I am seriously considering rhinoplasty to rid my nose of a hump and to shorten it slightly as it is over projected. I live in Boston and have met with 2 surgeons so far. One is the chief of plastic surgery at a top hospital and has been practicing for 30+ years. He does about 50 rhinoplasties a year among other procedures. He told me that he would need to make a small incision under each eye for my open rhinoplasty procedure. Is this necessary? The younger surgeon did not mention doing this.
Are Incisions Under the Eyes Necessary During Some Rhinoplasty Procedures?
Doctor Answers (18)
Promoted Local Answer
The incisions he is talking about are for Osteotomies to break the bones after hump removal. It is not necessary. Doing the osteotomies from inside your nose is a much more elegant way. When I was 14 years old I too met the chief of plastics at one of the Harvard hospitals in Boston and he said the same thing. Im glad I waited another 16 years and finally did my Rhinoplasty with an expert who does about 150 Rhinoplasties a year. Anyone doing less than 100 noses a year is just not focused on the nose enough but just because someone does 150 it does not mean he is doing them all well either. Do more research. See more people.
Incisions under eyes NOT necessary for rhinoplasty
Incisions underneath the eyes for a rhinoplasty are totally unnecessary. Osteotomies are all performed through tiny incisions inside the nose underneath the sidewall of the bone. Look for a surgeon who can perform a primary rhinoplasty with the closed technique, not open rhinoplasty. A simple reduction rhinoplasty can easily be performed by closed rhinoplasty. This means that all the incisions are placed internally. Busy rhinoplasty surgeons today usually perform between two hundred and three hundred rhinoplasties per year. Look for a surgeon who is board certified in facial plastic surgery and whose original background is ear, nose, and throat surgery or otolaryngology.
Every surgeon has their preferences when come to break the bone to narrow the nose. There are more older surgeons use the external osteotomy. If you scar well and your surgeon is very good in all other aspects by all means go with them. Otherwise consult another surgeon. I personally had never needed to make an external incision for a close or open rhinoplasty.
You might also like...
Incisions for Rhinoplasty Near the Eyes Are Used to Narrow the Nose
Hello, Boston friend.
Was there recently for the major head and neck surgery convention. Loved the town. Fabulous history. Cute narrow streets. Great food.
Now, getting back to business. Some surgeons do prefer to use tiny chisels, placed through short incisions placed between the side of the nose and the eye area to help crack the nasal bones to narrow them. This is done after the bump is removed. These fine instruments are only 2mm or 3mm wide. Therefore the incisions are very tiny and heal well.
In certain cases where the nasal bones were very thick and refused to narrow using the internal chisel approach, I have done what I believe the professor is recommending. It does work. Healing is excellent particularly when the tiny wounds are closed with one or two very fine stitches. The dissolving kind works beautifully.
Don't sweat that particular technique. The most important issue is: How do the doctors' noses look? Do you like the results you see on his website? In his office " before and after" album? That is really what counts: the results. If you see dozens and dozens of natural-looking noses, you should be comfortable with the doctor. If you are uncertain, then have the doctor do computer imaging to show you the nose he would deliver to you. That is always very important; a meeting of the minds, without guessing about outcome.
Do your homework. Don't mean to brag but my book, SECRETS OF A BEVERLY HILLS COSMETIC SURGEON will help make your research/homework easier. Wrote it for Bostonians and everyone else. Every bookstore has it.
Best wishes to the Patriots!
-Robert Kotler, MD, FACS
Beverly Hills, CA
External Incisions for Rhinoplasty
It is not necessary
It is not very common to perform rhinoplasties by making incisions under the eyes. Most likely these are small incisions that are being recommended but generally speaking are not necessary as most narrowing procedures are done through incisions inside the nose or along the columella or bottom of the nose. You might want to get a second or third opinion. I hope this information helps.
Insightful question....the "incisions" you speak of are the access points for the surgical instrument used to make small perforations in the nasal bones (much like the holes on a stamp) allowing them to break. Breaking the nasal bones allows the surgeon to nasal the middle width of the nose. This can also be done through incisions or access points on the inside of the nose.
I have used both approaches...individualized for each patient. External skin incisions, below the eyes as you state, may have a mechanical advantage and may lessen the risk of bruising and swelling. Whereas, the internal approach, although there is not a scar on the outside, uses a cutting technique that cuts bone and blood vessels, leading to more swelling and bruising (raccoon eyes).
Patients are individuals and have different anatomic requirements....benefits of both techniques. I know Boston well...please say hello to my professors...they taught me well. But, I would recommend that you continue to educate yourself and see as many surgeons as you can to find your comfort zone. A Board Certified Plastic Surgeon who loves rhinoplasty and is dedicated to the procedure, critically annalizes his/her outcomes, shows you their work and makes you feel confident in their ability to achieve YOUR goals...like a beautiful nose without any external scars below the eyes!
Hope this helps!
Incisions Under the Eyes Necessary During Some Rhinoplasty Procedures
Without photos very hard to answer. In some cases small, tiny incisions help with the surgery. These are very small and disappear in time. Seek more evaluations in Boston.
Nasal infracture techniques
The incisions that you are talking about may be small 2 mm puncture type incisions used to fracture the nasal bone. Most commonly a 2 mm osteotome or chisel is used to make a series of small punctures in the nasal bone. This will create an smooth infracturing of the bone to narrow the nasal base.
These answers are for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as a substitute for medical advice you may receive from your physician. If you have a medical emergency, please call 911. These answers do not constitute or initiate a patient/doctor relationship.