Kybella vs. CoolMini

What are the pros and cons of Kybella vs. CoolMini?

Doctor Answers 15

Kybella vs. CoolMini CoolSculpting

Both only recently received FDA approval.  It maybe too soon to say which one is better.
Both require multiple treatments, Coolmini 2 for a small neck but up to 4 for larger necks.
Kybella requires 2 to 5 treatments.
Both only have FDA approval for sub mental (under chin) fat and not jowl and jaw line contouring.

Although both are non surgical, there can be some swelling and few days worth of downtime with both.
Expect up to a 25% in fat reduction in both.  Results are not as good as Smart Lipo.
There is no skin tightening.   Both are not ideal for those with significant skin laxity.
This can be overcome with non surgical skin tightening treatments for those who want to avoid any and all surgery such as ultrasound (Ultherapy), external radiofrequency (Theramge) or focused radiofrequency (Endymed).

I offer patients all the above treatment options but if they are open to laser assisted liposuction, such as Laser Lift or Smart Lipo, this becomes the preferred modality as only one treatment is required, there is only 48 hours of downtime, results are superior, plus the jaw line can be contoured, and skin tightening is accomplished with one treatment modality.  Cost maybe a little more however.

Ran Y. Rubinstein, MD
200 Stony Brook Court, Newburgh, New York

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon (ABFPRS)
Fellow American Society forLaser Medicine & Surgery (ASLMS)
Clinical Professor New York Presbyterian Hospital
National Education Faculty (physician trainer) for:
Allergan (Botox, Juvederm, Voluma), Galderma (Scultpra, Restylane, Silk),
Cynosure (Cellulaze, Precision Laser Lift) & Solta (Fraxel, Thermage)
Zeltiq( CoolSculpting)


Manhattan Facial Plastic Surgeon
4.9 out of 5 stars 152 reviews

Coolsculpting Mini vs Kybella

Thank you for this excellent question.  I am excited that we have both on the market now and I expect many patients using one or both treatment modalities.  The Coolsculpting mini will get a broad reduction of the submental fat but has a little more difficult to customize the procedure as there is only one applicator size.  Kybella allow for a customized treatment for every patient based on their physical exam.  I would visit a plastic surgery a practice that offer both of these and who can also discuss with you the surgical options.

Kybella vs. CoolMini CoolSculpting

Pros:
1. Both treatment have been FDA approved for fat reduction of the submental area only
2. Both require multiple treatments
3. Both treatments are non-surgical

Cons:
1. No skin tightening, so not recommended on patients with significant skin laxity
2. No able to treat or sculpture jawline

We also have available SmartLipo PrecisionTX treatment that is able to decrease the submental fat area, sculpture the jawline, and do skin tightening in one procedure. Price are comparable when faced wit 2-4 tratments of Kybella or CoolMini.

Hope this helps,
Dr. Gus Diaz
Double Board Certified in Facial Plastic Surgery
Lumenis National Laser Center of Excellence

Gustavo A. Diaz, MD
Charlotte Facial Plastic Surgeon
4.7 out of 5 stars 15 reviews

Kybella vs Coolmini/Coolsculpting

 This is such an excellent question, I get asked this all the time in my clinic. Kybella gives more predictable and contoured results in my opinion. CoolMini can be an option, but the handpiece limits the amount of contouring that you can do. Comparing apples to apples, these are both non-surgical, noninvasive options  for neck rejuvenation with the  overall advantage going to Kybella. 

Cameron Chesnut, MD, FAAD, FACMS
Spokane Dermatologic Surgeon
4.9 out of 5 stars 76 reviews

Kybella versus CoolMini

Please see my video on cosmetic surgery times website.  
Both need multiple treamtents and take months to see the results.  Kybella can contour the neck and coolmini cant (applicator only fits certain sizes.  Liposuction with or without thermiRF still gives the best results in my hands with very little downtime.  Best, Dr. Emer.

Jason Emer, MD
Los Angeles Dermatologic Surgeon
4.9 out of 5 stars 165 reviews

Kybella CoolMini

Kybella has been FDA approved for use to reduce the double chin; use for other areas in the U.S.A. is considered off label. Three to five treatments are requried to produce noticeable results. Burning tiingling and redness are commonly experienced lasting up to three days, swelling ten to fourteen days.
CoolMini freezes the fat being midly painful during the procedure lasting one hour.  Soreness and tingling are common for up to two months as well as swelling.  Results become noticeable after six weeks.
Both treatments produce a ten to fifteen percent reduction of the fat that is palpable vs fifty percent with liposculpture.
Cool mini is somewhat more expensive than Kybella.

