Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

He Gave Me a Wide, Bulbous, Crooked Nose, and Nerve Damage…Think Twice...- Toronto, ON

ORIGINAL POST

I did my primary revision with Dr. Solomon in 2010...

Torontonian
$6,500
I did my primary rhinoplasty with Dr. Solomon in 2010. During these past 4 years, I've experienced nothing but physical and emotional pain, agony, and excruciating sense of guilt over choosing this doctor while I had a very negative gut feeling about him.
From his reviews on this site and another website, I can see that he has started to "care" about what's being said about him. I hope he reads this review. When I went to him, having consulted about 7 other very qualified plastic surgeons, he seemed to be cold, indifferent, dismissing,derogatory, and rushed. I left his office feeling that I would never return to him. It was only after consulting with my dermatologist that I was persuaded to return to Solomon, because, as she said, my rhinoplasty was a simple job and other doctors were simply charging too much! She also told me that she had heard so many good things about him. It was only after my botched surgery that she said she'd actually heard about him through the media and his paid ads in beauty magazines!!! She has also told me she will never refer anyone to him ever again...Dr. Solomon turned my beautiful, completely straight nose into a mashed eggplant. I asked him only to narrow my nostrils and correct my deviated septum. He gave me an ugly, botched tip-plasty and cut too much cartridge from the right side. He also caused a nerve damage that has left me in pain to this date. After talking to his other patients that I'd found on the internet (and yes, all those negative reviews are from different, very real, sane individuals), that I realized I am not his only victim. My nose is: bulbous, wide, crooked, collapsed tip, and worsened breathing problems. My nose is now so crooked and droopy that every revision surgeon I consult tell me out-right that my problems are due to an obvious surgeon's error.Finally, after many steroid injections (him thinking that it would make my bulbous tip smaller), he finally agreed to do a "revision septoplasty" telling me that I may have no cartridge left to be fixed (his mistake to begin with…) and that there is nothing more he can do. I am sure he is only doing that to charge the health ministry and from the experience sod his other patients he will never even attempt to fix his mess. I cannot trust him with a revision; I cannot really see him as a caring, competent surgeon. My primary was under 50 minutes, and from what I know, most his surgeries are under 1 hour (as I was informed by a nurse the day I went for my pre-admission tests at the Etobicoke General Hospital). I've been so depressed that, for the past 4 years, I cry every time i see myself in the mirror, don't let anyone take a picture of me, and absolutely believe that my face and facial expressions have changed since the surgery. Scared and untrusting of other surgeons, along with financial burden of doing a revision, I think Dr. Solomon is absolutely a horrible "surgeon" who does not possess qualities of care and responsibility, or professional competence.

Torontonian's provider

Philip Solomon, MD, FRCS

Philip Solomon, MD, FRCS

Certified Facial Plastic Surgeon

4.4 | 330 Reviews
PROFILE

Torontonian rating for Dr. Solomon:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (32)

User Avatar
December 17, 2013
I am very sorry that you had a horrible experience with this doctor. I am also glad you didn't let him do a revision. I hope you'll soon find a skilled doctor to fix your nose. There are many good doctors out there, so don't ever lose trust and don't give up. You just need to do your home work and take your time. I had a primary more than 10 years ago and was not happy with my results. And just like you, I didn't trust many other doctors that I consulted. Finally this month I found the surgeon that I believe can fix my nose. Good luck to you.
December 17, 2013
Thank you. I hope you have a successful surgery. I am excited to see how it goes for you. I am still doing my research to find a good surgeon.
January 10, 2014
Hi Zooster--Have you decided to go with Dr. Pontell?:)
User Avatar
January 10, 2014
Hi jennytyler- I think I might do it with Dr. Kofi Baohene. Thanks for asking.
February 1, 2014
Good luck and keep us posted:))))
User Avatar
February 1, 2014
Thanks. Will do.
February 4, 2014
What do you think of Peter Adamson. I have heard he is one of the veterans in the field. But I don't think I am able to afford him. Anyone has opinion?
User Avatar
December 17, 2013

Thank you so much for sharing your experience on RealSelf!

