Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Breast Implants REVIEWS

Got CANCER and a 17-month-long Seroma from my Implants, Now Forced to Have Them Removed with Even Bigger Scar. - Toronto, ON

ORIGINAL POST

I got my Allergan 410 Naturelle cohesive gel...

FairWanderer
$28,000
I got my Allergan 410 Naturelle cohesive gel biocell textured implants back in 2006. Just over six years later my right breast swelled up to double the size. No doctors could figure it out. Finally, 17 months later, Dr. Tracy Pfeifer in NYC (who is great) figured it out and I got tests done and it's definitely cancer caused by the implants. A type of lymphoma (that's not as rare as surgeons would have you believe, because nobody tests for it, I'm guessing on purpose) called ALCL is caused by getting implants of all types (silicone and saline). Anyhow, I have to have them permanently removed with most of the capsule, which the surgeon tells me is going to leave me looking not-so-great, and with a much larger scar than they needed to put them in (not to mention very expensive). I wish I'd never gotten them. Nobody told me about all the risks, and the ones I knew about I figured wouldn't happen to me -- but the worst-case-scenario did happen to me. Don't think it can't happen to you.

FairWanderer's provider

Mitchell Brown, MD

Mitchell Brown, MD

Certified Plastic Surgeon

FairWanderer rating for Dr. Brown:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (24)

User Avatar
August 15, 2014
So sorry to hear this! Prayers up for you that it hasn't spread & you have successful treatment. This is a scary reality too often overlooked, thanks for sharing.
August 15, 2014
So sorry to hear this!! Thank you very much for sharing.. I just a have a question, were you told that the ALCL was due to the implants? I have done soo much research and they said that there is no proof that implants can cause cancer. Your reply is appreciated. P.S I would just like to give you a small advice, there is a doctor in Rome called Dr. Tulio Simoncini who treats all cancers using bicarbonate and has plenty of good reviews on the internet. I would suggest you do good research before undergoing any surgery or taking any medication. Good luck, hope you will get well very soon..
August 15, 2014
IT's is 100% caused BY the implants. The other info stating that impants don't cause cancer is old and incorrect. Plus, surgeons usually don't test for it... most of the 200 people my oncologist told me about that have ALCL cancer from their implants saw many surgeons over many years, who didn't think to test for it. Google BIA-ALCL and check the FDA website (although the numbers aren't accurate, as they posted that before they notified doctors of the issue). I saw 5 top NYC plastic surgeons and none told me about this. My mom found out about it online and when I asked to be tested, the surgeon said there's no way I have it, so not to test for it. It's only because I insisted and went on my own for that type of biopsy that I finally found out I have cancer. I'm sure the industry wants to keep it quiet.
August 15, 2014
That's not good news!! I was really looking forward to get mine done :( Hope you will get well soon. Do you have any idea what's the relation between ALCL and implants as from what I understood its a type of lymphoma not a breast cancer. I hope you get well soon. All the best.
August 15, 2014
I would also like to ask you, did you go over the muscle or under? And do does it differ with ALCL
August 15, 2014
After reading about ALCL. Can I also ask you if you had textured implants or smooth ones?
August 29, 2014
Over or under, saline smooth or silicone textured... it makes no difference with ALCL -- all types have gotten it. I also think that the stats are completely wrong -- way way more women get this and are simply not tested for it correctly (it requires very specific type of testing that can only be done in certain major top cancer centers, and many doctors would accidentally put the biopsy specimen in formaldehyde which would kill the lymphoma cells and product a negative result, for example, or they would do the wrong test, which happened to me several times before the correct one was done at Memorial Sloan).
August 29, 2014
Thank you for your reply.. I wish you all the best in your recovery.. Get well soon
User Avatar
August 29, 2014
I have been following Dr Roberto Miranda with MD Anderson cancer center in Houston, Tx. and his research on breast implant ALCL. The numbers are very much under reported!
August 30, 2014
Did you get rid of the cancer and do you still have the implants.?
September 6, 2014
Actually, the FDA forgot to ask if the implants were smooth or textured in over half of the cases. In the cases that were reported, they were all textured. Hope that helps!
September 6, 2014
I'm having surgery to have them removed this month. BUT there are cases of relapse, even after the implants are removed, so I'll always have to follow a strict anti-cancer diet from now on. If you want to change your diet, I recommend "Crazy Sexy Diet" by Kris Carr (a beautiful young woman who also has cancer) - it's complete, fun and easy to follow.
November 19, 2014
I am sorry you're going through this and send you well wishes. I do have a couple of questions though. Did your doctors tell you for a fact that your issues are from your implants? Did they provide you with proof? You say you "think" stats are wrong. Do you have hard medical evidence that cancer and ALCL are caused by implants? According to the FDA: "The FDA has identified a possible association between breast implants and the development of anaplastic large cell lymphoma (ALCL), a rare type of non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma." They clearly state "possible". They also state: "Additional data is needed to fully understand the possible relationship between ALCL and breast implants. The FDA is asking health care providers to report all confirmed cases of ALCL in women with breast implants through FDA’s MedWatch Program." This article was from 2013. Just curious on your viewpoints of this data.
November 19, 2014
I am looking to have my implants done next year. I think my comment may have come off rude, which was not my intent. I just want as much information for myself as I can get.
User Avatar
February 9, 2016
As a regulatory affairs professional I think this is a very important issue. Please to the original poster report your implant info to the FDA even if you only know the year and manufacturer. If you have your implant card it should contain everything you need. There is also a phone number you can call to report an adverse event (medical issue) this is how FDA gathers the info they use to determine if something should be considered safe. You can also fill out the MedWatch form online. FDA takes these reports seriously. I am so sorry to hear about your cancer and thank you for sharing your story.
February 25, 2015
That's terrible. I'm very sorry. I hope you are recovering & doing better.
February 25, 2015
Hey sweetie so sorry to read this my anutie had breast cancer in her right side breast but had them both removed and her scarring wasn't that bad as her Dr had told her how to smooth them out so the scarring would not be thick or noticeable and she's manged to get the scarring looking good I had full uplift and scarring looks bad until she told me how to fade them away so anyway my anutie has beaten the cancer and last year she had her breast made back up and they look amazing xx
UPDATED FROM FairWanderer
8 years post

