Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Disappointment - CA

ORIGINAL POST

I will try to update with pics as soon as possible...

Can'tBreathe2013
$8,000

I will try to update with pics as soon as possible but right now it is hard for me to take one without crying. I had my procedure a few weeks ago with a double board certified ENT/ Facial cosmetic surgeon. I decided on him after meeting with two other cosmetic surgeons. I had an open septoplasty/ turbinate reduction/ rhinoplasty with cartilage graft. My nose had been broken once before. My breathing is much improved from the procedure but the cosmetic outcome makes me wish I never did any of this. I went to my doctor based on a referral from a family friend who's cosmetic outcome was simply gorgeous. I then scheduled an appointment for consultation, and the doctor really seemed to know his stuff. He showed me his book full of pictures and the results were nice and natural looking. Being that his pictures looked good and I had the advantage of knowing someone who, 2 years after the procedure still looked great and was pleased with the outcome, I booked my surgery.

Recovery was tough on me because I am not a mouth breather, and I was lucky to sleep more than 15 minutes at a time due to waking up coughing with a dry throat. Aside from that, I did not have much pain or anything like that..

I had my cast removed over a week ago. When it came off my nose was all red and flaky and I did not really know what I was looking at face on, so I tired not to look at it too much. He showed me a glance from the side and I instantly thought "the bump is still there!" but really tried to just not judge yet. He put the tape on and I went home.

I was told I could take the tape off a few days later and continue to tape whenever I wish. I will tell you right now, this tape is staying on my face until I get a revision. I look far better with it on than off. I know, I know, maybe there is still swelling, I am not even a month out, yadda yadda.... my nose is CROOKED. Not uneven swelling, crooked. as in leaning way more to one side.

As I said before my nose was broken, so he did a cartilage graft to balance things out but all it did was make it big and make it lean. I had nothing done to the tip or my nostrils. This was supposed to be a "finesse" type rhinoplasty. my bridge is still high, crooked, and there was supposed to be a straight line but there is still a boney, non-swollen hump that then dips down towards my tip. I can see where he did the graft how I still feel/look swollen, but that considered, this is not a nice outcome, and if the swelling keeps going down it will honestly probably look worse and make the bump that is still crooked and big, more prominent. I only told a few people I had this done and I am embarrassed for them to see what I paid for. I don't want my fiancé to look at or touch me. I don't want to leave my house. I am normally a strong person and can take things into consideration, but I know this is not an "it will get better" situation. Others like me who have had a bad outcome knew something was wrong right away. Now I face the even more terrifying thought of a revision... which I don't even know how to deal with. Seriously disappointed.

Can'tBreathe2013's provider

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

The doctor is not listed on this site, but I chose him based off of the recommendation of a family friend who appeared to have had a nice result. I will private message about my doctor to those who privately inquire. *******I also will no longer be responding to messages from non-established members on this site (people who sign up only to message me, are not documenting an experience or openly commenting to other members). *******

Replies (3)

May 17, 2015
Can you please post photos
May 17, 2015
Hi there, and thank you for your interest. At this time, I will not be posting photos. If it had gone right I would have, but it's a whole different thing when it does not work out. Thank you for your understanding.
February 19, 2016
I'm sorry you went through this, i feel your pain. we're in the same boat. Did you ever get a revision done?
UPDATED FROM Can'tBreathe2013

1/2/13 After doing a little research and mulling...

Can'tBreathe2013
1/2/13
After doing a little research and mulling it over, the initial shock and disappointment has subsided quite a bit. I have decided the World is not ending. I posted originally right after seeing that this bump will not go away by itself. But the more I have looked into it, I would revise that review to a "not sure". Nobody goes into this wanting/ expecting to have to have more fine tuning done afterwards. I realize after talking it over with my hunny & family that yes, there are still areas to be improved but it is better. Apparently septum shifting back to its original place happens, and isn't necessarily the fault of the surgeon. It's nature. It is unfortunate I had a residual bump but I am not alone with that. This is something that also can happen and from what I read can be resolved as soon as 6 months out. At least it was not over-scooped. This also does not mean my surgeon was incompetent. I placed a call to him and we will discuss the next step but I realize I had a complicated nose, and I could have had this outcome with even the best of doctors. I have high hopes and anticipate him to be more than understanding and to help me through this and want to further remedy this not only for myself, but his already wonderful reputation. This is just the reality of what can happen with this type of surgery. Good luck and best wishes to all! Will update again, soon :)

Replies (4)

User Avatar
January 3, 2013

I'm sorry you're not thrilled with your results, though it sounds like you're more at peace than you were when you initially posted your review. We'd love to see your before and after pics so we can visualize what you're describing.

Please keep us posted and let us know how you continue to heal.

