I've heard about juvederm and restylane but also long lasters like sculptra. for deep scarring is there one preferred injectable treatment?
What’s the Best Dermal Filler for Acne Scars?
Doctor Answers (14)
Acne scars - Make it plump and make it last
There are so many fillers these days that it is often difficult to know which is best. Acne scars are a specialized treatment area and thus the choice is often times easier.
The two basic requirements should be that the filler plumps the skin well enough to correct the scar and second that it lasts long enough for prolonged correction.
My personal favorite is Radiesse (Calcium hydroxlapetite). This filler plumps, provides immediate correction and last approximately 9-16 months.
Microroplet silicone is another excellent alternative. This is a specialized technique performed by only a limited number of physicians. It is a permanent filler and must be used with care.
ONE IMPORTANT NOTE ABOUT ACNE SCARS: there are many different types of acne scars (ice pick, box car, rolling type scars), and they must be approached using different techniques and combinations of techniques including lasers, acid peels and then fillers as a final therapy.
Dermal fillers and laser treatments
Fillers can improve the appearance of acne scars by partially lifting the depressed scar but their effect is temporary. The results can last from between a few months to a year using fillers such as Restylane, Juvederm, and Perlane, etc. However, laser treatments such as Pixel, Smoothbeam, Erbium or Fraxel can dramatically and permanently reduce the appearance of acne scars with improvement of overall tone.
Dermal Fillers for Acne Scars
Which demal filler that is selected depends on the type of acne scar that is being treated. For atrophic scars we use saline injections or a hyaluronic acid filler normally. If there is deeper tissue loss sometimes a volume filler like Sculptra or Radiesse is used. Fillers are usually not helpful for thicker scars and ice pick scars.
You might also like...
There are many options for filling in scars
Fillers are a temporary way to fill in depressed scars. Restylane can last about 6-9months, and radiesse 1-2 years. Fat can be another option to fill in scars and can last many years like 10 years give or take a few years when done right.
In my experience, using temporary fillers gives one only modest results and most people are left desiring more improvement. Other ways to lift the scar include subscision technique where you use a needle to lift the scar up so that it sits level with the plane of the rest of the skin. This can be done in conjunction with laser resurfacing. Other ways to lift up the scar is to use biopsy instruments to incise around the depressed scar and this is then lifted up into the right plane. Another way is to cut the scar out and follow this with resurfacing.
Depends on what type of scars, shallow, deep, rolling....
different fillers for different scars. If scars are superficial a more fluid filler is preferred, whilst deeper rolling scars and atrophic scars can benefit from lift and VOLUME, hence a thicker longer lasting filler is needed.
I often combine fillers, thick filler for deep scars and volume loss, thinner filler such as Restylane for superficial scars. This seems to work best.
Dr Davin S. Lim
Dermal Filler for Acne Scars
Filler Treatment for Acne Scarring Depends on Condition
Best dermal filler for acne scars
Most fillers plump exactly where they are injected, and the results can be seen immediately. These are hyaluronic acids like Juvederm and Restylane, which last 9-12 months, and Radiesse, which lasts up to two years.
Sculptra also lasts about two years, but injections are performed in a different way. A small amount is injected into several sites over a large area, and the entire area is stimulated to produce collagen and thicken slowly over several weeks to months. Sculptra injections are usually repeated to get the best benefit.
There is no one best filler since each patient is different. Someone with a few deep scars may benefit from spot treatment with Juvederm, whereas someone with multiple slightly more shallow scars may do better with Sculptra injected everywhere. Most often, these treatments are done in conjunction with other resurfacing techniques like laser and peels to get the best improvement.
Filler selection for scar tissue will depend upon the depth of the scar and your comfort level with fillers. Deep scars tend to respond best to more durable, firmer fillers. More superficial ones cannot hold thick fillers, and hyaluronic acid is preferred. Sculptra will last 2+ years, while hyaluronic acid (Restylane and Juvederm) may not last the full year.
Filler for Deep Acne Scars
Deep acne scars, not pits which are small deep holes, are often best treated with more than one modality.
In many cases, subcision (a special needle or blade is passed under the scar to release it).
To elevate the scar, autologous fat transplantation, Radiesse, or Sculptra are typically used.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.