Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

Fat Transfer to Breasts, Good procedure, Bad Doctor- avoid Michele Shermak

UPDATED FROM amelia girl
1 year post

This April will be 2 years since my fat transfer to the breasts by Dr.Shermak

amelia girl
$7,800
It took a while for me to notice just how bad the liposuction results were by Dr.Shermak. As time goes on, they get worse & worse. The skin on my legs & buttocks is very old looking (like a 90 year old). It is stretched out & sagging down to my knees with divets, dents, valleys, lumps, ripples and lipo track marks with a bulge of fat from my butt that slid down my leg. My hip is missing a big chunk and I can not wear any form fitting clothes or you see it. Dr. Shermak was nasty & unprofessional when I went to see her about this. She treated me like an animal not a person. I've noticed that my negative reviews of her have disappeared. She now has perfect reviews again. This is very scary b/c this is what we as consumers are believing. There must be a way the doctors are paying to have them removed. My breasts are about the same. A one size increase. While that is nice, I can no longer wear shorts or any clothes that do not touch down to my knees. I am not going to try to "fix it" b/c I've read that it just makes it worse. So I continue to try not to focus on it.

amelia girl's provider

Michele A. Shermak, MD

Michele A. Shermak, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

4.8 | 217 Reviews
PROFILE

amelia girl rating for Dr. Shermak:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (5)

December 7, 2014
Oh man! Amelia, I'm so sorry your lipo gave you such bad results -- or I should say, your bad surgeon gave you such bad results! That said, I'm sure things don't look as bad as you think -- we are all our own worst critics. I hope things calm down a bit in the coming months -- possibly your body may smooth things out? Good luck!
December 11, 2014
I agree. Very scary that the negative comments have been removed
January 12, 2015
Amelia, I just read your profile. Omg! I am so sorry to hear what you have gone through. It's good you've decided not to have a revision with her. My doctor said that he would take care of my issues because I wasn't happy, but he didn't admit there's anything wrong-even tho theres a huge crater on the buttocks/thigh area. So, why would he revise something he feels there's nothing wrong with? I would never let him touch me again. I can't believe we traded one little problem for a huge one. You wanted bigger breasts and I wanted to fill the lines on my face. I'm sure, if given the chance, we would take it all back. I'm going for a consult in Miami next week. I will not have a revision anytime soon, but I want to know what the extent of the damage is. I tried going to surgeons around here and they won't revise another surgeons mistakes. The only one that actually spoke to me was very honest and said that liposuction injuries are very difficult to fix and even when they are, one would never be the same. So, why bother? Well, I just need to know what the extent of my problem is. I have no idea if there are bigger issues than just missing fat or a collapsed buttocks. I hurt a lot and only on that side. The ps, in Miami, is a reconstructive surgeon. Hopefully he can shed some light on my problem. I'll let you know what he said. Again, I'm so sorry for all that you've gone through.
January 12, 2015
Thanks Emi. Good luck with your appointment. Let me know what you find out. Just take your time & really stay present. Trust your instincts.
May 10, 2015
Hello Amelia, it has been a while since I been to my review. I saw your post to me and I came back here to see how you are doing. I don't see any update so I guess not much has changed? As far as me, well, I went to Miami and Mexico and every doctor has told me they can't help me. Mendieta suggested a surgical lift and a thigh lift. Then he told me to leave it alone and that even if I gained 20 lbs I would still not have enough fat to fix all. This was just a couple of months after surgery. Well last month I had consults with 5 doctors in Mexico. I put on about 12-14 lbs for those consults. I got the same response as I did with Mendieta-only this time I did have some weight on. A couple of them said they could barely pinch enough to get about 3-400cc. The rest said no way. I must say that I appreciated their honesty but I had such high hopes. I was told to lose the weight because even if I put on another 10 lbs it still wouldn't have enough. Sorry I'm rambling but being botched it's just awful! I wish RS would have a botched community... Hugs!
November 11, 2015
Please tell us all the follow up; everyone seems to be searching for the same thing--good results
November 11, 2015
Please repost... With pictures and let the act speak or see from itself- why should good or bad tesults be hidden, they are what they are!!!!!!!'
User Avatar
May 5, 2021
Do you have any photos ? Sorry for you bad experience
UPDATED FROM amelia girl
1 year post

