Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Breast Augmentation REVIEWS

Fitness Instructor with Mild Ptosis...Over or Under the Muscle?

ORIGINAL POST

I'm 41 y/o, 5'4" and 110lbs. My pre-surgery bra...

User Avatar
joycal33
WORTH IT$6,900
I'm 41 y/o, 5'4" and 110lbs. My pre-surgery bra size is a 32B. I want a natural enhancement that mostly just restores my lost volume so I'm considering 286cc silicone. My PS suggested I have them placed over the muscle (Subglandular) due to my profession as a fitness instructor. He is concerned about animation with Submuscular placement and feels I have adequate tissue to cover a silicone implant nicely. I'm concerned that Subglandular implants might look matronly as they tend to be bottom-heavy. I trust his judgement but I do want to get some other opinions. I don't think animation is as big of a concern to me as the higher risk of capsular contraction, difficulty with mammograms, visibility of the implants and matronly looking (bottom-heavy) breasts are. One of my primary goals is to achieve more fullness in the upper pole which from what I've seen online is achieved well with a dual-plane approach (partial under the muscle). Bottom line is I've having trouble deciding whether to go over or partially under the muscle. Any other super fit, active women with mild drooping after breastfeeding have any opinions about going over or under the muscle? I've included my before photos.

joycal33's provider

Craig N. Creasman, MD

Craig N. Creasman, MD

Board Certified Plastic Surgeon

joycal33

joycal33 rating for Dr. Creasman:

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

Replies (10)

User Avatar
May 22, 2013
            you def. have enough skin to cover the implant if you decide to go over the muscle; plus your healing will be alot quicker: your breast will probably drop faster since you dont have the muscle holding it up! they will be softer and you probably wont have to massage as much as oppose to being under the muscle;i think your in a better position off not getting cc with is a plus: if you want upper pole fullnest ypu shpuld go with a high profile implant; thats what i did and i got alot of upper pole fullnest but im under the muscle;
User Avatar
May 23, 2013
Thank you, Violet1234. I appreciate your feedback. I'll look into high profile.
User Avatar
May 23, 2013
Hi, Im very active had 3 children with emptier and more droopy boobs than you. I am a uk size 8 with 32C/B bra pre op. I am post op day 5. I had 375cc round implants place above the muscles. I really don't think you want to go under the muscle as when you do and are slim, when you lift anything heavy your breasts part. Looks very weird. I am very happy with them at the mo. have a look at my profile. If you would like to know more or see more pics just ask [RS bleep] good luck!
User Avatar
May 27, 2013
Thank you, Rachealuk! I hope I'm not going too small by going with a 286cc??? I'm a size 0/2 in clothes and my PS measured my breast width, which was almost 11cm so he suggested I go with the 286 so that I don't end up with implants wider than my own breasts which could look weird. But I'm concerned I won't have enough fullness, especially with all of the droopiness I have. I was told the rice test isn't accurate. I noticed by reading your profile that you did the rice test. Did you feel like it gave you an accurate idea?
User Avatar
May 27, 2013
I went above the muscles, if you go under I think yo do loose a few cc's. but for me it was pretty much the same. I'm a bit bigger than the rice test as i measured 32D and I'm at the moment 34DD/E. that maybe due to swelling but I'm happy with that. My pre op measurement was 32 large B/C and measured 13. I went for a 375cc moderate profile and at the moment my breast would pass the pencil test and feel very small. You sound a lot slimmer than me so you would need a smaller implant or you end up massive. Mine were saggy and empty before the op and I had it in my head that I needed a lift. I'm so glad I didn't as I love my boobs now. They are starting to drop, so will look a bit more natural, which was what I was after. If you want the round fake look go for a higher profile. But the rice test is an accurateish test and will give you the best idea, just make sure you're scales work :-).
User Avatar
May 27, 2013
I put feel small 1 mean firm lol
User Avatar
May 27, 2013
Thank you, Rachealuk! Very helpful feedback. I will go out and buy some rice today. I wonder if cous cous would work?? Just kidding. :)
User Avatar
May 26, 2013

This is a tough decision. As a fitness instructor, over the muscle might be more practical. Eight years ago, I went under the muscle as my mother is a breast cancer survivor and I wanted to make mammograms a bit more simple as you mention. However, many women seem to be getting silicone these days. And, women with breast implants are very good about doing self exams for early detection. Let us know where your research takes you. Thank you for sharing on RealSelf!

User Avatar
May 27, 2013
Thank you, BethH! This site has been so amazingly informative and reassuring already. Being able to read so many women's experiences and see their photos has been tremendously helpful and everyone is so supportive!
User Avatar
May 30, 2013

Glad to hear you are finding RealSelf helpful! You are now helping others by posting your review and comments. I agree with your decisions about type/size/placement of your implants!

UPDATED FROM joycal33
2 months pre

What size should I go with?

User Avatar
joycal33
I have a very narrow ribcage (28-30") and my breast width was 10-11cm. I have weighed out all of the variables and decided to go with Subglandular silicone implants. I am now trying to decide what size I should go with. My doctor likes the Natrelle moderate profile 286cc for me since the width matches my frame best and I have a fair amount of breast tissue already but I've been reading so many comments of women saying they wished they'd gone bigger. Is 300cc or 330cc too big for someone like me?

Replies (0)

UPDATED FROM joycal33
2 months pre

Ideal Shape

User Avatar
joycal33
I really want to have a nice gradual slope, not overly round on top with some fullness in the lower pole and nipples that point forward and not downward. As someone else wrote (can't remember who) "a natural look with a little wow factor!" I would like to be a full C-cup. I've always been a small B and now I'm a droopy, barely B.

Replies (1)

User Avatar
May 27, 2013
Altho not a fitness instructor I did breast feed and I workout with weights, do TRX and spin. My breasts looked very similar to yours- essentially empty with some sag but adequate tissue. I was a small 36B. My DR was going to go above the muscle but when i told him i definitely wanted some upper pole fullness he changed to the dual plane and i am very pleased with the results. I am only 4 days post-op but I think because I am in good shape I have had minimal discomfort and have essentially full range of motion in my arms. The most difficult thing for me is and will be forcing myself to take it easy and to fully heal before starting to work out again. As far as animation- I also do not consider that an issue and I believe you like me have plenty of breast tissue to cover most of the movement that might be caused when lifting weights. I hope this is helpful and Good Luck! Oh I received 400cc silicone mod profile but I am also taller than you-5'8, 140lb Let us all know what you decide.