Best Treatment for Ice Pick Acne Scars?

What is the best treatment for ice-pick acne scarring? I am interested in doing Fraxel Re:pair, and maybe punch excision beforehand but would like more input.

Doctor Answers 16

You have a few good options for ice-pick acne scars

Punch excision followed by a laser such as Fraxel re:pair which is a fractionated CO2 laser device is a reasonable strategy for ice-pick type scars in Fitz type I and II (lighter) skin types. I would caution you that in darker skin types, the risk of pigmentary problems is high. Lasers alone for acne scars in general are not that helpful, and much less so for pitted acne scars. Fillers while helpful for rolling scars, spoon-shaped scars, are usually not appropriate for ice-pick scars.

You do have a couple other options as well, including:

Saline subcision which involves breaking up the scar tissue under the ice-pick scars as one method to promote collagen growth.

The "Cross" method which involves spot application of a very strong chemical peeling agent to stimulate the growth of collagen can help "fill in" the ice-pick depressions over time.

To appreciate the results of saline subcision and the "Cross" method requires patience, since the final results are not fully achieved until a year after starting treatment.

I would consult with a qualified physician to review what option(s) would be most appropriate for you.


San Diego Dermatologist
5.0 out of 5 stars 5 reviews

Ice Pick Scars and Punch Excision

Ice pick scars are characterized by punctate deep scars that are usually caused by deep cystic acne. These scars are difficult to resurface with laser or chemical peels because the base of the scar is deep with very steep sidewalls. The most effective treatment has remained punch excision with suturing despite many advances in lasers and chemical peels over the years.

Fraxel may diffusely improve the overall quality of the skin but there is no clinical evidence to support the claim that it will improve deep punctate ice pick scars. However, Fraxel laser resurfacing may improve more superficial scarring associated with chronic acne.

If you are considering a treatment for acne scars, you should discuss options with a physician who is familiar with the use of chemical peels, lasers, subcision, and punch excision of scars.

Raffy Karamanoukian, MD, FACS
Los Angeles Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 63 reviews

Acne scars- TCA CROSS or punch excision followed by laser

Ice pick scar....sounds deep, and hard to treat, but they are one of the easiest acne scars to treat....and treat well. I usually use TCA CROSS  70-100% , several sessions, or 1-2 mm punch, suture, then heal. This is then followed by total or full laser resurfacing.

Ideally I use erbium, with a downtime of 8 days. One treatment and its done and dusted. This combination of treatments can improve ice pick acne scars by upto 90-95%, in some cases, we can totally remove scars all together. 

In summary, one of the easiest types of acne scars to treat, no matter what colour of skin you have. Review my before and afters on acne scarring for an idea. 

Regards

Dr Davin Lim
Consultant Laser Dermatologist
BRISBANE
AUSTRALIA

Davin Lim, MBBS, FACD
Brisbane Dermatologist
5.0 out of 5 stars 13 reviews

Treatment for Ice Pick Acne Scars

There are a few options for treatment of acne scars. Small, deep acne scars can be treated with surgical excision, which will ideally trade a depressed and discolored scar for a thin, flat scar.

Other techniques to improve the base of large or numerous scars involve resurfacing the skin by intentionally traumatizing it in order to stimulate collagen production. This thickens the skin and shrinks the surface area of the scar, and color may be improved as well. The Cross technique uses a very concentration of TCA peel. Lasers and dermabrasion (surgical resurfacing) are other techniques that are used to resurface large areas. Often, several techniques are used over time to get the best result. Patience is key since the full effect is often not seen for several months, and multiple procedures are usually necessary for a significant improvement.

Risks include temporary or permanent lightening or darkening of treated skin, crusting, scabbing, scarring, reactivation of cold sores, infection, redness, acne flares, milia formation.

Dana Goldberg, MD
Jupiter Plastic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 23 reviews

TCA CROSS works for ice pick acne scars.

For deep ice pick scars, I use TCA - CROSS, a technique which involves spot peeling with TCA 50% or 100%, applied at the base of the scar using a blunt, but fine probe. Results typically start showing around 6 to 8 weeks, with more improvement over 3 - 6 months,  and it works fine even in darker skin, which is the type I predominantly get to treat. A test area targeting say, 5 to 10 lesions, should always be treated before going onto a larger area. This technique does have a downtime of about a week, during which time the treated areas may be covered with concealer/ make up.

Ice Pick Acne Scars

Punch excision is an excellent method for icepick scars. This procedure uses a circular biopsy tool which is basically a round, sharp "leather punch" type tool that comes in diameters ranging from 1.5 mm to 3.5 mm (rarely larger). The size of the tool is matched to the size of the scar to include the walls of the scar. Under local anesthesia the scar is removed with the punch biopsy tool and the skin edges are sutured together. The newly produced scar eventually fades and may not be noticeable. If it is noticeable, it is more amenable now to resurfacing techniques.
My favorite treatment is a strong focal chemical peel using the “cross hatch” technique. Trichloroacetic Acid (TCA) is the peel typically used. TCA peels are considered medium-depth peels (with 100% concentration being the strongest). In the treatment, the solution is applied to the bottom of the scar with a wooden instrument (like a toothpick) pressed into the base of the pit. A white crust forms on the scar base after the procedure is complete. This superficially deconstructs the bottom of the scar to stimulate collagen neogenesis and the healing process. This can fill in the scar, decreasing scar depth ideally helping the skin “blend in”.
Always consult with a board certified dermatologist for best results catered to your specific condition.

David J. Myers, MD
Salt Lake City Dermatologic Surgeon
5.0 out of 5 stars 3 reviews

Treatments for scarring

It is hard to dertermine the best course of treatment without seeing the severity of the scarring first, but what you have listed are both options.  We usually treat with a combo of a deep peel with profractional laser for the more server scarring. 

Recently BellaFill received its indication for acne scarring and we are having great success with the product. It is a long lasting filler that will allow you to not have to continue to fill the scar over and over again.

Hannah Vargas, MD
Kansas City Facial Plastic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 29 reviews

Ice pick acne scars?

Four techniques are especially good for acne scars. Punch lift, punch excision, CROSS and microneedling. I used to prefer CROSS but have been impressed with agressive microneedling to 2.5 mm with or without PRP. Thanks

Jeffrey Rapaport, MD
Clifton Dermatologic Surgeon
4.5 out of 5 stars 21 reviews

Ice pick acne scar treatments

Ice pick scars can be difficult to treat. Some patients have great results in minimizing them but others unfortunately will go through all treatment options with moderate results. Depending on the size of the scars your best option may be going to a board certified plastic surgeon and having them excised. There is a chance this can lead to additional scarring but an experienced plastic surgeon will guide you in the right direction and give you realistic options. Another treatment choice is to have the area filled with filler such as Juvederm or possibly even have dermabrasion done. There are definitely many treatment options out there its just a matter of finding the one that will work for you.

Ice Pick Scars

The best treatment for ice pick acne scars is often laser. Laser treatments such as the FAST treatment for acne scars is a two part approach to helping to build collagen to fill in scar scars and resurface the skin entirely. 
The Focal Acne Scar Treatment (F.A.S.T.) procedure, which combines two different fractional CO2 lasers and delivers outstanding results in a short period of time.  There is also the new platelet rich fibrin matrix (also known as PRP treatment or vampire facial), which promotes the growth of healthy skin and new collagen formation in and around the area of acne scars by introducing your body’s own growth factors deep into the dermis. This new acne star treatment is best used in combination with laser procedures and produces results that are very impressive.

Eric Schweiger, MD
New York Dermatologic Surgeon
3.5 out of 5 stars 12 reviews

These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.