I am trying to decide between saline and silicone. I have had both and both have ruptured. Because I now have silicone, and the rupture is causing nerve pain and traveling to my lymph-nodes, I need to get it removed. I would like to get them replaced and am trying to research which is better.
May 12, 2025
Answer: Saline vs. Silicone After Rupture – Which Is Safer to Replace? Sorry to hear about your experience with ruptures. If silicone has caused nerve pain and lymph node involvement, removing the current implants and capsule is the right first step. In terms of replacement options, Saline implants may be a better choice in your case. If they rupture, the body absorbs the saline naturally, and the issue is immediately noticeable. Unlike Silicone implants that tend to feel more natural and maintain shape better, but when they rupture, it can be silent and—like in your case—lead to complications if not caught early. Ultimately, it’s important to get a consultation in order to get the most suitable recommendation based on your medical history and personal goals. Best, Erman AK, MDPlastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon
Helpful
May 12, 2025
Answer: Saline vs. Silicone After Rupture – Which Is Safer to Replace? Sorry to hear about your experience with ruptures. If silicone has caused nerve pain and lymph node involvement, removing the current implants and capsule is the right first step. In terms of replacement options, Saline implants may be a better choice in your case. If they rupture, the body absorbs the saline naturally, and the issue is immediately noticeable. Unlike Silicone implants that tend to feel more natural and maintain shape better, but when they rupture, it can be silent and—like in your case—lead to complications if not caught early. Ultimately, it’s important to get a consultation in order to get the most suitable recommendation based on your medical history and personal goals. Best, Erman AK, MDPlastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgeon
Helpful
December 3, 2024
Answer: Silicone vs Saline There are pros and cons to both silicone and saline implants. You can review them both to decide which is for you. Both are FDA approved and considered safe. I've included a video that goes over both types to help you with your research. Be sure to discuss your options with a board certified plastic surgeon who can go into more detail with you.
Helpful
December 3, 2024
Answer: Silicone vs Saline There are pros and cons to both silicone and saline implants. You can review them both to decide which is for you. Both are FDA approved and considered safe. I've included a video that goes over both types to help you with your research. Be sure to discuss your options with a board certified plastic surgeon who can go into more detail with you.
Helpful