It's been 1 yr with no answers, what is this lump on the right front side of my nose? Could it be cartilage or a cyst? (Photos)

I’ve been given differing opinions by dermatologist, ent, and plastic surgeon. Derm & ent plastic surgeon say cartilage , plastic surgeon says cyst. The fix ranges from scarring my nose to slice it out to a small rhinoplasty unless he gets in there and sees it’s a cyst after all. No one can tell me what this is. It’s on the right front side , with one also forming next to a tip mole I have. I’d like any opinions I can get to try to deal with this. It’s already been a year with no answers