Skin Tightening Under Eyes VS. Fillers, Which Would Work Best? (photo)

Stick with what works. Fillers fill up hollow areas, which is what you have under your eyes. Laser tightens the skin, which you don't need.

Restylane is the preferred filler product for this area.  There is no reason that you can't have all the benefit you have enjoyed from the prior treatment.  Laser resurfacing procedures are may not provide what you need.

If there is hollowness or a depression in the under eye area, especially the junction between the lower eye lid and the cheek, then a filler is the best choice. Remember a filler does exactly what it sounds like. It fills. So, if there is hollowness or a depression, use a filler. Other options may be helpful if there is skin laxity or skin texture issues, such as crepe paper appearance, or etched lines or wrinkles.

Restylane and Belotero are my favorite under eye fillers. I often use a combination of the two because they each have different characteristics. Restylane is for lift, and Belotero is for superficial placement in thinner skin.

I think that since you did well with Restylane you should use that again. Never mess with success.