January 4, 2013
Hi Angie! Yes, I am trying to be more at peace with it in the meantime.... it is very hard and I still have my moments where I break down over it. Last night was my first trip leaving the house with out tape over it to mask it while running errands and that was quite challenging for me. It is an emotional roller coaster even for those who are happy with their results, and it is considerably more so when you have an undesirable outcome. I will try to get pics up soon as I said I would. It is still just very hard for me to look at them myself, let alone have the World do so. But I know this site is for showing, not just telling.
User Avatar
January 4, 2013
Sorry to hear that you didn't like your results. but just remember that sometimes we are harder on ourselves about things and it really may not be as bad as you think. I look forward to seeing your pictures. I've read plenty of stories on here where people feel disappointed of the result at first, but as they give it time they end up loving it. Just be easy on yourself and give it some more time to heal.
January 4, 2013
Thanks for the words of encouragement. I spoke with my doc yesterday and he sounded very concerned about my being unhappy with this apparent residual bump. Though he said he didn't anticipate any touch ups needed he would still give it a look and see where we are at. I am hoping to find out what is going on and really hope I don't get the run around of the whole "it's just swelling" game. I will continue to try to be easy on myself! It is quite upsetting to spend so much money and feel like you really did your research over the last few years, as well as have realistic expectations and come out of it all feeling even more self conscious. I am trying to stay strong.
UPDATED FROM Can'tBreathe2013

So to catch all up to speed, swelling has...

Can'tBreathe2013
So to catch all up to speed, swelling has subsided, and I dislike it more and more. I know, everyone is all about seeing pics and I know I prefer a review with pics but I am sorry.... if I was happy or satisfied in any way I would, but I am so upset over it that it just is not going to happen. For people in my area who want to pm for pictures I could probably arrange that. But if I go posting on my review, well I might as well post naked pictures, too. That's how I feel.

My surgeon doesn't really know what he can do for it, which I am on the one hand glad he expressed because if he has no confidence in himself than I don't either. While it is sad I can no longer trust him, better than for him to lie and I end up with a bigger disaster. On the other hand it is so unacceptable to me that he has no real explanations. In regards to the residual hump, he said "I don't know if fixing it would even be worth it". I wanted to yell "WORTH IT TO WHO?!" Because OBVIOUSLY it is worth it to me. I'd maybe bear it if it even resemled my old natural bump before I broke it, but this is a completely different looking one. My nose still looks broken... the only real change was the sides were narrowed. Only one side was narrowed in too much to where the side bone sits under the top bone instead of joining it smoothly... giving me a real nice dent. It still leans, and I see no attempt was actually made to straighten my septum. I had a nasal valve collapse prior to surgery from a break that I thought he would address being that he said he was going to use spreader grafts... well he totally ignored where it was really needed. He said he didn't put any where the collapse was because then my nose would look too big... I'm sorry but I thought this was about achieving balance? So the narrowed sides now emphasize the collapse. This is why, even though lots of docs don't like computer imaging, it would have been helpful in this case because I would have a visual of his intent not to fix my collapse, and I wouldn't have gone to him.

Not a day goes by that I am not depressed over it. It is ruining my life right now and my relationship. I never liked my nose to begin with but I never sought surgery until I literally broke it. I figured that it made sense to fix something broken. I researched doctors for longer than most do, and this still happened to me. So just know, no matter how much of your homework you do, you could still end up unhappy and the end result could be very hard on you psychologically. I did my best to be patient and have hope in all of this even though I was unhappy since cast removal, but I can't pretend anymore. I'd even take my broken nose over this one, because at least I didn't pay for that one. I wish the best of luck to everyone on their journey of trying to be satisfied with their reflection.

Replies (6)

User Avatar
March 9, 2013
Miss K, just read your review ....I'm very sorry. I know how difficult this is...please try and stay busy and try to count your blessings as time passes. Hoping it gets a lot better as it heals. The more work that was done, the longer it takes so patience is a must. Hugs
March 9, 2013
Thank you, Faith. My situation is looking more like a case that gets worse with healing... pinching and collapse and such. I have very thin skin so it is hard to camouflage. I am still trying to be positive but it is very difficult as you know. Thanks again!
User Avatar
March 29, 2013
Hi MissK, same here.... initial swelling often masks problems that eventually become apparent as the swelling subsides. I had a feeling things would get worse for me because I preferred my nose in the morning when swelling was worse but tried my best to stay optimistic. Have you met with any other surgeons yet?
March 29, 2013
Yes I find I like my nose more after I cry, lol--- I always swell up in my nose when I cry, even before surgery. Nope no other docs yet. I think I will wait just a bit longer before going on any more consults, since I have time before a revision.
March 28, 2013
I am very sorry to hear all of this! It is very tough to hear as I know how it feels to be embarrassed about your nose...but think of it this way, you seem to be a confident determined person by nature! Do not let this defeat you because there are things in life that are far more important. Also, hold that surgeon responsible! If he promised you an outcome that was not delivered he needs to try harder to make you happy..something should be done, you deserve it...I hope for nothing but the best outcome, overall! Keep your head up and Good luck :)
March 28, 2013
Thanks, ANune 2012! I appreciate the kind words. I usually am a confident and determined person.... I suppose that is one reason why this has all been so difficult and tolling! I did try to hold him responsible, but when I last met with him he had no explanation and no solution to the problems he caused and the problems he did not address. I have lost faith in him due to him seeming to not have confidence in himself to handle these issues. At first I took it as a death sentence for my nose.... well, this doctor acts like it can't be fixed, so it can't! But I have gone on to realize that some people are just more capable & experienced than others. There was a time I would have trusted him to fix it but I believe it is best for me to seek a specialist at this point. I had always liked him up to our last meeting.... but he made me lose hope and I can't get back my confidence in him. I want all issues addressed and he tried to sugarcoat all but one. Not cool :/ But thank you again for the kind words, I will try to stay strong! :)