Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Risk too great-The Nose Makes the Face - Washington, DC

ORIGINAL POST

I was the pretty girl but with a wonky,...

Peonia
$7,600
I was the pretty girl but with a wonky, asymmetrical nose. But people that I know and don't know told me I was beautiful all the time. Still, I remember the first time I saw my nose profile. I was 12 years old and I was surprised. I had never really seen my profile. I had a hump develop after puberty. At 17, I would look at my nose in the mirror and see what I could change about it. At 21 I had my first consultation, but decided after I was shown the simulation "after" photos that the typical change performed by surgeons was too drastic. I searched until I came across a top surgeon that I decided had a conservative approach. I wanted minor tweaks. A less bulbous tip. a slight reduction of the hump. I wanted to wake up and look like me but better. I finally had my surgery at 25.

The past 4 months have literally been horrible. I have thick skin, so the swelling was ridiculous. I looked absolutely hideous the first month. The swelling in the tip was really really bad. I didn't even recognize myself until I hit the 2 month mark. I became obsessed with taking pictures and trying to see progress. It was a big shapeless blob. Then as it started taking on its new shape, I realized how so many things change with a nose job: how you look in pictures, pictures with flash (I look worse in those at the moment), how you look under different lighting, how it can look natural under certain lighting but the "operated" look is definitely visible under others. More so, my dorsum was slightly over-resected, so I had the option of filing down the hump some more (which I did not want to do because, again, I did not want a drastic change in how I look, and the profile is usually the more obvious change) so I just had a restylane filler to fill the dip in the meantime until I can undergo a procedure to build the cartilage back up. Also, with my tip made less bulbous, my nostrils appear flared when I smile and highlighted my asymmetrical nostrils. I also developed indentations on the sides of my nose. It has brought too much negativity into my life, I became obsessive about every aspect of my nose, and it literally consumed my thoughts. I've avoided so many social gatherings because I have been so self-conscious. I don't think it's obvious to most people that I've had a nose job, and it's by no means an ugly looking nose or deformed in anyway. I just like my before nose better. I wish I had done LESS. If I could do it again, I would definitely NOT getting any tip grafts put in. I would just file down the hump and cut the muscle that makes my nose turn down when I smile. I realize how much I liked my nose and how it added to the beauty of my face rather than detracted. I also realize that with a new nose, there will be aspects you don't like about it, just like your old nose. There are too many risks involved and your nose can drastically change your appearance. If something goes wrong, you have to wait AT LEAST 6 months to do anything about it. A revision surgery is just added expense and has a longer recovery time. Also, when you make your nose smaller, you lose a lot of definition that can take a long time to return as the skin shrinks to the new shape. I don't know how I will feel about it in a few months from now, especially since the swelling is still dissipating and it's looking better each week, but I still feel that if I could do it again, I probably wouldn't.

Peonia's provider

Houtan Chaboki, MD

Houtan Chaboki, MD

Board Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

Peonia rating for Dr. Chaboki:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (15)

April 16, 2014
Very, very helpful posting. Thank you for sharing your experience and wisdom.
April 20, 2014
No problem! Let me know if you have specific questions about the experience
User Avatar
April 22, 2014
Thank you for your cautionary tale. I'm sorry you aren't happier! Do you feel that you're obsessing about your nose now more than you did before your rhinoplasty?

