I Just Had Tickle Lipo and I Was in an Incredible Amount of Pain During and After, Is This Normal?

Surgery without appropriate anesthesia is painful not matter what the surgery is. The level of anesthesia you had was obviously not appropriate for the surgery you had. If you were sold on a procedure under local anesthesia as being safer with quicker recovery etc. you were duped, especially if the tickle term was used to make the surgery sound less invasive. It is not normal if the surgeon is fully trained, ethical and empathetic.

I hope you realize that this format of posting questions and receiving answers lacks the face to face direct communication required for you to make an informed decision regarding your surgery.

My response to your question/post does not represent formal medical advice or constitute a doctor patient relationship. You need to consult with i.e. personally see a board certified plastic surgeon in order to receive a formal evaluation and develop a doctor patient relationship.

TIckle Lipo, in the appropriate skilled hands, should be the most comfortable office based lipo procedure.
All awake lipo procedures are done using local anesthesia, otherwise known as tumescent anesthesia. How this anesthesia is administered is the key to keeping you very comfortable. The rotation and vibration of the Tickle cannula should deliver the anesthesia WITHOUT any significant pain. I tell all my patients when I start the procedure, you will notice three things during anesthesia; you will feel the vibration of the instrument, you will feel some fluid leaking out, therefore feel wet  and lastly the swelling of the fluid in the tissues will stretch the tissues causing the sensation of an occasional pinch. That should be ALL that you will feel. My patients are NEVER describing any pain. And my patients do not receive any pain meds before the procedure and only the occasional one-two tables of an anti-anxiety agent like Ativan.
During the procedure, we are just talking and listening to music. They lie on a heated table and the lights are dimmed in the room and aroma therapy is going as well. We do our best to deliver a comfortable spa-like experience. 
All I can say is the doctor was not adequately trained in the technique of delivering the anesthesia, or was rushing thru the anesthesia process, or the settings on the Tickle machine were set way too high.
Post-procedure I tell my patients that they will feel like they did a really hard workout and they will be very sore. With that said, everybody has a different degree of pain threshold, what one describes as being pretty sore another may describe it has pretty painful. 
I have literally done thousands of Tickle lipo procedures, I have only had a handful of patients that described their post-op recovery as very painful. 
Hopefully your results made up for the physicians inability to keep you comfortable.

Sorry to say , "you were SOLD!"  You must be careful out there. Was the surgeon a boarded PS? Why under awake local without some IV sedation? Did you receive a full pre operative workup? And finally DUPED? You bet!