Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER V Line Surgery REVIEWS

V-Line At Regen is Not Worth It

ORIGINAL POST

CONSULTATION + SURGERY DAY I want to begin this...

searchingforcute
$7,700
CONSULTATION + SURGERY DAY
I want to begin this review by saying that I actually plan on uploading a Youtube video on my experience at Regen. I've seen lots of sponsored surgery reviews done by social media influencers with thousands of fans, but I've barely seen any reviews posted by average-Joe's like myself.
I'm a 25 yr old mixed black/white woman from the United States.
I chose Regen for two reasons, the first one being Dr. Oh's huge success on Korean television. The second reason was the fact that I had seen more positive reviews about their practice when compared to clinics like ID and Wonjin.
I contacted Jina through Line app and immediately mentioned the most important key detail of this entire journey: I wanted to make my -chin- less square. I had no intentions of changing my jawline as it was already extremely slim. I simply needed the "v" shape in my chin.
I wen't through the process of putting down a deposit (you're offered a percentage off if you send money ahead of time and write an honest review afterward) and booked my trip to South Korea.
Fast forward to consultation day. You're not allowed to eat/drink 12 hours before surgery.
Everything happens very quickly. You have an hour or so to take x-rays, bloodwork, and fill out paperwork. Jina was present for the whole thing, guiding me through the process. (She was definitely very friendly and sweet.) Finally, I was allowed a chance to talk to Dr. Oh. I showed him a before/after photo of what I wanted my chin to look like (something I whipped up in photoshop) and made sure the emphasize the importance of changing the chin.
He had examined my x-rays. He mentioned my face was already asymmetrical and would do the best he could to work with the shape. He also brought up that he would have to do v-line (rather than mini v-line) to achieve the small "v" shaped chin I longed for. V-line involves removing some jaw bone as opposed to mini v-line where they only cut/shave the chin.
Now, like I mentioned earlier, I'm an average-Joe. The intricate details of plastic surgery will always be a mystery to me. The way Dr. Oh explained things, he left me with the impression that I wouldn't have the chin shape I wanted unless he removed some jaw bone.
Side note, I came into this meeting expecting this suggestion.
Another user on this forum mentioned this sort of up-sale during her consultation as well (even though several other clinics told her a mini-vline would be fine.) She seemed semi-happy with the result so I wasn't particularly bothered by the Oh's suggestion.
I figured "Hey, he's a doctor. Surely he wouldn't recommend this unless he thought he couldn't get the job done without it."
V-line is in fact more expensive than mini v-line. I took a leap of faith and agreed to let him cut off some of the jaw-bone as well. As long as it meant my chin wouldn't be so box-y and square. (He then wen't on to explain to me how is methods would decrease the risk of sagging, another important factor in my decision on going with him.)
Next thing I know, I'm in a hospital gown being prepped for surgery.
You don't feel anything. They put you out with general anesthesia and you wake up 1-2 hours later. The worst part of recovery is probably the first couple of hours. I couldn't really swallow, and when I did, my throat felt dry and tight. I had tape wrapped around my chin and jaw (I guess to hold everything in place as I healed). The skin between my gums and bottom lip was stitched up and my entire face was swollen/puffy.
I didn't sleep the first night (and only night) they kept me in the hosptial. I kept spitting up bloody mucus (saliva production is ridiculous) and it felt like I'd choke on my own tongue if I laid back a bit too far.I stayed in an upright position on my phone for most of the night. I had a nurse checking on me every once in a while. You're suppose to use an icepack on your chin/jaw area to help reduce swelling, but for some reason I think the nurse forgot to tell me where/how to get icepacks. I finally had access to one closer to the morning when she showed me where the freezer was.
Morning was a bit better. I was finally able to have a sip of water. It didn't go down easy, but it helped with the dry feeling.
I was sent back to my hotel with a prescription for medicine (I'm assuming anti-biotics), mouth-wash to keep my stitches clean, pain killers, an icepack, and aftercare instructions.
The next few days were a rollercoaster. The extreme swelling really distorts any concept you might have about what your face is going to look like. It felt like my face was changing shape every hour!
You're also unable to eat solid food, so I stuck with a lot of drinkable yogurt and porridge.
I wasn't bedridden. Walking is actually encouraged, so I spent most of my days cycling between keeping up with medicine, using the prescribed deswelling methods, and exploring South Korea.
WEEKS 1+2
Everyday, my swelling was going down. Little by little.
Now, one thing I must say that I immediately recognized is that Dr.Oh took off A LOT of my jaw-bone.
As the swelling went down (and after seeing x-rays at my 1-week post-op appointment with Jina) it was immediately obvious that he took off as much as he could (ultimately having to stop where the nerves on my jaw began). I'm indifferent about this (and I might be inclined to say he removed too much?) as the jaw was not my concern in the first place. I have some salivary gland swelling that may be permanent (and it's certainly accentuated by the reduced jaw-line.) It is still asymmetrical (something he warned of beforehand). So I guess if you're looking to correct your jaw, Regen might be a good choice for you. That's undeniable.
I also noticed (after viewing the post-op x-rays) that he didn't use the t-osteotomy cut I thought would be necessary to address a square chin. That's...worrying.
With this deswelling, I became increasingly confused about the chin area.
My husband said my chin appeared to be just as wide, long, and square-shaped. (He jokingly asks if I even had any work done lol) I had to agree. Worried, I ended up scheduling a meeting with Oh since he wasn't present at the 1-week appointment. He re-assured me that everything was -still swollen- and that I would need to wait at least 6 months to see how things shape up. (He also mentioned that botox shots to reduce chin muscle would be a solution if my chin still appeared square. I'm honestly not sure if this would work.)
Just before the two-week mark, I have an appointment for lazer treament (It was not explained to me how it works, but apparently the lazers help reduce swelling??). Then, on the two-week mark, I have an appointment for stitch removal. It didn't hurt that bad and simply felt like somebody pinching my gums with their fingernails.
I once again express my concerns with Dr.Oh about the current "square" shape of my chin. In all honesty, even now, it looks exactly the same as my pre-op chin. He once again reassures me that it's swelling and that I should wait. (He also recommends botox shots again. I'm definitely getting a second opinion in the US if it comes to that.)
We'll see how this goes. I'm trying to have faith that the chin will become more "v"-shaped by the end of the journey. What do you guys think? I've attached two before photos and one marked "After".
It would be a bit weird (and expensive) to have had a surgery where none of my actual concerns were addressed properly. I'll keep you all updated and post again when the Youtube video is up!

