Silicone or saline? - Will 425 cc in silicone look as big as 425 of saline?

Question

I had a consult today.. and I have decided on silicone implants. It seems to me that saline look a little higher profile???

Michael K. Kim, MD · Answer

in my opinion, saline implants "look" a little larger as they do not have the same consistency and therefore "pop out" more particularly with patients with less skin. When i switch patients from saline to slicone, i usually suggest a little larger slicone implant to look similar in size...i personally like the look of silicone but that is a personal decision i let my patients make.

Richard J. Bruneteau, MD · Answer

Breast implants come in a large
variety of shapes, sizes and styles.  As
a general rule when comparable silicone and saline implants are evaluated they
should have similar appearances.  It’s
important to note that although they have similar appearances, they often have
a different feel depending upon the amount of soft tissue coverage that’s
present.

If you’re considering breast
augmentation, you should carefully discuss this issue with a board certified
plastic surgeon.  This surgeon should be
able to determine which type of implant is best for you.

Vivek Bansal, MD · Answer

Saline tends to look just a bit bigger, and requires a small incision.  But, gel feels more natural, has no valve, and very durable.  There are different profiles so take that into consideration.

Vaishali B. Doolabh, MD, FACS · Answer

Hi, the difference in dimensions between saline and silicone is a factor of the profile, diameter and volume of the implant. Your surgeon will guide you between the different profiles and diameter, at the same volume, based on your expressed preferences on breast shape, cleavage, etc., and your physical examination. The ability to distinguish the saline implant from surrounding breast tissue is easier than a silicone implant, especially if the implants are placed above the muscle. So, it is easier to make a breast appear "larger" by placing a full/high profile, fully filled saline implant above the muscle.

William Bruno, MD · Answer

Saline and silicone implants of the same volume (425 cc) will be the same size although the shape may vary in a subtle way. High profile implants do have more projection and this style is available in both saline and silicone.  I would try on as many of these implants as you can (in a bra) in order to find the size and shape that is best for you.

	I use 3D imaging on my patients which allows them to visualize what they will look like with certain implants in place (saline/silicone/high profile/etc.) before having surgery.

	Best wishes,

	Dr.Bruno

Camille Cash, MD · Answer

There are some variations in how silicone versus saline implants may look and feel once placed in the body.  The overall volume will be the same, but patients often state that silicone implants feel and look more natural.  Saline implants look and feel more like a bag of water.  Your surgeon can help you determine what is best for you based on your surgical goals.  I've included a video on this topic that I hope you find helpful.

Tom J. Pousti, MD · Answer

I agree that, in general, saline implants seem larger (more projection) than silicone implants (which tend to conform to the chest wall). Determining exact implant size is very difficult. Consult your board certified plastic surgeon to discuss the best and safest possible option for you. Every surgeon has a certain technique to determine the best implants to use. It is very important that I communicate with my patients prior to surgery to discuss the look they would like to achieve. Intra-operatively, I use sizers to determine the size and the profile of the implants to be used. This is best determined based on the patient’s body type and overall goals. The main difference between saline and silicone is the feel of the implant. Silicone gel is the more natural feeling of the two. Saline is not recommended for patients without enough coverage or breast tissue to begin with.

Peter E. Johnson, MD · Answer

If the implants have the same size and profile, and correct fill, both will look the same. Size is only a number. Your choice of a silicone gel implant is fine if you have done your homework and understand the differences. There is ample material on this site alone to guide you. Focus on the look that you want, the numbers your surgeon should take care of.

	Best of luck,

	peterejohnsonmd

Darryl J. Blinski, MD · Answer

You ae correct in checking the sizing. I like silicone but try to go up one size in them. Best to see your surgeon to try on different sizes in saline/silicone implants.

Robin T.W. Yuan, MD · Answer

Contrary to popular belief, you cannot, and should not, go by the volume. You will need to look at the dimensions, namely diameter and projection. While the volume are exactly the same, the dimensions will be different depending on the style and manufacturer. See my previouos posts.

	 

	Robin T.W.Yuan., M.D.

Silicone or saline? - Will 425 cc in silicone look as big as 425 of saline?

Answers (12)

More Mommy Makeover Questions

FMLA for Plastic Surgery

What Tests Should I Get Before Mommy Makeover Surgery?

How Soon Can I do Water Sports After a Mommy Makeover?

Mommy Makeover: Is it Advisable to Stay n Hospital Overnight?

Advil or Tylenol After Mommy Makeover

Is it safe to get a mommy makeover w/ stents?

WE SEND PRETTY
EMAILS