Logic dictates that the stats on how many women get ALCL are totally wrong

FairWanderer
I think that the stats on how many women get ALCL are completely wrong. It only makes sense that way way more women get this and are simply not tested for it correctly (it requires very specific type of testing that can only be done in certain major top cancer centers, and many doctors would accidentally put the biopsy specimen in formaldehyde which would kill the lymphoma cells and product a negative result, for example, or they would do the wrong test, which happened to me several times before the correct one was done at Memorial Sloan). Also, I saw five top NYC surgeons (both in private practice and at the top hospitals here) and a slew of doctors and NONE of them thought to test for ALCL despite the fact that I had a recurring seroma for 18 months. My mom read about ALCL and I had to go get tested on my own to find out I had it. So, if I had that experience in the upper east side of NYC, then imagine someone living in Oklahoma or Brasil... there's almost no chance they'd get tested, or tested correctly. Also, the treatment is to remove the implant and capsule before it spreads and needs chemo... I imagine that most of the women who've had seromas did this without realizing that it was cancer and were just lucky that it didn't spread... or it did spread and they assumed it was regular Lymphoma. See my point? The FDA numbers can't possibly be correct.

Replies (4)

April 23, 2015
you are spot on. I am in Oklahoma. I present to my PC with a large hematoma/fluid collection under my left breast, it was extremely painful. Had ultrasound and they sent me home with ice and pain meds. It subsided several days later. Then suddenly my left arm started tingling and almost went completely numb. I went to the hospital and they did a CT scan and the radiologist came into the room to say my RIGHT implant look deformed or abnormal on the scan, which is odd because I hadn't had any symptoms on the right. PC ordered an MRI two weeks later. MRI confirmed rupture on both sides. Right was intracapsular, left extrcapsular. I went to see a PS/recon surgeon to get on his sched for removal and he read all of my symptoms (26lb weight loss, hair loss, skin rash, night sweats, breast pain, hematoma, arm numbness etc) and he said he had a patient with ALCL with exact symptoms. He didn't feel comfortable removing until I had oncology work up and a PET scan. Oncologist found enlarged lymph node in left armpit and in my pelvic region (both sides). I am going to MD Anderson in Houston in 2 days for clinic visit and surgery. Praying that it hasn't spread. It has been almost 2 months of seeing dr's and fighting with insurance company to get proper tests and get to the right dr's. I am ready to start living my life again!!
April 23, 2015
Also, my surgeon at MD Anderson says they are seeing on average 1 new patient a month with bia-ALCL. It is as rare as they have us believe. I have had my implants for 5 years. Allergan Textured cohesive gel.
August 24, 2016
Did you get a confirmation of BIA-ALCL at MD Anderson?
December 16, 2016
Only 23% of PS are testing for BIA-ALCL. BREAST IMPLANTS cause Cancer, specifically Lymphoma. It is not in the Industry's best interest to promote testing for CD 30. Rare Vs Under Reported are not synonymous.
UPDATED FROM FairWanderer
8 years post

FYI

FairWanderer
FYI: My seroma came and went about every two months for the first year, and then stayed large for the past 8 months. I also had an itchy rash on my calves and arms (probably a reaction to the inflammation).

I'm having surgery to have the implants removed this month, at Memorial Sloan in NYC. They don't think I should put new ones in, but I plan on putting smooth gel ones in (using Dr Tracy Pfeifer) after I heal fully, in 3 to 6 months. No way am I going to wear a training bra for the rest of my life!

Replies (1)

September 6, 2014
Good luck!! All the best.. Wish you a smooth recovery. Btw why did u decide on putting smooth gel one?