searchingforcute's provider

Myung June Oh, MD

Myung June Oh, MD

Plastic Surgeon

searchingforcute rating for Dr. Oh:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times
Myung June Oh, MD
Response from Dr. Oh:
Hello. Thank you for the review. I am also unhappy that you didn't get the results you wanted. However because there is misinformation in your review, I have decided to leave a comment. I thoroughly checked your CT scans and found there to be no nerve damage at all. I think it would make sense to share photos as evidence here if you plan to do harm to a Doctor's reputation. And about our consultation being short, if a patient is very sure about what he or she wants, it can be shorter than most.

Replies (29)

May 27, 2018
I also had surgery at Regen with a different doctor and am still depressed about my rhinoplasty :( I wish that I had at least come out looking around the same like you did, instead of looking much much worse than pre-op. Anyway, keep us updated about your healing/de-swelling.
June 21, 2018
I'm sorry you're going through that. Hopefully an American doctor can give you the natural look you desire. I see you're looking into revision so there is hope!
June 21, 2018
Thank you! I see you're also looking into a revision for your chin but honestly you look lovely already. Square chins look good on a lot of people, i.e. Margot Robbie who is GORGEOUS :) The Korean plastic surgery aesthetic is so narrow-minded honestly. Have you considered just getting some filler to see how a sharp chin would look on you? I think idols like EXID's Hani probably do that?
May 30, 2018
Absolute perfect! I have a visible v-shaped chin, I would have loved to look like you. Excellent work done.
June 21, 2018
I disagree but thank you!
February 16, 2019
Can I plegase see your pics? I was seriously considering this surgeon until now... :/
June 5, 2018
You don't have any photos of before and after that have your face directly facing the camera in the tilt angle. It's currently impossible to tell if he reduced your chin by a few mm.

From the photos provided your ramus bone doesn't go down as much though. Your chin also looks a tiny bit softer looking.
June 5, 2018
You do look very good and it's a subtle change but one for the better I think. Your chin doesn't look square to me. It looks in the middle of oval and diamond shaped. Your lower face looks great. I'm a straight guy, trust me. :)
June 7, 2018
Did he not do a T osteotomy for your chin to narrow it?
June 21, 2018
He did not.
June 16, 2018
a better picture angle would help, your post op chin looks pretty good. I need a jaw reduction revision, will you recommend him?
June 21, 2018
I'm not sure I can recommend him yet as I am currently not satisfied with my own work.
UPDATED FROM searchingforcute
1 month post

5 Weeks

searchingforcute
(I've included photos of my current chin and more bone-work)
A lot of the numbness that came directly after surgery is disappearing slowly. I sense feeling in my chin again but the gums are still quite numb.
Mouth movement has improved a lot. My smile is becoming less and less weird and mouth movements are becoming less strained. I can open my mouth at about two/two and a half fingers now and I can whistle again.
Swelling under the chin and neck area has improved but I’m hoping it tightens up more. The muscle and salivatory glands there have been more noticeable since surgery but I don’t think it’s a double chin.
Chin is still square :sad: once again that was my only area of concern. Not the jaw.
It still hasn’t changed shape (and in fact has gotten more square with subtle deswelling)
I’m praying it’ll improve with time.
Edit:
I should mention that I’ve spoken to two clinics about revision. Cookie and TL. TL has a chance to see my x-rays and told me it was possible to sculpt a softer/smaller chin.

