Eyelid surgery or laser resurfacing - which procedure would best reduce the appearance of dark circles? (photos)

Question

I am looking for a long-term solution to help with severely dark circles. I want help with discoloration and wrinkles and am trying to decide which procedure would align best with my goals.

James R. Gordon, MD, FACS, FAAO · Answer

Thank you for sharing your question and posting your photos. Surgery (blepharoplasty) would improve the lower eyelid bags which create a dark shadow under them. You do not appear to have this issue. Lasers are good for removing dark pigment under the eyes. If the skin is thin and the darkness is simply blood vessels beneath the skin, then only makeup can hide it. See an experienced oculoplastic for detailed consultation. 
Good luck!

Monika Kiripolsky, MD · Answer

Hi Kandaham,
You would actually be a fantastic candidate for a phenol peel to treat the dark circles.  Make sure to go to a board-certified dermatologist for this procedure as it is an advanced technique and - because you have a darker skin type - there is more potential for complications than when one of these procedures is performed on a pale white person.
Hope this helps!
Dr. Kiripolsky

Anna Chacon, MD, FAAD · Answer

Deciding between eyelid surgery (blepharoplasty) and laser resurfacing for addressing dark circles, discoloration, and wrinkles under the eyes depends on the underlying causes of your dark circles and the specific outcomes you are aiming for. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you make an informed decision:

Eyelid Surgery (Blepharoplasty)

**Pros:**
- **Structural Improvement:** Effective for addressing sagging skin, puffiness, and fat deposits that contribute to the appearance of dark circles. 
- **Long-Lasting Results:** Offers a more permanent solution to structural issues.
- **Wrinkle Reduction:** Can help reduce wrinkles by tightening the skin around the eyes.

**Cons:**
- **Invasive Procedure:** Requires surgery, which involves incisions, anesthesia, and a longer recovery time.
- **Risk of Complications:** As with any surgical procedure, there are risks such as infection, scarring, and changes in sensation.
- **Cost:** Generally more expensive than non-surgical procedures.

Laser Resurfacing

**Pros:**
- **Improves Skin Texture and Tone:** Can be very effective for reducing discoloration, wrinkles, and fine lines by promoting collagen production and skin regeneration.
- **Non-Invasive:** Less invasive than surgery, with quicker recovery times.
- **Customizable:** Different types of lasers can be tailored to specific skin concerns.

**Cons:**
- **Multiple Sessions Required:** Often requires several treatments for optimal results.
- **Temporary Results:** While effective, the results may not be as long-lasting as surgical options, especially for structural issues.
- **Risk of Side Effects:** Potential for side effects such as redness, swelling, and pigmentation changes, particularly for darker skin tones.

Considerations for Decision-Making

1. **Cause of Dark Circles:**
   - **Structural Issues:** If your dark circles are primarily due to fat deposits, loose skin, or puffiness, eyelid surgery may be more effective.
   - **Pigmentation and Skin Quality:** If discoloration and fine wrinkles are the main concerns, laser resurfacing might be better suited.

2. **Desired Outcomes:**
   - **Permanent Structural Changes:** For a more permanent solution to structural issues, blepharoplasty is likely the better option.
   - **Skin Quality Improvement:** For improving skin texture and pigmentation, laser resurfacing could provide the desired results.

3. **Recovery Time and Tolerance for Invasiveness:**
   - **Surgical Recovery:** If you are prepared for a more invasive procedure with a longer recovery time, eyelid surgery might be appropriate.
   - **Quicker Recovery:** If you prefer a less invasive option with quicker recovery, laser resurfacing would be the way to go.

4. **Consultation with a Specialist:**
   - **Personalized Advice:** It is essential to consult with a board-certified dermatologist or plastic surgeon who can evaluate your specific condition and recommend the most appropriate treatment based on your skin type, the severity of your dark circles, and your overall health.

Both eyelid surgery and laser resurfacing can be effective for reducing the appearance of dark circles, but the best choice depends on your specific goals and the underlying causes of your dark circles. A consultation with a qualified specialist will provide you with personalized advice and help you make an informed decision.

Raffy Karamanoukian, MD, FACS · Answer

Dark under eye circles can make you look tired and older than you are. I would use a combination protocol that includes topical Melarase creams first, followed by a combination of injectable fillers, fractional laser, and RF to blend out the eyelid hollowness and tighten the skin. 
Recommended Creams: Melarase Brightening Kit
MelaClenz
Melarase AM
Melarase PM
Melapads
Replenish Retinoid Cream
Best, 
Dr. Karamanoukian 
Realself100 Surgeon

Eyelid surgery or laser resurfacing - which procedure would best reduce the appearance of dark circles? (photos)

Answers (4)

Answer: Recommend doing CO2 and a combination of melarase creams to help brighten the under eyes

Answer: Recommend doing CO2 and a combination of melarase creams to help brighten the under eyes

Recommended reading

Everything you need to know about Laser Resurfacing

Our mission is to create a world where every investment in modern beauty is Worth It.

Eyelid surgery or laser resurfacing - which procedure would best reduce the appearance of dark circles? (photos)

Answers (4)

Answer: Recommend doing CO2 and a combination of melarase creams to help brighten the under eyes

Answer: Recommend doing CO2 and a combination of melarase creams to help brighten the under eyes

Browse related questions

Recommended reading

Everything you need to know about Laser Resurfacing

Our mission is to create a world where every investment in modern beauty is Worth It.