Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Facial Fat Transfer REVIEWS

Fat and enzymes ruined my face - San Francisco, CA

ORIGINAL POST

Had fat transfer to my face and lips. BIG...

RedRoxie
$35,000

Had fat transfer to my face and lips. BIG MISTAKE-looks awful and distorted. These doctors need to stop using methods that are so unpredictable. Then they have the nerve to say just wait it out-for at least a year. Are you kidding me? A whole year? Do Not Consider it-I dont' care who the surgeon is and what they promise. Need a facelift? Leave out the fat. Absolutely the worst experience of my life.

RedRoxie's provider

RedRoxie ratings

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
After care follow-up
Time spent with me
Phone or email responsiveness
Staff professionalism & courtesy
Payment process
Wait times

This Dr in SF came recommended by people on a forum and from researching fat grafting. Very few doctors do fat and this one swears by it. He talked me out of implants and said he could fix my problems with fat. There is very little information about him online and he has no website. Beware doctors that don't have a lot online these days. This Dr ruined my face. And don't even try to get in to see him for repair He won't admit to wrong doing and just brushes you off. He comes off caring but only cares about money. Happy to share his name upon request.

Replies (18)

February 27, 2015
I've read your comments regarding your fat transfer procedure and I really feel for you. I, too, had a fat transfer procedure done and during my second follow-up visit, I noticed that the same hollowness return as before the surgery. My doctor. too, failed to tell me that there is no definite length to the amount of time that the benefits of a fat transfer will last. This is what I found on the internet: "Over the course of a few months or a year, a portion of the injected fat will be reabsorbed and dispersed by the body. A fraction, perhaps around a third of the original volume, will remain in place. Though it depends on the extent of the change you desire, multiple fat transfer injections are very often recommended by the surgeon performing the procedure." None of this was told to me at the time I elected to have this procedure done. During my second follow-up visit to the doctor, I told him I was not happy with the results and pointed to the study I just sighted. He was willing to do it again for 1/2 off the original price. I, too, was quite upset when I left his office. After giving some thought to it, I sat down and wrote him a letter telling him of my disappointment and telling him that the internet is replete with articles regarding how long the fat injections might last. After giving my letter some consideration, his office manager called me and said the doctor was willing to do it over at no cost. My procedure is scheduled for next Friday, March 6th. I'm hoping it goes well. I can see a small lump remains on my right cheek. It probably isn't that noticeable to most people but I know its there. If he hadn't offered to do it over, I too would not recommend this procedure to others. Good luck!
User Avatar
November 23, 2015
Who is your doc?
July 3, 2015
Awful. Tje best oculoplasty doctors are in Los Angeles and they can do things you wouldn't even imagine possible. Check out dr. Massry , there's a few more. I lost all fat due to skin tightening device, so here I am on ur page. It's all so,unpredictable
August 9, 2015
I don't understand why you are protecting the doctor's identity. Please post his name so that others are aware of him. If he is a part of this blog then he paid to be reviewed by his clients.
August 9, 2015
Your right eye was cut in the former of an arch. Too much fat was removed. An occuloplastic surgeon can skillfully place a little Restalyne in lieu of the fat he took out. That will even out your eyes.
User Avatar
November 3, 2015
why are you not naming the doctor. i wish you would unless you are afraid of him in which case i certainly understand. thanks.
UPDATED FROM RedRoxie

3months out-looks worse now than it did before....

RedRoxie
3months out-looks worse now than it did before. One side is losing fat faster than the other and there are lumps and uneven areas. Face is flat with no definition. Dr says now have to wait 18 months to see the "true" results. How convenient to keep changing the amount of time. Opinion hasn't changed. This is the worse experience of my lift. I don't look feminine at all. I feel like I was ripped off. Whatever prettiness I had before, its gone. My doctor was a really good salesman and now he is saying we never talked about cheeks and "you didn't have cheeks before" OMG-are you kidding me?

Replies (1)

November 2, 2018
My ps says the same don’t do anything wait it out till at least next year . Sucide would be an option I can’t live like this i look like a 55 year old not a 38 year old . I feel like asking for my money back . Surely if things go wrong they need to fix the mess or refund . I’ve been thinking sculptra but backed out last minute as I felt scared I cass it makes things worse
UPDATED FROM RedRoxie

Fat is disappearing and now have hollow under eyes...

RedRoxie
Fat is disappearing and now have hollow under eyes. Dr says any areas where more fat is needed can be added after 6 months and will cost more $$$$. If course! Why didn't I think of that? The fat doesn't last and is uneven. Lumps and bumps. Face is ruined. If any of you are thinking about this, PLEASE don't do it. You will regret. I have had people contact me who aren't happy with their results. What more do we need to say?? DON'T DO FAT. It's a money maker for these docs. Recent follow up with doctor was a joke. He has completely changed what he told me (and my spouse) in the consult. Now he says he cannot say that any of the fat will remain. He never promises that. But can add more at a reduced price. WHAT A GUY.

Replies (6)

User Avatar
March 12, 2013
Redroxie...same thing happened to me 2 yrs ago & I'm still not right after spending over $30,000 on surgeries, injections, and laser in an attempt to fix it.  Trust me, the lumps never go away.  Finally wrote my review yesterday (see: "Fat Transfer...Don't Do It") but have been commenting on this site regularly thru this whole horrible ordeal.  I can't believe that women still read thru this site and all the bad reviews...yet still go thru with it.  Just saw another one today.  Are they insane? I only wish I had found this site before I messed up my face permanently.  As far as I'm concerned, fat transfer should be banned.  Apparently, its just a huge source of revenue for PS's now & its impossible to sue these guys.  Its criminal.  And the ones who aren't doing FTs are making a fortune by trying to fix the messes.  What a racket.  
March 12, 2013
I am so sad for both of us. My mission is now to keep others from doing this
July 26, 2013
I am sooo sorry for all of you I consider myself one of the lucky ones. I had never heard of fat grafts before my surgeon suggested it for my cheeks only. He does not recommend it for anywhere else, especially the lips, as it is too unpredictable. Anyway, they came out beautiful. He belongs to a practice in Charlotte, NC that is very prestigious, called, Charlotte Plastic Surgery. I am sick at heart because he has since left the practice to head up Emory College Surgical Program. But the other doctors are also very competent. Another world renowned practice is, Long Island Plastic Surgical Group, Garden City. So if you are near either of those locations, I highly recommend them. Good luck and I will keep you in my prayers
User Avatar
December 13, 2013
Dear notsogood, I can't wait to look at your review as I am taking these reviews seriously; however, if people don't provide clear before and after pictures, it will not be convincing to me as I just wrote to Redroxie, there is just too many positive before and after pictures and please don't take offense but if a person doesn't provide pictures that clearly show what the problem is, then how do we really know that it isn't an ex-wife or girlfriend as I know that this has happened to one doctor I know of. I do take this seriously and I think we all need to insist on knowing how often a doc does the procedures and see before and after pictures including long term as it appears that there is a question as to whether this fat transfer has the lasting results they charge more for because of that expectation.
User Avatar
December 13, 2013
Chellamia, I wrote you a reply, but for some reason it was removed. I put in a link to a photo I have online here at realself when I asked the doctors here a question. I will write you a private message with the link. Sorry, don't know what happened to my post...and the link was just to another place at this site, so I don' understand the removal.
June 19, 2017
This describes my situation exactly! If you & I both experienced this, makes one wonder about all the fabulous results lauding Dr. Martin as "the best of the best." Fake reviews - astroturfing?