Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Revision Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Revision Rhinoplasty for Tip Irregularities and Deprojection

ORIGINAL POST

I had a primary rhinoplasty with another doctor in...

User Avatar
clouds90
WORTH IT$14,000
I had a primary rhinoplasty with another doctor in 2008 to fix a deviated septum and deproject my nose. This left me with an asymmetric tip. Although my nose is still prominent, I am choosing to stay on the conservative side and only fix the tip, as I am satisfied with the length of my nose (especially compared to my original nose). I am scheduled for surgery on Dec. 22 and am very anxious and excited! I have done a lot of research in choosing a surgeon and finally decided to choose Dr. Kim in SF. Thank you to everyone on realself for the worthwile and supportive interactions! :)

clouds90's provider

David W. Kim, MD

David W. Kim, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 71 Reviews
PROFILE
clouds90

clouds90 rating for Dr. Kim:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (20)

November 21, 2014
Excited to see your results! You are in excellent hands.
User Avatar
November 21, 2014
Thank you so much for the reassurance! I have read only great things about Dr. Kim. :)
November 21, 2014
Can't wait to see the revision! It will be great go with confidence you have done your research!
User Avatar
November 21, 2014
Thank you :)
User Avatar
November 21, 2014

And thank YOU for paying it forward and starting your story. I had a revision rhinoplasty as well and was so pleased with how smoothly it went compared to the primary. I hope this goes really well for you. Please keep us updated!

User Avatar
November 21, 2014
I hope so too! Thank you! What did your revision consist of?
December 5, 2014
All the best for the surgery. Thanks for posting 'before' photos. I look forward to seeing photos of the result. I am looking for a very good revision surgeon and have tip issues similar to yours so am very interested in the fact you've chosen Dr Kim.
User Avatar
December 5, 2014
I really really really hope that this surgery fixes my bossa tip. I dream about the end result every day. Thank you for the support and I will keep everyone updated both short term and long term.
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
I heard Dr. Kim was amazing. Please let us know how it goes. Also, I have a question. The Pretrusions on your nose... Was it like that after your primary rhino... Or did that happen over a course of a few years?
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
I noticed that my nose was a bit angular when the cast first came off, but I thought it was just the imprint of the cast. Then there was a bit swelling which hid it. After my primary, I loved the deprojection so much that I didn't really think about the tip much. The protrusions probably became obvious after 6-8 months when the skin started tightening around the cartilage structure.
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
I see. I'm afraid that's what will happen to my nose soon. I am 2 months post op and I feel a stiff cartilage on my right side of the tip. I see it more when my powdered make up falls on it. I truly wish I never did the surgery in the first place but I definitely look forward to a revision now-a-days. I have been hearing great things about Dr.kim. Can you please keep me updated on the results and what exactly was done during the procedure. =] I really look forward to seeing your results. I wish you the very very best.
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
Hmm perhaps it's only noticeable to you? Have you asked a close friend or family member if it was noticeable to them? I kept asking myself how noticeable my irregularities were to other people, until I decided that it bothered me enough to seek a revision...I'm still not sure how many people noticed. Thank you very much for your support. I will keep everyone updated, and I wish you the very best as well!
User Avatar
December 26, 2014
I have... The change from my original to my new nose is quite noticeable. I knew my face couldn't handle a small or narrow nose. Now my nose is too narrow and a little collapsed looking on my left side. Putting these foreign objects in my nose scares me. But, I think I have a strut or something like that in there. I have no clue. I know I went to a great doctor I am just not happy with these result unfortunately. By any chance, did you ask what may have caused that issue? I can't wait to see your results soon. =]
User Avatar
December 26, 2014
Hmm perhaps post pictures? If I look at any given person, I feel like I can imagine them with a much wider or slimmer nose, but I'm sure they can't imagine themselves that way. Maybe the rest of us will find your new nose very appealing on you? Just a thought though. I'm not sure exactly how my bossa was formed, but here are some common reasons: asymmetric domal approximation, domal separation, buckling at the cephalic border (the weak point) and improperly secured tip grafts (from "Revision Rhinoplasty" by Becker and Park, pg 24, available through google books). That book describes the complications that may arise after a primary rhinoplasty (with many pictures). Hope that helps! And I can't wait to see my results too -- but my nose is going to be huge because of all the swelling!
UPDATED FROM clouds90
1 month pre

Consultation

User Avatar
clouds90
The consultation with Dr. Kim went well. He listened to all my questions and explained the procedure in detail with schematic images of the nose. Upon request, he showed me before and after photos of a couple patients with severe bossae. Also, he did 3D morphs, which he later sent to me via email. Dr. Kim's mannerisms and overall attitude was very pleasant and understanding. The staff (Nanette, Natalie and Autumn) were all very nice and patient with me.

Replies (18)

