Eyelid Surgery Reviews
75%
WORTH IT RATING
"Worth It Rating" shows the % of consumer reviewers that stated the procedure was "Worth It" or not. See more RealSelf Worth It Ratings or Add Your Review
Eyelid Surgerybefore & after photos
View Before and Afters

Average Eyelid Surgery Cost: $3,875

Learn about Eyelid Surgery

2,269 people and 797 doctors are talking about Eyelid Surgery

Get Free Email Updates

Hate my Hollowed Eyes After Blepharoplasty - New York

Not Worth It
Spent: $5,000 in new york

Comments (5)

Posted 5 Dec 2011

Went to a well respected top plastic surgeon in new york. Specifically asked md prior to surgery, "will my eye shape change" "will I have a sunken look" and I was told no to both questions. I had some bags under my eyes at the time &thought removing the bag would just give me a more well rested appearance. Well, I hated the results the minute I looked in the mirror after surgery & hate it even more today, five years later. I had beautiful almond shaped eyes, that truly were my best feature on my face. I regret the surgery every day I see my changed face in the mirror. I feel so sad that my beautiful eyes are gone forever. The plastic surgeon made me feel like I was just being overly critical, but I am not. I honestly would do anything to have my eyes back, bags and all. My eyes are now round, when once almond shaped, hollow when once full, now in a downward slant when once slanted upwards....so regretful.

I feel this surgery is just not a surgery that will make anyone more youthful looking or better. By removing fat, that God has placed there for a reason, it can only make one look older and hollow! Today many plastic surgeons are repositioning the fat instead of removing it...oh how I wish one would have suggested that to me.

This review is the subjective opinion of a RealSelf member and not of RealSelf, Inc.

Helpful review?

Comments (5)

Post a Comment
Stephanie1 10 Dec 2011
Who was your surgeon?
JessieR 20 Feb 2012
Dear Regretpsoneyes,
Wow, so many of our experiences with lower bleph are similar. I too had bags under my eyes. I thought I would look more well rested if I had them reduced.

I am at 5.5 weeks post op and absolutely hate the results. My eyes are hollow, especially my right eye.

My doc is also "highly regarded". I felt comfortable with his advice because he specifically said that removing too much fat would produce a negative outcome. As he was well aware of the problem of "overcorrection", as he put it, you would think he would have been conservative with the fat removal, right?

Well, when he came to see me in the recovery room, he said, "I took out a lot of fat. I think you will be pleased with the result".

Long story short, now my eyes are way more hollow than they ever were puffy. Every second of each day is filled with regret, panic and despair. I would do anything to have my beautiful, God given, puffy eyes back. My eyes now look round and droopy.

I fear that this regret and despair will be a life sentence. I really think there should be in-person support groups for people who had bad plastic surgery, maybe similar to AA. There are too many of us suffering and obviously the regret lasts for years.

Have you ever tried fillers to restore some of the fullness?

Best wishes to you.
ernurse 23 Mar 2012
I am so sorry to hear that you have had such a bad result. However I am not surprised. Surgeons will say whatever they think you want to hear and then do whatever they want when they do the surgery. They then of course deny that anything is wrong. Also the true facts are that no surgeon can truly predict the outcome no matter how highly regarded they appear to be. Did your surgeon offer to do anything to fix things? I ;personally have used some filler to restore some fullness. This does help, but I would definitely seek out an expert in this. Tell your surgeon you want your money back...you did not get what you paid for. DO NOT let him touch your eyes again. I agree there should be a group and there should be more expose of these bad surgeons and the reality of the high risk involved.
JessieR 25 Mar 2012
Hi ernurse,

My surgeon went on vacation shortly after my surgery and just recently came back. I'm going to see him in early April. I know he will offer suggestions to "improve" my result. However, I am NOT going to let him touch my eyes. I mainly want an opportunity to tell him in person how much this has devastated me.

I want to tell him how inadequate my consultation was. (How inadequate most consultations seem to be.) At the time, what he said seemed to make sense - just take out a little fat and puffiness will be reduced. He was such a charming salesman. "This procedure goes very smoothly and produces a wonderful result." Yeah, it produces a wonderful result if you forever hold your face at rest with perfect overhead lighting!!! But try smiling, laughing, being in dim light, or side lighting and the shadows on your new eye hollows will make you look like a goddamn Halloween ghoul !!!

Only NOW do I know that the fat around our eyes is an essential structural element that supports our eyelids. It is also an essential cosmetic element that provides fullness and balance to our upper face. Yet, these doctors treat it like wisdom teeth or tonsils - some superfluous anatomical feature that they can remove without consequence.

I should have been told that it was surgically impossible to "give me back my old eyes" - and that achieving a reasonable facsimile was a crapshoot at best. That removing fat would, in fact, reduce puffiness, but it would also change so many other things. That all surgery could accomplish was the exchange of one set of circumstances for a different set of circumstances - then letting me decide if the trade-off would be worth it. In my case, the puffiness was not so bad that is was worth the hollowness.

I have set up three consultations with some of the Los Angeles oculoplastic surgeons. All three consultations will happen in April. Each of these docs is an "expert injector" around the eyes. I'm hoping they say I'm a good candidate for Restylane. I think it will give me some peace of mind just to have some fullness back.

I'm also starting therapy this week. I have so much regret and I need help getting past it. I responded to a comment on my own thread: "Sunken Right Eye After Lower Transconjunctival Blepharoplasty - Northern California" where I admit that I was not in the best state of mind to undergo surgery when I did. Ultimately, I made a bad decision. But my doctor also needs to know that he played a role in my dissatisfaction.

Ernurse, please reach out to me via personal message or post on my thread if you would like to keep in touch. I would greatly appreciate your support. Every connection brings comfort during this nightmare.

This website is great, but I really feel "plastic surgery regret" is underrepresented in the world of recovery. There are recovery programs for so many other problems that cause despair - alcoholism, drug abuse, compulsive behavior, eating disorders, etc. The list goes on and on. But other than RealSelf, and a couple of other message boards, it is hard to connect with others who understand this special brand of regret and devastation. Let's be honest, people who haven't been through it really can't relate and can only offer limited support. In addition to being able to vent, we need a path of emotional recovery, maybe along the lines of a 12 step program.

Again, please keep in touch.

Best wishes - JessieR
JessieR 25 Mar 2012
There is one more thing that my doctor should have told me during my consultation. That the probability of asymmetry was HIGH. That it is damn near impossible to produce adequate symmetry. If he had told me that ONE FACT alone, I would have walked out the door. But he didn't. He never mentioned the possibility of asymmetry, which is what I ended up with.

My eyes weren't perfect to begin with, but the minor asymmetry was NATURAL and did not look freakish. The surgical asymmetry is really unacceptable to me.

I just hope Restylane can even it out.

Post a Comment

used for verification

Read more Eyelid Surgery reviews