Teeth whiting is part science, part product choice and a large part art.
After more that twenty years of whitening teeth, the results depend FAR less on what brand, and far MORE on what your teeth are like, and what style of whitening will be the most comfortable as well as the most potent.
I just saw a patient in my office this week who used Da Vinci last year. She looks like she has never whitened her teeth. I would say it's more the fault of the office and the staff, and less so for the brand.
We spent a lot of time looking at what option would give her great results, we spoke a lot about what to expect, and what would fit in with her "whitening personality".
The answer to "Are these whitening approaches the same?" Probably not. But more important than that, I find that whitening tends to be a rushed-through service. An assistant takes some fast impressions, then a few days or a week later, they give you a bag full of things and tell you good luck.
The most important key to success in teeth whitening is to be clear on what you expect, and to ask your questions before you start. Make sure they explain to you what to expect. Unfortunately, I see that a lot of patients wind up on this forum asking about disappointing results AFTER they have had something done.
Great cosmetic dentists and their staff will make sure you know how to succeed and that you will get results you'll be happy with. They will help you find the process to get amazing teeth whitening results.