I had different things done to my nose, but I have never regretted it for a moment. When all is said and done, I wish the same for you.
April 23, 2014
I used to only think about my nose when I had to take pictures or saw some bad pictures of myself and they would make me cringe. Otherwise I was pretty confident overall and thought I looked decent. In my life, only two people ever said anything negative or mean about my nose. It wasn't a cute or pretty nose by any means, and my profile looked the worst when I smiled, but my profile is not what I saw when I looked in the mirror daily. I don't think I realized how attached I was to the way I look from the front. I woke up to that face for 25 years! After this procedure, I literally wake up and sleep thinking about my nose. Every time I run into someone I know, I keep thinking "did they notice? what are they thinking? Do they think I made a big mistake?" It's just made me more insecure and I hate that. I really wasn't ready for the emotional baggage that comes with this procedure.
April 25, 2017
I am 46.... imagine the impact on me! For a change I never wanted. I can't believe this. I said repeatedly I like my nose. I like my nose. So dumb i signed for "a tad" change. "You but better" "nothing different " totally believing it will be all on the inside cartilage stuff in my tip. He did a lot of plastic work. And my whole
Tip is gone. The one I told him don't him touch. My humps are missing. I am miserable
May 16, 2018
i’m 43 and i feel like you! i’m onto month 4 and i’m obsessed with it and all the things you say! i know it’s probably better than before but the feelings that go with the change of my face and regrets off not looking like myself anymore has overridden anything good that’s come from it. i feel so stupid! for 30 years i’ve wanted one only to wish i looked like me again :(
April 24, 2014
Thank you for your honest feedback, it's good to get a realistic sense of all the emotions we feel when we look at a different face in the mirror every morning. I understand that a nose can throw off the entire familiarity of your face, and that must be a difficult thing to come to terms with. I fear I will feel exactly as you do, and I really dread that prospect. I'm already sick of myself for even thinking so much about this silly feature, and I would really hate to fixate even more about it afterwards. I hope you come to accept your new nose with each passing day, and it continues to 'grow' on you. With time, the swelling will definitely recede, and you'll feel a greater sense of relief to put it behind you. Stay active, go out and enjoy nature, meditate, listen to wonderful music, be thankful for the small things, don't let it get the best of you. We must forgive ourselves and not be so harsh--that's what get us in trouble in the first place. I'm sure you're a very pretty girl, and believe me, no one but you is paying attention to your nose! (everyone else is obsessing on their own issues :)
April 24, 2014
Minorwhite!! Thank you so much for your lovely message. I am working on forgiving myself and learning to adjust to my new nose. That said, I just saw the pictures you have added of your self. I am a stranger behind a screen, and I have nothing to gain in appeasing you or lying to you, if you had an ugly nose I'd be like, yeah, might be a good idea to get this done, but holy crap! you are incredibly BEAUTIFUL! PLEASE don't touch your nose! You don't have a hump that needs to be filed down, and your "wide tip" is not lacking definition (mine was just this round ball). I look at my face now and wish my tip wasn't narrowed so much. It fit my face better. The tip also gets really swollen even when no tip work is done, and you are so close to your wedding date. I really hope you don't go through with the surgery, but regardless, I wish you the best of luck and many congrats on your upcoming wedding.
December 3, 2014
I feel the same way you do about not wanting to go out in social settings and obsessing with photographs and it consuming your thoughts. I went to my surgeon with no real intention of changing the way my nose looked, I just wanted the tip to be a little more refined and I wanted to be able to breathe better. My surgeon did the total opposite of what we agreed on prior to the surgery and he really only worked on one side of my nose so my breathing is still terrible. I have never regretted anything before in my life until I walked into my surgeon's office.... I hope that over the next 6 months or so your swelling comes down further and you are happier with the look.
December 5, 2014
I see a difference and really like your nose. Are you still feeling the same about your results?
UPDATED FROM Peonia
4 months post

No one can tell a difference

Peonia
I had only told two people before my surgery. Afterwards, not a single person noticed, including immediate family members who live with me and my own mother who couldn't tell anything was different over video chat.

This past week, I decided to specifically ask two of my best friends whom I hadn't told before. Both have known me for at least a decade. Both said that I look exactly the same to them.

I have realized how much a cosmetic procedure messes with your head. I don't think I have ever looked at my nose as much as I have since my procedure. It is really toxic and for that reason alone if I could redo all this, I would not get ANY tip work done.

I also just saw my before and after pictures at the doctor's office. I am happy that I got rid of my hump, but I think my front profile looked better before :( I still have swelling, and I hope I will be happy with my results at the one year mark, but again, I wish I hadn't gotten any tip work done. It just wasn't worth it for me, especially now that it has brought more attention to my nostrils, which flare a little bit when I smile ( I had NEVER noticed my nostrils before my tip was narrowed).

I still think Dr. Chaboki is a fantastic surgeon and is the right choice for conservative surgery.

But, is all this pain really worth it for a change so minor? definitely debatable.

Replies (1)

August 19, 2016
Yeah my revision rhinoplasty has been the worst mistake i have ever done. Its taken my natural beauty my eyes have become sunken and hollow. I wish i could turn back time!
UPDATED FROM Peonia
5 months post

All tip jobs look fake

Peonia
:( I wish I'd never touched my tip and never gotten grafts. maybe others can't tell at all, but I did this to feel better and now I just feel worse. My nose looks so fake under florescent lighting and today I was at the store and they had that security camera where you self-checkout and I was horrified by my reflection. It looks SO FAKE. I am utterly devastated by the results and my decision to undergo a rhinoplasty. I will have to live with this for the rest of my life :(

Replies (3)

User Avatar
December 18, 2016
I am in same boat ... i don't know what to do .. I'm hoping revision will help
April 26, 2017
@maytheforcebewithyou/ did you have revision?
April 26, 2017
I didn't even know I was getting a tip graft. At all and my nostrils changed at all. I did no research because I didn't plan on rhino. It's so bizarre. I understand your posts and wish I read it 4 months ago