cosmetic result. Sincerely,

David Hansen,MD

There will be a scar where a mole is removed; there
is no getting around it. But seeing the mole and thinking of what the
scar could look like, I do believe that a shave removal could be more
aesthetically pleasing. There are ways to decrease scarring including
keeping the wound moist, using silicone sheeting on the site for a month or two
afterwards at night, and/or using a laser to decrease redness. It could
take 6-12 months to have the scar turn back, or close to, skin color. If
pigmentation returns and the pathology at this site showed it was a normal, or
inflamed, mole, I often freeze the site lightly to decrease any returning
pigmentation, but this is more for aesthetic purposes. Good luck.

As a plastic surgeon I'm more inclined to excise this which would leave a longer but thin scar on your breast.  In my opinion, this is often better than the "cigarette burn" hypopigmented scars that result from shaving it off.  That said, you look like you have very lightly pigmented skin so either option would probably be acceptable and cosmetically better than what you have now.  Have it evaluated by a plastic surgeon, dermatologic surgeon or cosmetic dermatologist that is comfortable doing minor surgery procedures.

As a Dermatologic surgeon, I remove moles exactly like yours daily.  The raised part is easily removed by shaving it even with the skin, but the darkness I can see around the edges which is not raised would likely leave you residual pigmentation.  This would most likely still look better than the mole, but you also have another option.  That is excision of the mole.  You would be trading the mole for a line scar about 2X the size of the mole, but because of where it is located on your breast, the resulting line scar should be very thin and hardly noticable.  It would have to go through the normal healing period, but may be your best bet.  If unsure, you could shave it off and always have the option of excision if the scar from the shave displeases you, I think either way, in the right hands, your scar would look better than the mole currently does.

Moles can tend to scar more on the chest and back but that's the nature of that area of the body. Proper postcare should alleviate your scarring and it shouldn't be overly significant. I might suggest you find another dermatologist for an evaluation just for a second opinion. I would think a shave removal, followed by good postcare, and maybe a few IPL or laser flashes to the site should leave you with something absolutely tolerable and much better than what you have now. Try to find a dermatologic surgeon - not all dermatologists are created equal.