Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

horrible scarring - Livingston, NJ

ORIGINAL POST

Had an eye lift and wound up with giant long scars...

User Avatar
blonde54
$4,999
Had an eye lift and wound up with giant long scars at each outer aspect of my eyes. it aged me and looks like crows feet! HORRIBLE SURGERY! I have bat wing scars! AWFUL self conscious, from a terrible job. When I asked why I had these awful stitched up eyes I got no answer. Doctors who have no real PLASTIC skills should not make promises about their expertise. I am pissed to this day every time I look at my eyes. Built on CROWS FEET from a bad surgery.

blonde54's provider

Janet M. Neigel, MD

Janet M. Neigel, MD

Oculoplastic Surgeon, Board Certified in Ophthalmology

blonde54

blonde54 rating for Dr. Neigel:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (4)

User Avatar
October 31, 2016

Thank you for sharing your experience. Hoping you find support in the community.

October 31, 2016
You said it.!! I too had a dr with NO aesthetic or plastic surgery skills when it came to my lower eye lid surgery. Filling my tear troughs full of fat, not seeing where cheeks start and stop, where lower eyes are completely FLAT for if francis johns did not remove my pretarsal then he tightened lower lid to making it so flat with no contour, saying he thinks he did a great job. Well if this is so great i like to see him do it to himself or his family member making rhem look like freaks. Then having no remorse , asking me not to come back and to find another dr after he damaged me, but he's got his $8,000 for the WORSE eye job. Butchered like me, i am so sorry for you. Like me we got to live the rest of our lives mangled with bad plastic surgery results. There ought to be laws for us victims
User Avatar
October 31, 2016
just warn others....! best to you...!
November 1, 2016
Yes. Not only did I ended up with unrealistic, unnatural eyes I wasn't treated right after I told of my unsatisfactory outcome, francis johns did not know how to deal with the botched job that he had his secretary call me asking that i find another surgeon, for my check had cleated and if he tried helping then it would dip into the money I paid him. I'm not the only one who was treated this way, I found 3 others who have the same story. Eyes, boob, facial scars, stomach so it's not only the eyes but all over
User Avatar
November 4, 2016
oh my get an attorney class action lawsuit
November 4, 2016
plastic surgeons are too protected, however there are 3 of us who all had horror stories on different body parts done by francis johns. something will happen. thank you
October 3, 2018
Thank you for sharing. I hope he will take responsibility and have the decency to either pay on your behalf a competent surgeon to perform a revision or pay for damages. If I made an irreversible mistake at my job I am positive I will be standing at the unemployment line. Why a physician shouldn't take responsibility like everyone else? The problem with incompetent physicians is their lack of modesty and understanding of their limit. Not everyone can actually perform this type of surgeries, and it's ok they can do something else instead of ruining the life of other people .
May 12, 2017
my eyes are so badly scared from Sherwood Baxt (Paramus NJ) Stay away from him!
May 14, 2017
Good lord!
UPDATED FROM blonde54
11 years post

still scarred after 10 years

User Avatar
blonde54
please do not go anyone not board certified in plastic surgery! my eue scars from this shoddy slap job on my eyes make me look like I have crows feet teaching to my ears!

Replies (3)

User Avatar
May 23, 2018
I just did an eye lift as well. I am nervous about the possibility of visible scars. Have you tried any laser resurfacing to minimize the scar?
User Avatar
September 27, 2018
no but its too far gone
October 1, 2018
I have lumps and atrophy from a double board-certified surgeon, dropped me after two months and revision surgery now I’m wearing an eyepatch and contacts