Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Deeply Regret Surgery. Richmond, BC

ORIGINAL POST

I had rhinoplasty several years ago and regret it...

SS53421
I had rhinoplasty several years ago and regret it every day. I went to this doctor who being young and naive was my only consult and the only surgeon i saw. I went in for a minor bump removal and for my tip to be raised slightly. In hindsight there were many red flags that i missed. The surgeon did not discuss with me exactly what was to be done but made me believe it was routine surgery and that he could give me the results i want. I was also rushed at the consult, my total consult lasted about 15minutes.

When the cast came off i was in complete shock, i could no longer recognize myself in the mirror and began to have panic attacks. He removed way too much of my bump leaving me with a scooped out bridge and removed all of my lower lateral cartilages leaving me with a rounded bulbous tip that is isolated from the rest of the nose and also pinched above the nostrils. When i went to my follow up this doctor was not helpful, when i told him this was not what i asked and said i only wanted very little removed he acted like it looked fine and when i started to cry tried to rush me out of the room so he could take the next patient.

I believe that just as important as being a skilled surgeon is how you treat your patients when they are unhappy with the outcome. It was even more difficult because the surgeon refused to acknowledge the mistake. I went to see a top revision specialist later who told me he could not do my tip for fear it would collapse, he told me the lower lateral cartilages should not have been removed and for that reason he could not help me.

I also want to add that the secretary is extremely helpful and friendly when you book a consult with him and pay your money. If you are unhappy with the outcome and want to see him to try and get it fixed she is an entirely different person. She actually hung up on me telling me there is nothing he could do for me. I feel like something was also done to my radix which is not in the report i wanted to consult with him on this as i can feel that there is some type of graft there, but she refused to allow me to see him and hung up on my three times.

Please do your research, this is your face and you have to live with your decision for the rest of your life. Do your research and go to the most skilled surgeon who is at the top of his field who has won numerous awards also ensure the surgeon spends a lot of time with you during the consult and does not make you feel rushed.

If you have already had surgery from him and are happy with your result than i am very happy for you. This was no my experience at all I felt like he was not invested in me and did not care about the outcome. Also i believe just as important is the way you are treated after your surgery especially when you are dissatisfied with the result you need to believe your surgeon will be there for you and will try to help you fix the problem. It is very devastating after a bad result when you have no other options and no one to turn to for help because the person who did this to you refuses to help you.

SS53421's provider

J. Andrew Bartlett, MD, FRCS

J. Andrew Bartlett, MD, FRCS

Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

0

Replies (9)

August 24, 2015
:( I feel so bad for u. I know how u feel, nothing worse than feeling alone with a bad nose surgery and not getting answers. Who was the revision specialist u consulted with to get a second opinion?
August 25, 2015
PM me and I'll tell you. It was one of the top revision specialists in Manhattan. I did a lot of research this time and was ready to put this all behind me but unfortunately he couldn't even help me with the mess I am left with.
User Avatar
August 26, 2015

Thank you for sharing your experience on RealSelf!

August 27, 2015
It's just awful what still goes on in this field with over-resection of cartilage and I'm sorry this happened to you as well. I would not be discouraged by one doc saying it could not be fixed, try to get other opinions from surgeons who do nose reconstruction.
August 27, 2015
Thank you for your response. I'm trying hard not to lose hope but it's really difficult. I am considering flying out to consult with two other specialists but am so worried they will turn me down too. The first surgeon said he could help me until he saw me in person.
August 27, 2015
Wow, so sorry that you experienced a bad outcome plus non-existing aftercare! It sounds like he and his staff treated you very poorly. I'm glad that you posted this review so that others are aware of your experience. I know that you are in Canada, but if you are willing to travel I believe it would be worth it to check out Dr. Richard Davis in Florida and Dr. Thomas Le in Baltimore. Both docs are known for reconstructive work on challenging cases. Many blessings to you dear! And please don't give up hope.
October 12, 2015
Don't give up hope Hun, you need to get your mojo back and come out of this stronger. Research the surgeons mentioned in this message (great message btw, very supportive).
August 30, 2015
Thank-you for sharing this review. What doctor did you see for your revision?
UPDATED FROM SS53421

Listen to your gut

SS53421
I have had people private message me who have had surgery with this doctor and are very unhappy with the results..or are having anxiety about surgery with him. All I can say is if you are having anxiety please listen to your gut ..please do not let his secretary talk you into something you do not want to do. Once the surgery is done you are on your own they will not care if you are happy or not. If you even have an ounce of doubt ..cancel your surgery. You can always postpone
Surgery but you can not reverse what's been done.

This is your face ..do your research and go to the best surgeon you can find..or better yet try to be happy with what you have..their are too many risks and complications with this surgery

Replies (6)

September 6, 2015
you are brave. thank-you for posting this. more people should be speaking out about this doctor. you are not alone.
October 4, 2016
SS53421 I'm very sorry this happened to you. Sound like you have similar problem that I have, exept I never wanted a rhinoplasty but the doctor removed my hump and narrowed my bridge while I was under anestesia without my permission.

Now I have scooped down bridge and bulbous, maybe saddle nose tip. I'm looking for a revision. Did you find someone to help with your case yet?
April 11, 2017
That's my problem. I tried toncancel 3 times. Even morning of surgery ....was so anxious panicked and they convinced me to stay. Regret it. Had no idea what they were doing
May 31, 2017
this is so true.
May 19, 2019
Hi SS53421, did you ever get around to having a revision?