Replies (8)

June 24, 2018
i think it looks really good, and you're not even fully healed.
the enemy of good is perfect.
July 2, 2018
I'll be honest..I'm sorry but I don't really see a significant difference.
August 27, 2018
Same. I'm pretty disappointed.
October 12, 2018
Where re the photos?
October 12, 2018
Removed for privacy. I had them uploaded until swelling subsided (and things went south). Sorry. I might re-upload once I’ve had my revision/repair surgery.
October 12, 2018
But the bad result is very important to show! It would be a gift and may stop someone from going to that surgeon or even declining the surgery.
October 12, 2018
I understand what you're getting at. But if "The doctor cut above my nerve-line" isn't enough to stop somebody, I don't think before/after photos will either. I'm having revision surgery in mid-November. I'll upload everything then.
October 12, 2018
Good luck and best wishes!!!
UPDATED FROM searchingforcute
3 months post

4 Month Mark - Chin is Still Big + Over Resection of Mandible :(

searchingforcute
So some time has passed since my surgery.

I don't think I have anymore swelling - At least that's what other doctors are telling me.

Chin is still about the same shape and width. But that's not the only issue I'm having now. As the swelling disappeared, I began to see just how much of my jawline was removed.

Now the jawline looks immensely unnatural. My salivary glands are not swollen like I initially believed - they've simply been exposed by over-resection of the mandible. A few other doctors have taken a look and agreed - the jawline shave was unnecessary. My pre-op jaw was already slim.

Like I mentioned in my first post, I wouldn't have done the mandible reduction if I knew the doctor was going to remove all of my bone UP TO MY TEETH. And I especially wouldn't have done it if I knew it wasn't going to help contour my chin (as I was lead to believe.)

The reduction has also given me a short lower face (my chin height is the same as my top lip...not good) and the close-cut to my nerve line is going to make it difficult to revise this job safely.

Regen is telling me to use injections to shrink the chin muscle still (???) but I'm positive that won't solve anything. When I pinch the skin down around my chin, the bone still remains the same - proportionally large compared to the rest of my jaw.

When I questioned whether or not Regen had implants available to correct over-resection, nobody really wants to help guide me toward that direction. (I don't expect much anyway, none of these doctors are skilled in custom mandible angle implants.) Instead - I'm told to simply shrink the salivary glands. I'm not being offered any solutions to the actual issues I'm having.

I'm still completely numb on the left side of my chin. No big improvements yet.

As for sagging, I can't answer whether or not I'll experience that as it's only been a few months. Time will tell.

As of now, I'm searching for a Maxillofacial doctor that specializes in custom implants for my jaw-line. I also have to figure out if said doctor is also skilled enough in genioplasty to reverse the 4mm projection Regen gave me and contour the chin the way I originally desired (a round shape rather than square).

Lesson learned - don't accept a doctor that gives 5-10 minute consultations and don't go to Korea for facial surgery. The Before and Afters don't depict the doctors real+ work - and they will not custom tailor v-line procedures for your face (especially if you don't have typically Asian features)

Replies (3)

April 13, 2019
I'm sorry to hear that, are you planning on posting some of your pictures?
April 28, 2019
I'm afraid that the lesson you are learning is wrong. There is nothing wrong with facial surgery in Korea. But not every surgeon is skilled in everything. For facial bone sculpting you should always go to a maxillofacial clinic. These surgeries should be performed by a qualified dentist not a general plastic surgeon. Take a look at Dr Oh's profile on real self. A large amount of the procedures he does is in a gray area labeled as "other". Vline and other facial contouring are popular in Korea but it's clear he doesn't specialise in them. But take a profile of any maxillofacial surgeon. Most of the surgeries they do are facial countouring of one kind or another. I would not in fact be suprised if Dr Oh did not know how to do the chin surgery you requested. I thought it was very suspicious that he tried to get you to agree to a v line when you clearly said you just wanted chin surgery. Also, an unskilled doctor cannot tailor a procedure to you because they have little knowledge and skill. This has nothing to do with your race. A skilled maxillofacial surgeon would approach your case with caution and work carefully.
So the lesson to be learnt is go to the right specialist for the procedure you want.
July 19, 2019