Please use this information when consulting in person with an experienced Board Certified Plastic Surgeon prior to making treatment decisions.

Luis A. Cenedese, MD, FACS
New York Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 19 reviews

Kybella vs CoolMini..possibly both

Great question; Kybella is an injectable that dissolves fat; It has been FDA approved for the sub-mental fat (aka double chin) since April but only actually being used in clinics since about August 2015. And the Cool Mini was just FDA cleared for treatment of the same area in the past month. Many of us will be offering both treatments and I think it is too early to say which one will be more popular, but I think there is room for both and both treatments do work.
In terms of the CoolMini, it is a "one size fits some".  If your fat fits the applicator, you can be a good candidate; For some people the applicator is too big to fit their chin and for others it is too small to give them a good result.
Kybella can be used more artfully to reduce the fat in areas that the Mini can not reach or for people who the mini does not fit.
I hope this helps!
Dr. Quenby Erickson

Kybella vs. CoolMini

Both offer permanent fat reduction, which is evident starting about a month after treatment and continues to improve for 3-5 months. Permanent is awesome! There are almost no contraindications for either treatment choice. Kybella causes a "chemical death" to the fat cells, using an ingredient natural to the body, deoxycholate. CoolMini causes a "thermal death" to the fat cells, freezing them to death, since fat cells are more sensitive to cold than other body cells.

Only the Kybella will also tighten the skin.

Also, one can sculpt out the neck and jowls more accurately to desired contours with Kybella (injectable deoxycholate).
CoolMini handpiece of CoolSculpting takes 1 hour per treatment session, and has no significant aftermath to deal with, except some redness and swelling, mild to moderate in amount for a couple hours, at most. Pain is minimal. The discomfort is due to the strong suction and cooling plates used.
To tighten the skin better after CoolMini, one usually needs another skin-tightening procedure.
Kybella takes about 5 minutes of injection time, will cause pain (moderate-to-severe, lasting usually 6-8 hours just after the treatment, and easily taken care of with oral pain medicine), immense amounts of swelling (which peaks 20-28 hours after injections and is almost gone after 2 days...and the more swelling, the more skin tightening!, as shown by the published works of Diane Duncan, MD, one of my teachers). The discomfort is due to the tiny (skinny needles, ~1/4 inch deep) injections (lessened with pre-treatment topical anesthetic cream) and quick death of fat cells. (Bye-bye fat, forever!!)
Both procedures can give patients a transient hoarseness and mild discomfort swallowing solid food for about 4-12 hours, in the first 24 hours after treatment, but no problems with breathing or
The number of treatments of either treatment modality depends on both the amount of fat present and experience level of the doctor. (I have been performing the deoxycholate injections for TEN YEARS, have performed thousands of these treatments, with 100% satisfaction of patients for the neck/jowl area. I was taught by the inventors of the procedure and formula. I have both treatment types available, and find patients have a more desirable outcome from the deoxycholate/Kybella treatments).

Kybella vs Coolmini vs Liposuction

Fantastic question! Good to know all of your options.
There are multiple factors that go into answering this question...
If there is a lot of fat, liposuction is your best bet. This can be done in-office under local anesthesia.
If surgery is not something you are comfortable with, Coolsculpting would be your best bet financially... as long as the Coolsculpting applicator fits and you are okay with more time to see full results (than liposuction). If your jaw is too small or the amount of fat too little, the CoolMini may not fit.
Lastly, if you have a small amount of fat and the CoolMini applicator doesn't fit your face, I would go with Kybella. There is a significant recovery period with Kybella and the product is not cheap. That is why I reserve it for people with a small amount of submental fat.
All three will give you some skin tightening.
My best,
Dr. Nazarian
@drsheilanazarian on Instagram

Sheila S. Nazarian, MD
Beverly Hills Plastic Surgeon
4.9 out of 5 stars 51 reviews

Kybella versus Coolmini

I find that both Kybella and the Cool-mini are highly effective.  The choice depends on patient's preference - needles versus the applicator, expense and nature of the fat and difference in side effects. In a larger neck I prefer the cool-mini for treatment as a cost saving method in my practice. I offer both in my office and customize the procedure based on the patient.  Best, Dr. Green

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.