Rock hard nose - is it edema or hanging columella? (Photo)

I don't believe that you have a hanging columella either at rest or with smiling. Since your cheeks will pull your nostrils wider when you smile, there will naturally be a change in the appearance of the bottom of your nose. In my opinion, you do not have an unusual appearance to your Columella. Firmness of the columella may take longer than one year to completely go away if it is due to swelling. Sometimes cartilage grafts are used at the base of somebody's nose and this may have feel firm to the touch as well. Definitely don't stress about your nose! Wishing you well. Sincerely, Dr Joseph PS If you have severe dissatisfaction, you should bring your concerns to the attention of your surgeon, or consider getting a second opinion from another reputable rhinoplasty specialist.

At 9 months, most of the swelling should be gone. However, you can still have some swelling. I would recommend giving it at least 1 year before doing anything. I would not recommend a revision.

Best Wishes,

Gary Horndeski, M.D.

Your description is typical of what can happen with a cartilage graft in your columella. They call it a columellar strut. I’ve removed many because of complaints such as yours