December 17, 2013
You're most welcome! Your website is a great forum for people to communicate and share their experiences. I wish I'd done more internet research before my primary. There were many warning signs on different websites about this surgeon that I didn't see until after my surgery.
December 20, 2013
OMG! Thank you for posting this review on Dr. Solomon. I have had nothing but problems with my nose which I originally had done back in 2007 by Dr. Solomon. If you can believe it I went to Dr. Solomon a total of 3 times to get him to fix his mistakes. He is not a good doctor. He rushes people and doesnt listen to what you want and then says there isnt much else he can do. I keep hearing this from other people who have gone to him too. I should have done more research before I chose him but I was lured in with his advertising, nice office and tv appearances he has done. I am sorry that you too are not happy with your nose. All these years having to have my nose fixed and I was so dumb to keep going back to him. If I had chosen another PS I bet I wouldnt have had to go through all this and be happy with how I look. I want to consult another surgeon but I dont have money to get a revision right now. :(
December 24, 2013
Unfortunately, there are many of us--his victims--out there. Please believe every complaint about him on different websites as they are all true and I have actually had direct contact with many of those patients, and have seen first hand what he's done to people's faces, men and women. I saw your pictures and I have to say that I have similar problems. You are right, my nose also looked better right after surgery when I still had swelling--at least you could't see the asymmetrical tip and crooked nose. Reading through your post was like talking about my own experience. However, he also cut too much cartridge from the right side of my nose, which means my nose is extremely crooked. The reason that your tip is bulbous and big is because the implant to hold up your tip was improperly placed, and your nose rejected the implant. When you look at my nose, it looks like someone is pushing a sharp object through my skin. My tip is also very droopy and my face looks like it was all tangled up in an accident. I never had a negative self-image before this surgery. I did it because I thought I would look better with narrower nostrils. Never, ever, I asked him to change my profile or do a tip-plasty. This so-called surgeon is the epitome of greed and incompetence. Surgeons I consult are in awe of his enormous errors. And believe me, all of his "colleagues" are familiar with his left-over mess as I've been told by a few of them. I decided not to my revision with him, because I cannot trust this doctor. His patients who had gone under his knife warned me about his so-called "revisions" that will leave you in more pain and agony. I am so traumatized that I can't even trust anyone else even though I know for a fact, that he is properly one of the worst out there. He has no empathy and no sense of responsibility over his errors. A simple acknowledgement of his mistakes would have calmed me down, or reassuring me that he would do his best to correct the situation. And you are right again, going with another doctor would have spared me of this pain. But for me, personally, knowing that there are others who understand my pain makes me feel a bit better. It's such a feeling of guilt and regret when your nose pre-op was more beautiful and flawless than post-op. It's like I paid him thousands of $ to punch me in the face! :(
December 30, 2013
I completely agree. He doesnt own up to his mistakes. I asked him many times why this keeps happening to my nose and his response is "it just happens" I remember those exact words out of his mouth and a shrug of his shoulders too. He would never admit to his mistakes. You are right in that the implant was not placed right and my nose is rejecting it. I also posted on here for other PS's to respond to my problem and so far I got one response and he basically said the same thing as you. Poor placement of the implant and my nose rejected it. Not once did Dr. Solomon say anything to me about that. He just tried to cover it up that I have thicker skin and you can only do so much. I get that and that is true but for my nose to change as much as it did and after his implant he put to support the tip it got the worst its ever been. Im not sure what he did third time around but I shelled out $2000. It looks better but still not pleased. It frustrates me that myself, you and many others have put our trust in him and this is the outcome. Not good! Thank you again for sharing this. I see the bad reviews but havent "talked" to anyone that was unhappy except for you. It's nice actually "talking" to a real person besides just reading the reviews. Did you post pictures ever or no?
January 6, 2014
If you click on on my Profile ID, you will see a few pictures I posted when I was still fresh out of surgery back in 2010. I hesitate to take close-up photos these days as the size and crookedness of my nose reduce me to tears. Plus, the protruding implant is not noticeable in photos. I am adding a photo that was taken a few months ago and shows how "wide" my nose is now; it looks like a cartoon character's. The problem with Dr. S. is his money and his advertising machine. I am making the point of telling everyone about him and what he did to me. Unfortunately, money talks: if you google "rhinoplasty Toronto", you will see his business mentioned as the top two results and mentioned again later on the same page. I will never be the same person I was before. My nose, still after almost 4 years, swells up and looks like I've glued on a tennis ball on my face. After refusing to acknowledge that my nose became crooked after the surgery, he took photos of me and his immediate response was "oh, I see what you mean!!!" Just Shameless...he even blamed it on my luck, saying that my skin was "too thick" and people with my skin type are sometimes "unlucky" and that's how their nose turns out. This could not be further from the truth. I have Mediterranean skin type, but every doctor I have consulted before and after my surgery told me that my skin was not considered "thin" but it was definitely not thick either, rather somewhere in the middle. This "thick skin" nonsense is just an excuse to cover up his incompetence. For a very long time, I thought about filing an official complaint with CPSO. If you look at his reviews on different websites (e.g., ratemd and real self), you will see that other PS have negative reviews as well, but his seem to be the worst of any other doctor I've ever seen. There were many negative reviews and detailed complaints on Makemeheal as well, but he managed to remove them. He does the same thing to reviews on ratemd, where he flags all the negative reviews. I will go for a revision as soon as I can get the finances together. My problem is not just about vanity anymore, I have a collapsed valve (because of him) and hardly breathing. It is shameful to say that a silly rhinoplasty damaged the quality of life for me. I will never ever trust a doctor who spends more time advertising and developing apps (yes, he has an app!!!!) instead of caring for his patients and correcting his wrongs. Next time, I will go with my gut feeling. That's what I should have done in the first place.
December 25, 2013
The word, cartridge, in my posts should be replaced by: "cartilage" --sorry for the typo :)
May 25, 2015
I'm so glad I had my gut feeling not to proceed with surgery . First consult less then 60 sec , second consult unprofessional . I asked very simple question he answered with irrelevant to the question answer and I'm very disappointed that I wasted my time . Confuses you , rushes you and I find him trying to mislead you it's all piece of cake . I'm so sorry what happen to you . I'm happy I read the reviews in rate mds .
May 28, 2015
You made my day, Neoush. I'm so glad you didn't go through with him. The element of "luck" and whether he 'likes' you seem to be the driving force behind his work. You never know what he'll do to your face and then refuses to fix the mess and make you believe that your nose is so bad that no one else can fix it either (see the irony in this? He indirectly acknowledges that he butchered you!!). Count your blessings and hope you'll find the right doctor.
June 6, 2015
Yes , you are so lucky BELIEVE ME . Don't allow your face to be playground .May God keep you safe and all of those reviews you have read are real stories real experiences unfortunately some of them really painful experiences . Be safe .
UPDATED FROM Torontonian
3 years post

Pics

Torontonian

Replies (0)

UPDATED FROM Torontonian
3 years post

photo

Torontonian

Replies (0)