Is This a Normal Look After Botox?

You are describing what is called the Sinister, Spock or even the Jack Nicholson ("Here's Johnny!") look. IT usually treated by injecting small amounts of Botox into the outer forehead regions.

I would agree that a small amount of Botox in the lateral forehead will resolve your concerns. You do seem to have bruised a moderate amount. Definitely avoid any blood thinners and ice the forehead after your next injection. Best of luck.Stephen Weber MD, FACS

Your situation is easily explained by just needing a couple of units of Botox in the mid outer forehead on each side, not too low in order to prevent flattening or drooping of the eyebrow or upper eyelid.

From your photos, it looks like the Botox is working fine, but that you could use a little more on the lateral aspects of your forehead to limit the high peaking of your eyebrows.  This will blunt the response with expression, and decrease the "evil" look.  I hope this helps.

Your Botox injector can easily address the issue with a touch up.  You should pay a visit.