Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Revision Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Consultation review: Eric M. Joseph Consultation for Revision Rhino - Orange, NJ

ORIGINAL POST

I met with Eric M Joseph for a revision...

Rhinox2
$150
I met with Eric M Joseph for a revision rhinoplasty consultation. He has such rave reviews on his skills along with his bedside manner, he was the first I wanted to see. All I can speak of at this point is my first impression of him, there are a few less than stellar reviews on here that get lost within the positives (like all good surgeons). But I wanted to write this because I agree with some of the comments that aren't praising him. I'm sure he's a nice guy and a good surgeon but I did not particularly enjoy his beside manner. First off when I was greeted in the office and asked to pay $150 consult fee they told me they only take cash or check. I could be wrong, but I DO NOT recall being told this on the phone. I took the day off, spent 15 hours traveling from MA just to see him, this was a big deal and I was incredibly organized... I don't think I would have overlooked a detail like that. They let me pay with a credit card because I didn't have a check or $150 cash but they did it somewhat reluctantly and seemed semi annoyed.
When Dr. Joseph walked in the room he didn't introduce himself, didn't shake my hand, immediately sat down made a comment about my hair and started reading my post operative report ignoring me. It was kind of awkward, I was just sitting there waiting for him to say something for a good 5 minutes. I'm not a nervous or shy person but I would imagine this would not be a good first impression for some people. Then abruptly asks me to tell him what my issues are, (which is fine, it's why I was there). But again, there was no "hello nice to meet you", nothing. It caught me off guard to start talking about something very personal and a huge source of insecurity of mine when he had done nothing to even earn my trust or make me feel comfortable in his presence.
Go into another room for photo imaging and while yes that's a nice tool, a 12 year old could have done this same imagining with photoshop, I wasn't overly impressed. I was really trying to talk to him about some of my concerns and questions and felt he was kind of steam rolling me, talking over me. I actually stopped mid sentence at one point because he wasn't looking me in the eyes, engaging with me, or listening - is how it came across. He seemed sort of A.D.D, rushing, distracted, would cut me off while I was talking. I felt he was kind of blowing my concerns off. He made a comment about my old nose looking like a beak, and how he could definitely improve it because he couldn't make it look any worse. These comments didn't offend me but they weren't exactly sensitive. Then he sort of abruptly gets up and says I'll go talk to the front desk woman about pricing, etc. I felt sort of rushed out of there. I asked if I would see him again or if this was the end of our appointment. He said I'd see him again (which I didn't), but then he took my hand and said he would walk me into the next room, while calling me his love.. It was embarrassing. Some reviewers seem to find his personality charming, I thought his singing, calling me his love, holding my hand and talking to me in a condescending voice like I was a child was unprofessional and a turn off. I also am an atheist so I didn't really enjoy the few times he talked about church, praying, God, etc. Then once I was in the room to discuss pricing it was, "these are the papers to sign, if you want to move forward it will be $10-$12,500. I had to ask them about their financing options etc, how things worked, nothing was brought up or explained to me. Overall I didn't really enjoy his personality or the experience. And I'm not sure how I feel about the permanent filers he pushes either. He wants to have your permission to inject you after surgery if results could be improved. Id rather have a surgeon handle it confidently not needing to use permanent fillers. He may be a great surgeon, but I need to feel 200% confident moving forward with this since I already have the issues/shame of not doing this right the first time and those regrets. Sorry for the long review but I wanted to support a few of the people on here with similar comments.

Rhinox2's provider

Eric M. Joseph, MD

Eric M. Joseph, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 627 Reviews
PROFILE

Replies (16)

June 23, 2016
Don't do it. If he doesn't have the decency to treat you humanely, forget it. Not worth it. Find a more caring doctor.
June 24, 2016
Totally. I absolutely wouldn't. I have another consult next month with Spencer Cochran.. We will see. Thanks for reading.
June 25, 2016
Wish you the best!
April 5, 2021
How was your consultation with spencer Cochran?
July 15, 2016
Hi there,
You will know when you find "your" surgeon, go with your instincts.
As for the fillers, I found this article on Torumi's website, I thought I should share with you and anyone else who wants to know more about filers. "Nasal injectible fillers causing damage". I stayed away from all the doctor mentioning about this easy "fix".
http://www.deantoriumi.com/issue1-1.asp
User Avatar
July 17, 2016
I agree, I would absolutely stay away from anyone who is so quick to use fillers.
June 16, 2017
Commenting on an old review here lol but never know who is reading it (like me!). I noticed Dr Joseph REALLY pushes Silikon 1000 like nobodies business which I find really suspect. Ultimately one of the reasons I decided not to even bother with a consult.
September 11, 2016
Wow.... It was like reading my own review of him, that is exactly what happened when I went to visit Dr. Joseph.... I don't ever recall them telling me they only take checks, and I drove about as many hours as you did and they reluctantly took my credit card because I wasn't recalling anything about "cash only." I will say that when Dr. Joseph came into the exam room, he greeted me and shook my hand, and was very personable. But, I definitely didn't get the warm and fuzzy front desk that everyone else has praised his practice about.... I ended up not going with Dr. Joseph because I wasn't as comfortable with him as I was with Dr. D, or Dr. Glasgold. I really am praying for excellent results when you go for surgery with Dr. Glasgold, he is such an amazing person, and he really seems to know what he is doing. I kind of wish I had gone to him instead of Dr. D, but I really believed Dr. D could fix ALL my concerns.... I still like Dr. D, I think he is a great surgeon, I am just not happy with my results... I have seen results much better than mine that he has performed, and perhaps I was believing if he can fix some of those complicated cases, mine would be a breeze? I think I may have over simplified my understanding of this whole process!! Anyway, I sure hope you keep us posted on your surgery, and if there's anything I can do to help just let me know! I am so happy to hear you chose Dr. Glasgold, and i am excited to hear how it all turns out for you!!
September 12, 2016
Yes he sings the ENTIRE time during consultations. He talks about other random things. I paid with my card and they didn't say a word about only cash or check.... I didn't like him either and didn't proceed forward