Is a Punch Biopsy Enough for a Severe Dysplastic Mole?

December 14, 2011
Asked By:CS28 in Plano, TX

I had a mole shave biopsied and the result stated severely abnormal - recommend removing slightly more. Dermatologist said I needed to set up a punch biopsy. I went in and had this done and I think he removed it with 3mm margins. Im extremely concerned because after researching I have learned that severely atypical moles should be treated like melanoma in situ and be excised with 5 mm margins. Im concerned that it was not an excision and just a punch biospy as well. Should I be worried? Also, others were removed through a shave biopsy - two were moderately atypical and one was mildly atypical. The dermatologist said that no further treatment was needed on any of these unless the area repigments. Is it possible that a shave biopsy can give clear margins on moderate atypical moles?

Answers (7)

From board-certified doctors and trusted medical professionals
December 20, 2011

Answer: A severely dysplastic mole is very close to melanoma.

1 person found this helpful
December 20, 2011

Answer: A severely dysplastic mole is very close to melanoma.

1 person found this helpful
January 23, 2018

Answer: Removal with Clinically and Microscopically Clear Margins Important

2 people found this helpful
January 23, 2018

Answer: Removal with Clinically and Microscopically Clear Margins Important

2 people found this helpful

Recommended reading

Mole Removal

Everything you need to know about Mole Removal

  • 95% worth it
  • 371.0k reviews
  • Avg cost: $1,123
Learn More
ADVERTISEMENT