Also read realself review by Busybee in Baltimore about Micheler Shermak's horrific treatment of patients

amelia girl
Here I read Busybee's review of Dr. Shermak and it was EXACTLY what I experienced. She was so nasty to Busybee that it caused her anxiety. This is exactly how I felt causing me not to go back for so long about my revision. This is a horrible breach of the Hippocratic oath.

Replies (1)

User Avatar
October 17, 2014
Wow, I'm sorry girl. I just read your earlier post. I'm amazed at how often I hear about doctors discontinuing service with a patient if the patient asks them to fix a mistake. I like my dr, I don't feel that most of my complications were his fault but I do feel like I paid him twice to do my flanks and they barely look any different and now look even worse because they are disproportionately fatter than my stomach. I'm dreading having to bring it up. Especially after reading stuff like this. It is terrible was PS are able to get away with.
October 18, 2014
Thank you for acknowledging this. It stinks that you have to fear dreading it. It should not be like that. The more we file complaints with the medical board about the doctor's conduct, the less they will be able to get away with it. I am finding everyone that has had terrible experiences with Dr. Shermak and asking them to share their story with the MD Medical Board. If they receive enough complaints they do file charges and take action on doctors. I know doctors that it has happened to and they can be reprimanded, given fines and risk losing their license to practice. I hope your issues get resolved with consideration from your doctor.
October 23, 2014
Hi Amelia you are right not to continue with your current PS. Congratulations in not having implants also. I have to say from the photos you look amazing and I'm sure any indentations can be evened out at some point. In the UK I haven't heard of the BRAVA being used at all, it's interesting reading, although after my explant I have enough saggy skin so no worries there. Thanks for posting your story please continue to update and good luck with finding another PS.
October 23, 2014
Thank you Gillvitamin. Yes, I really am way to embarrassed to post all the pics of the dents and valleys & unevenness in my legs and missing chunks of my hips. I did have photos posted for a few hours but I had to take them down. Sorry you have saggy skin after your explant. Are you planning on getting a fat transfer? Are you still happy that you explanted?
October 23, 2014
I'm really happy I've explanted, it was only four weeks ago so I'm still pretty swollen, it's hard to tell what I'll be left with at the moment. I would LOVE to do do the fat transplant it's the way forward, implants are not but I'm quite slim, I'm hoping there will be enough fat for the left side which looks a bit sorry for itself. I had capsules that would have made a good pair of stout walking boots so they came out too. To be honest I've had enough of operations, choosing to go under four times is enough for me so I'd have to really want the fat transfer if it meant a general aenesthetic again.
October 24, 2014
That makes sense. Why did you have 4 operations? What are capsules? Glad you are happy. Take your time. Happy Healing!
UPDATED FROM amelia girl
1 year post

