Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty Reviews

24 Yo. Profile Balancing (Rhinoplasty + Chin Aug. + Fat Grafting) - West Hollywood, CA

UPDATED FROM renba91
5 years post

5 year update

renba91
$16,000
Well.. I won’t say much I think the pictures speak for themselves and are testament enough for the subpar work he did. I don’t like my nose anymore than I did after getting the cast off and while it was kind of bearable for a while when the majority of the swelling subsided. It has only worsened over time. He will give you the run around to let it settle for a year but quite frankly, he is so aggressive with his work that you will be so swollen for at least 2-3 years. He overfilled my face with fat all the way up to my nasal bridge and he removed so much cartilage that it took years for the skin to start to shrink wrap to the new shape. My nose did not have any of these problems before surgery and most of these were not so obvious until the last year and a half of so. My nose was not crooked, it was not upturned, and it was not collapsed. I was explicit in stating I did not want my nose shortened or upturned and I didn’t want my front view to change, I asked for my nostrils to be symmetric . The pictures clearly show he did everything I did NOT ask for and more. Of course by now it has been so far since the initial surgery that you can’t get a revision covered by him.
Really disappointing that I let myself be fooled by his photoshopped perfect pictures. Yes his profiles are amazing and yes my profile looks great ; however he completely deformed my nose in pursuit of a balanced profile, which quite frankly negates any point in having the procedure in the place.
For anyone considering him, please take into account that he rarely posts consistent angles of all his patients, he only seems to post the most flattering angles. You will find patients with only 3/4 angles or profiles but no front of under nose pics. Now you know why. I have also updated the poor job he did with my fat transfer.
I am of the belief that if you can’t get it right the first time, you will not any time after that. I refuse to go back to him for a revision. Specially given that there are people who ended up worst with their revision. I’m going to consultations now for a revision and it looks like I will need a graft because he removed so much cartilage and I’m getting quotes in the $20k range. So please think twice about going to him. If I would have known any of this I would never have undergone any of my procedures. I feel betrayed, used, and angry. I felt like he preyed on my insecurities and did whatever he wanted. It’s been a long journey, dealing with a sort of identity loss and emasculation and having to deal with this in my early 20’s... Now I have to deal with the consequences. Even some of the docs I consulted with were in disbelief of what was done to me.

renba91's provider

Gary Motykie, MD

Gary Motykie, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

renba91 rating for Dr. Motykie:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (3)

March 11, 2021
I have been following your journey and agree with everything you have stated on this update. I am two years out and am scared that it will get worse. The fat grafting is horrible. He is definitely aggressive with his rhinoplasty even though he claims to go for he natural look. Very minimal changes. I too was told that my front look would not change . Worst mistake of my life
May 19, 2021
Thx for your longtime review and I understand what you have been through.
Brave man.
My nose tip is now also unique, similar to yours.
I would never recommend a nose job, if it`s not 1000% necessary.
Nose jobs are very hard to get right, even if you have the best doctor.
I underestimate that, but no matter life goes on. Be strong & patient
You still look good
June 23, 2021
Try going to Warren Katz. He did a great job on my nose. It’s such a draining journey and can screw with your mental. But know you’re still a handsome guy either way.
UPDATED FROM renba91
1 year post

1yr 8months

renba91
Nearing the two year mark. Wow time flies. Sorry I don't get on here often enough or post updates often. I don't really plan to have any more work done in the future and I'm just busy. But here are some pics I managed to snap tonight bored at home. Things have settled very well. There's still a tad bit of swelling in the tip and sides of nose. And I've also noticed my cheeks go down a bit more recently. I'm still not super happy about the cheeks but I can live with them. Also I'm sure as I lean out a bit more they'll probably go down a bit more and also help keep me from looking too haggard and tired . Chin is fine. It's still a little odd in close up pics I feel like it's a tad big and boxy given that I already had a strong jaw but I pull it off fine. Nose is great. No breathing issues. There's a little bump on the right side I'm not sure if it's scar or cartilage it's not too noticeable but I'm hoping it goes away on its own. Also not sure why but my left 3/4 shot looks a little scooped compared to my right 3/4 im not sure if my upper lateral
Cartilage is collapsed but I don't have any breathing issues ... yet. It doesn't bother me too much as it's hardly noticeable in pics.
Overall things have come together nicely get compliments often i.e. Are you a model ? and no one has suspected I had any work.
Would I do it again ? Not sure. Do I regret it ? Not really . I don't worry or feel self conscious anymore so I guess that's always a plus. I'd probably have skipped out on the fat transfer to the cheeks. I did lose a bit of angularity with that. Oh well.

Replies (5)

June 24, 2017
You look great. I'm in awe of your face. Your entire review was incredibly informative and you taught me a lot, particularly about aging and bone structure.
July 3, 2017
Roller coaster of a journey but ultimately great outcome.
September 3, 2017
Wow your results are amazing! I am so looking forward to my fat transfer to my face. Thank you so much for sharing your journey!
January 28, 2018
you look so good! I'm at 10 weeks and going through a very similar journey as you so reading this has helped me a lot. Thank you so much for posting this :)
April 9, 2018
you look really good
UPDATED FROM renba91
1 year post

Few more pics

renba91

Replies (5)

October 9, 2016
You look pretty darn perfect to me :)
User Avatar
October 10, 2016
You look is cute, congratulation¡
November 18, 2016
So glad to hear you are doing well! I also had my procedures done last year in November (full face fat grafting, lipo, rhinoplasty, chin implant and bleph done at once. The first 6 months was horrible. I looked like the doll in the SAW movie. My swelling has gone down a lot but the fat injected nasolabial fold has also melted away. So tempted to get a revision. The tip of my nose is still very swollen, look big in pictures sometimes but the septum looks great. My body definitely react to sodium intake differently. My face looks puffy when i have salty food or alcohol. I am still avoiding group photos. I only look good in selfie angeles. Please continue topmost so I know what to expect in the time of recovery. You look great by the way!
November 18, 2016
Hi Victoria, yes I remember your story early on when you underwent these. I'm just over a year and I do still have a bit of swelling in my tip. It's not bulbous but it is a little "boggy" . Some days it's a little more than others . I would wait longer to see if your nasolabial fat grafts melted. I will say that I didn't really have prominent nasolabial folds before but after the cheek grafting it looked like I had nasolabial a for a while. I really hated it. Lately the fat has gone down significantly and when the fat has gone down the nasolabial are less apparent. Trust me it's a very long slow process. I do believe my results will continue to shape for probably at least another 6 months. But things definitely look a million times better . I get a ton more compliments and "looks" now lol. It's crazy that I even got any compliments when I was super swollen and very plasticy looking early on ahahah.
December 23, 2018
Hi Victoriakate ,I just had the same procedures and I’m having a hard time . Can you provide any updates please?
November 25, 2016
I just read your fat transfer review (https://www.realself.com/review/beverly-hills-ca-bad-fat-transfer#) which is decidedly negative, in strong contrast to this positive review. Is your overall result only positive because of revisions? You mentioned kenalog shots.
February 21, 2017
any new updates? Hope all is well :)