Write a review

Very Disappointed - Madison, WI

I did it because I used to be a boxer and had my...

I did it because I used to be a boxer and had my nose broken a few times.



I had reconstructive nose surgery from this Dr. in January of 2006. He took cartilage from my ear and put it on the tip of my nose for better support. When the bandages came off and the swelling went down I noticed a bump that goes across the tip of my nose where he put the cartilage. He said it was from the swelling and would eventually disappear. More than four years later it is still there. Twice he made some minor tweeks to correct this with no success. I have had many people ask me "did you get a bug bite on your nose?"

I am a performer in the entertainment industry & I have lost a considerable amount of film and print work due to this issue.

Madison Facial Plastic Surgeon

I recently talked to "patient relations" to see if another Dr. from this facility could look at the problem and fix it. I was sent a letter that more or less said too bad, if you want it fixed, pay for it yourself. So, if you need any surgery on your face and want it to look natural, please find a surgeon who will stand behind his work or send you to a Dr. that will correct his work. I understand mistakes can be made, but they should also be corrected.

1 out of 5 stars Overall rating
Was this review helpful?

Comments (7)

I agree, do you have photos?
  • Reply
I had a similar experience in Madison, WI and I currently have after 2 surgeries a very lopsided nose, a wider mid-section, a much bigger tip than my original nose, and about a 1/4" farther projection because for some unknown reason this doctor built up the top mid to bottom portion of my nose and built-up the left side more than the right-very uneven. I can see and feel what looks like a large pimple, but I know it is a chuck of cartilage on the middle left side of my nose, which I begged him to remove after the first surgery, but it is still there. I never had breathing problems and now I cannot breathe. It feels like someone shoved something up my right nostril and I am woken up several times a night because my right nostril makes a loud whistle noise. I live on Advil and decongestants. I had 2 surgeries with this doctor and everything he said the opposite occured. He is very dishonest and is good at one thing-photoshop. Don't be fooled by pics your doctor shows you, make sure you get real referrals from people. Best thing I did do was let family and friends know I was getting the surgery, so I had their honest opinions. The doctor tried to convince me I was not seeing my nose as it really was, but I have a very large, intelligent, compassionate and honest support group and not one of them said anything different than what I believed. I went in for a smaller nose and came out with a bigger, very lopsided, lumpy nose, which I cannot breath out of. It is going to take a miracle worker to fix this mess, so if anyone knows of a great doctor-please let me know!
  • Reply
Wow our experiences are indeed very similar. Believe me, I feel your pain. Do you mind sharing the name of your doctor??? I ask because I had my third revision perfromed by a doctor in Middleton, but very little was fixed. In fact, I too am researching new surgeons. I am so depressed about the whole situation. As for a good doctor, one of the best I have researched is Dr. Motykie in CA. However, much of this is based on before-and-after photos and not actual referrals which, like you said, can be risky.
  • Reply
I had the EXACT same situation as you after a rhinoplasty revision performed by Dr. Andrew Campbell in Sheboygan. I mean EXACTLY. This grafted cartilage created a bump on my left tip that looked and felt like a huge ingrown pimple. Several people (only close friends and family, of course) commented on it. I have since had to go to a THIRD doctor to have my nose fixed, but much of the damage caused by Dr. Campbell is irreversible. Even making matters worse, he charged more money ($10,000) than any doctor I have ever researched and or consulted with! I was fooled by the exceptional (and very corrupt and inacurrate) marketing/advertising this doctor does. All in all, I am now up to a grand total of $25,000 on my nose and just devastated with the results still. Did you ever find a doctor to successfully revise your nose??
  • Reply
Can you say who the doctor was or maybe the clinic or street it's on? I am currently considering rhinoplasty and would definitely take your experience into consideration when choosing a clinic.
  • Reply
Yes, I saw another Dr. who said he could fix it. But I would have to pay out of my pocket since it now seems to be a cosmetic issue. I guess that is what I will have to do. I just feel I shouldn't have to pay almost $2,000 for another doctors work.
The photo situation is difficult since the bump is more visible when lights are shining down on me. I tried to get some photos taken, but the flash of the camera always seems to take away all shadows on your face. I'll see if I can find something to post.
  • Reply

I'm sorry you're unhappy with your rhinoplasty. Have you gone for a second opinion elsewhere?

Also, do you have a photo you can post?

  • Reply