Why not to use Dr.Shermak after another unprofessional consult for revision

amelia girl
I met with Dr.Shermak today about a revision to the hip/buttock area and back of legs. I attached photos (which I will remove soon) so you can see some of what I am talking about. You can see how part of my hip/buttock is missing. She agreed. You can not see in these photos where my legs were oversuctioned. It is hard to get a close up of the dents. So, she decided she could "throw a little fat" into the hips from my stomach and arms where I gained weight. I now weigh between 3-5 lbs more than I did on surgery day, on any given day. But then, she starts going down the typical ps "accusatory road". She tells me that I did not communicate, that I have cellulite, that I must have lymphatic issues & that my legs look fine even though in person they are clearly way different sizes (can't see in photos). She becomes as she was pre surgery- very gruff and nasty. She then tells me that I do not communicate well so she is not going to do the repair. I ask her so what is our resolution to this then since we both agreed that part of my hip is caved in/missing? She says the resolution is nothing, that I can leave. I told her that I need to get this repaired & would she reimburse for part of the fee since she won't repair to have another doctor repair? She says no and that I can get out. She told me that in my profession that I should be able to communicate better and now, she has done nothing wrong. So, I ask for copies of my original photos (which if I knew how to scan & post I would b/c I actually looked really nice). She gives me the photos and walks out. As she is walking out, tells me to go w/her asst to take "after photos". I tell her assistant, "no thanks, my doctor just abandoned my care" & I will file a complaint with the medical board. As soon as I got home, I filed a complaint with the medical board. It is one thing that we sign away our rights to have the work turn out well, that's fine. But, I do not sign away my rights to be treated with professional conduct, not be yelled at, accused and abandoned as a patient. Not to mention, she operated on several areas that were never discussed in our surgical plan. She and many other ps think that they have a free ticket to not be held accountable for their work. I wish I could change her rating on here. Not sure how? I only knocked down her rating a little because I was afraid she would see my reviews and it would effect my aftercare because she is such an angry and nasty doctor. You can also see just from gaining 3-5 lbs how much weight is in my arms. There is also a lot in my upper & lower abs but it is hard to see in these photos. So, a heads up for those considering lipo, that very little weight gain can cause an unattractive weight distribution. That is something I will work on. Because she was so unprofessional, I don't know that I feel I can trust another surgeon to do the repair work as many of them don't want to be responsible or accountable after the fact. Her attitude seemed more about engaging me in an argument so she could throw me out and not have to rectify her work. I honestly don't know how people like her sleep at night. One day, I hope she doesn't make the wrong patient unhappy because her sons are on facebook which easily link to their school and her home address. My resolution is to let the medical board handle her by filing a complaint. Other people may not be as nice as me especially since her personal information is so easily accessed. Unless you want bad lipo, and lots of grief from your doctor, stay far away from Dr. Michele Shermak. She does not abide by the Hippocratic Oath. Sad! Shame on you Dr. Shermak! Shame!

Replies (3)

User Avatar
October 19, 2014
Oh Amelia, I am so very sorry your Dr has behaved so badly to you. Must be extremely distressing. Actually would you really want that woman to touch you? She sounds dangerous and totally unethical. Wishing you luck with finding a surgeon who can help.
October 20, 2014
Thanks Exq. I appreciate you saying that. Yes, I think she is dangerous and your right, it is for the best. Research shows that doctors that display anger with patients have a 70% greater chance of making errors in their work. So, no- all that happens is a sign to stay away. I do have someone in mind if I decide to do this down the road. How are you doing Exq?
December 11, 2014
Thank you for this post . I live in MD as well and just today considered a consult with this Dr. however after reading this post she has been removed from my list of Dr's! This is outrageous
December 11, 2014
TBelize- I am glad it was helpful to you! Best of luck!!
User Avatar
December 11, 2014
So sorry for your experience w this Dr. Although my surgery was completely different , I had similar results. I had a breast reduction surgery w her about 7-10 years ago and feel your pain. I was 5"2 w C cups that were saggy after pregnancy. She insisted that I just simply get a lift but that's not what I wanted. So it seems to me that I didn't do what she said that she gave me awful job. My scars are rather wide and looks like my 2yo could have drawn a more straighter line than this doctor. My areoles were left very large. They didn't match my now smaller breast. And she's suppose to be a "top" doctor. Yes, if you have friends are family members please tell them to avoid this doctor.
December 11, 2014
Wow, thank you Nikkig! I am very sorry to hear of your experience. Dr.Shermak is a disgrace to her profession. She does not follow the Hippocratic oath of do no harm. She is a very angry person who takes out her anger verbally and physically on her patients. I filed a complaint with the medical board. Again, thank you for sharing and I am so very sorry for your experience.