User Avatar
November 21, 2014
Looking forward to your updates! Best of luck to you and thanks so much for sharing your experience and photos with us! May I ask who did your primary?
User Avatar
November 21, 2014
Thanks for the support :). Dr. Zarem did my primary.
User Avatar
November 22, 2014
It's coming up very quickly! I can't wait to see your new nose :) you must be so excited!
User Avatar
November 22, 2014
Thank you!! and yes I am! :) :)
User Avatar
November 23, 2014
am looking forward to seeing your results. It sounds like the consultation was very thorough and the doctor provided a lot of support, such as computer imaging to put you at ease. I am also in the process of getting revision surgery for similar issues. Can you please tell me how your doctor will fix the bossae ? Is he doing a graft ? Thank you and good luck with the surgery!
User Avatar
November 23, 2014
Thank you! Yes, I believe he will be using a strut graft and reconstructing the tip cartilage. I'll post the details of the surgery after I get it done :).
User Avatar
November 23, 2014
Thank you Elisa. I have also been told that a graft will be needed to cover up the cartilage in the tip and give the nose a more smooth appearance. That made me nervous, sounded so complex and involved. The surgeon reassured me that it is not and I shouldn't worry with a graft from my own tissue. Are you going to have closed or open rhinoplasty ? Thanks for all the feedback, so helpful. This was such a huge decision for me to make after 10 years, still nervous about the outcome.
User Avatar
November 23, 2014
It will be open for me (which I prefer). I think that no rhinoplasty surgery is easy, but tip work is especially challenging. Bossa tips are often not an easy fix...especially with thin skin. Grafts will make the nose stronger and will ensure long-term success. I hope our surgeries turn out well!! It was a huge decision for me too.....but I need the confidence boost. I want to feel more positive about myself while I'm alive. :)
User Avatar
November 23, 2014
I am glad we were able to share our experience, since we have similar cases. I also said I need to do this now while I am young!
User Avatar
January 1, 2015
I also had grafts to smooth everything out under my thin skin. You're ahead of me in the recovery game...do you have any advice or tips on swelling in the first few days? My nose feels like it is going to burst under the cast and tape.
User Avatar
January 1, 2015
Hmm my nose didn't swell that much under the cast (there was a bit of room between the flanks of the cast and my nose), but I avoided any added salt, ate anti-inflammatory foods, rubbed bromelain/msm gel under my eyes, slept upright and kept the room cool (so that my face was chilly rather than flushed). I didn't end up icing much, although it seems to help a lot of people. I'm sure you're fluent in the procedure and the rest is just time.... Best wishes and take care!
User Avatar
January 1, 2015
Also I would sneeze with my mouth instead of my nose (sounds weird...but somehow possible?).
User Avatar
January 2, 2015
Hmm, all good advice! I haven't had any salt since my surgery, but the room I'm in is rather warm. I am sleeping propped up in the corner of a couch and drinking lots of water, but my cast is verrry tight and taped over that in addition, and I feel like my nose is just pressing against the cast from the inside. I suppose every nose is different! This is such a fun process to learn about. Thanks for your input!
User Avatar
January 2, 2015
Indeed! Every nose is different. I hope the rest of your healing goes smoothly. Can't wait to see the cast off :).
March 20, 2015
This is all very helpful -- I've been reading your discussion, as I am considering having the procedure and mine is almost exactly as yours. This is such helpful information! Thank you so much for sharing this detail and your pics!!
User Avatar
November 24, 2014
I like how the consult was thorough. I hope you have a successful revision. I am excited to follow your journey.
December 11, 2014
I am very excited for you!!! Can't wait to see your results! !
User Avatar
December 11, 2014
Thank you so much!! I am also very excited!!!
UPDATED FROM clouds90
1 day post

Day after my surgery

User Avatar
clouds90
Hi everyone! Yesterday was my big day! I have to admit I was insanely nervous (both the night before and the morning of my surgery), but the staff at the surgery center were so cheerful and comforting that I started to feel better.

Dr. Kim was very reassuring, confident and realistic (reminding me that my nose will not be perfect). He listened to my concerns and desires. We agreed that if there was enough septal cartilage, to go ahead and insert thin spreader grafts and reduce the height by a couple mm, but if there wasn't enough septal cartilage to just fix the tip.

Upon waking up, Dr Kim told me that there was plenty septal cartilage, so he inserted the thin spreader grafts and reduced the height. He showed me photos of my nose right after surgery (without the cast) and from what I remember they looked great.

Alicia, a lady recommended by Dr. Kim's office, took amazing care of me at my hotel. She was genuinely concerned for my physical and mental state, and told me comforting stories. I had no nausea or discomfort after I got to my hotel.

Today, I feel pressure in my nose... Other than that, I feel well. No bruising or swelling. Mentally, I'm also feeling quite positive. Just watching movies and eating soft food :).

Unfortunately, I forgot my camera-computer cord at home, so I won't post photos until I get back in a week (not like there's much to see anyway). Thanks for all your support and I will keep you updated!

Replies (16)

User Avatar
December 23, 2014
Glad to hear that everything went well and your recovery is going great. I am excited to see your results!
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
Same here! Kee us posted.
User Avatar
December 25, 2014
Today I woke up with a bad headache...otherwise doing fine. I'm starting to see that my nose is going to be huge when the cast comes off and that I need to be prepared for lots of swelling..... I just hope that after a month the swelling will only be noticeable to me.
User Avatar
December 29, 2014
I'm glad you are safely out of anesthesia and I'm do hoping your healing is swift. Keep drinking water and relaxing. I'll be checking on you!!
User Avatar
December 29, 2014
Thank you so much!! I'll update everyone in a couple days with photos.
December 29, 2014
Thank you for sharing your story. Please keep us posted!
User Avatar
December 29, 2014
I will! :)
December 29, 2014
Thank you so much and best wishes on your recovery.
User Avatar
December 30, 2014
Hi Elisa! I'm thinking of you as I prepare for my surgery and how strong you've been through this revision. I'm hoping your results are beautiful and that you're recovering well! How are you feeling?
User Avatar
December 30, 2014
Thanks so much! I had my cast and splints removed today. Although swollen, I really like what my nose looks like so far, so I'm feeling quite positive! :) I'll be thinking about you too! Good luck!!
December 30, 2014
Happy healing :) get lots if rest. I hope your nose will look amazing!
User Avatar
December 30, 2014
Thanks so much! Cast off today and so far so good :). I'll post photos soon!