Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Almost a year post-op... still unhappy

ORIGINAL POST

My surgery is scheduled for November 16th, 2011 -...

HBgirl
$6,275

My surgery is scheduled for November 16th, 2011 - exactly six weeks from today. I'm very nervous, but have recently told my family about my decision and they have been overwhelmingly supportive!

My nose is just big. It's got a bulbous tip and it just doesn't fit my face. I'm 28 years old and I feel like my face should be a lot softer.. a lot prettier. My nose throws everything off.

I liked my plastic surgeon, but has has recommended closed rhinoplasty (predicting 1.5 hours in surgery). The more I'm reading on it, I'm starting to get nervous and wondering if this is the right procedure for me (vs. open). Sure, I hear 'closed' is less invasive and you can heal faster, which is great, but I think my biggest fear is to go through all of this, pay all this money, take all of this time off of work.. and not be happy with my results. I've got a call into the office to address some of my questions... But I would to hear from anyone who has had a closed procedure done and their opinion!

Beyond that, I'm afraid of what my co-workers will think. I work for a very conservative school district. That fear is slightly diminishing as I'm reading more and more that usually, people can tell something is different about you, but can't quite put your finger on it.

In the end, I'm anticipating natural results with loads of new confidence! Will post pictures of me now (before) soon!

HBgirl's provider

Jed H. Horowitz, MD, FACS

Jed H. Horowitz, MD, FACS

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

4.9 | 143 Reviews
PROFILE

HBgirl rating for Dr. Horowitz:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (5)

October 6, 2011
Hi, I've also just had closed rhino and also had the same questions. I think it has a lot to do with how the doctor was trained, how experienced they are and if they feel that they can get results using either of these 2 options. I also wanted my bolbous tip reduced as this was my main concern and discussed that I wasn't sure that closed surgery could fix this. I got to see slot of pictures and spoke to a lot of doctors and have come to the conclusion that the doctors expertise will make the difference regarding your nose not the technique.
October 6, 2011
Thanks Pjbis.. Do you have before and after photos? If not, I understand. It's hard to find before and after photos with a bolbous tip issue - Most photos I have seen are hump reductions, and that isn't really my issue.
October 6, 2011
Best of luck to you!! The countdown begins...
User Avatar
October 7, 2011

Aw, your little guy is so cute!

Here's some information about closed versus open rhinoplasty. Definitely do discuss your concerns with your surgeon. You want to go into this being completely on the same page.

I hope you'll come back and let us know how it goes!

User Avatar
October 8, 2011
i had closed but i think it really depends on what you are getting done... if you think your procedure is going to be more invasive i would prob opt for open... mine was pretty minimal but if i would have done my HOMEWORK and read open vs. closed and had given the choice...i prob would have just gone with the open surgery....
UPDATED FROM HBgirl
20 days pre

Surgery is 3 weeks away and I had another...

HBgirl
Surgery is 3 weeks away and I had another consultation last week with my surgeon to help ease my mind and answer loads of new questions I came up with.

Not sure how, but I heard "closed" during my first consult, but I will actually be having open surgery. My doctor showed me my charts and that was the plan all along.. I don't know how 'closed' got stuck in my head. This actually makes me happy... after lots of research and knowing that my tip needs some work, I was glad to hear his reasoning behind the open surgery.

I'm still very nervous. I really hope I'm making the right decision and that I'll be happy with the results. I'm starting to question if I should have consulted with more surgeons, but I think I'm just getting cold feet because I really do like and trust the surgeon I chose.

I'm having a hard time kicking my 3-5 cigarettes a day.. Doc told me to stop at least 4 weeks before surgery.. and here we are, less than 3 weeks away, and I can't seem to kick the horrible habit. I need to get serious.. I don't want anything to delay my healing.

I appreciate this forum and all the support. Next update will probably be after my surgery!

Replies (1)

User Avatar
October 27, 2011
Hi there! I had septorhinoplasty about a month ago by Dr. Elam in orange county. I was really worried before my surgery as well.... about down time, bruising etc & I wanted it to be a very subtle change, not too drastic! I had an open procedure, I am EXTREMELY happy with my results already & it has only been a month! It only took about a week for my noticable swelling to go down & I had barely any bruising that went away quickly as well.. It was a breeze! I also had to quit smoking- it is difficult but SO important for you to do so at least 2 weeks before surgery for recovery purposes. Read Allen Carr's " Easy way to quit smoking" It helped so many of my loved ones quit & myself as well = )
UPDATED FROM HBgirl
16 days pre

Looking for any input on those who have had...

HBgirl
Looking for any input on those who have had surgery and caring for children afterward. I have a son who is almost two and worried about recovery and caring for a energy-filled little boy. Luckily, I will have help for five days - just wondering if the 6th day after surgery would be safe timing to be active with my little one, again. Of course, I know to watch for accidental nose-bops! Doctor said I should be ok to lift him (30 lbs) in and out of the car, etc.. I'm just wondering if anyone has input on what they did in this case? Also, I'm worried about scaring him (by face being bandaged/casted) after surgery... but I can't just lock myself in a room for a week and not see my sweet little boy! Any suggestions? Thanks for all the support and advice!

Replies (2)

October 31, 2011
Thanks for the tips. My surgery is in two weeks and three days, and this weekend, I only had three cigarettes (the whole weekend!)... hoping to have NONE starting today! Thanks for the advice and support!
User Avatar
October 31, 2011
Get that book girl! If not just 4 your surgery..... read it during your recovery time to quit 4 good ; )