Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Tattoo Removal REVIEWS

A tattoo I've wanted ended up being a tattoo I'd rather forget.

ORIGINAL POST

We all have a story of how we got to the point of tattoo regret...

User Avatar
anchor_regret

Hi guys! We all have a story of how we got to the point of tattoo regret and/or removal, and well, here's mine:

After years of wanting a tattoo but fearing the commitment/pain that comes with getting one, I decided to finally suck it up and get inked! I knew exactly what I wanted because I've been talking about it for as long as I could remember... An anchor to honor my grandfather who was in the Navy. I also wanted to "mark" my body to commemorate a new chapter in my life after a drastic weight loss and lifestyle revamp.

Despite being recommended several tattoo shops in NYC, I thought it would be exciting to get the tattoo while I was on a weekend getaway (Mistake #1), so I found a tattoo shop nearby with pretty good reviews, and just like that, found myself there on January 23rd.

I had finally settled on the anchor design that I wanted and was ready for that needle to hit my skin.
The tattooist recommended I go slightly bigger on the design so the detail in the rope would be visible, which made me quickly rethink the placement I originally wanted (Mistake #2). Instead of getting it a couple of inches above my wrist, I decided to get it right below the crease of my forearm.

After he was done tattooing the outline, I actually really liked the way it looked and decided to not fill it in.

I wasn't too thrilled about the placement I chose, but I was willing to look passed it because I was just so excited.

A week went by, my excitement wore off and I started to observe the tattoo more clearly... And, that's when I realized it was asymmetrical and the placement of it was actually not something I was able to look passed.

The friends I showed it to did not think it was all that bad (I'm sure to them, I was just being overly dramatic), but it didn't matter... It was on MY body staring right back at me. I don't want a tattoo to knock down the confidence and self-esteem I worked so hard on regaining this past year... and that's exactly what it is doing.

So, once the tattoo fully healed, I decided to go to a different tattoo artist to try and salvage it.

And as I was sitting there, in the spur of the moment, I asked him to extend the rope and add a RED HEART to the bottom of it to add some "character" to the piece (Mistake #3).

I left the shop unsure of the outcome. On one hand, the artist did a decent job covering the asymmetry as best he could... On the other hand, the extended rope and heart looked completely inconsistent with the rest of the tattoo.

I thought about adding a black outline around the heart to try to make it look better, but how many more times can I possibly retouch this tattoo in hopes that I'll grow to like it?

I can't move it down a few inches, so what's the point in trying to "fix" the look when I can't even fix the placement?

I've become neurotic about it... self-conscious about it... And I'm even losing sleep over it. I spend HOURS scouring the internet looking at other anchor tattoos to try to reassure myself that mine isn't "all that bad," but it's hard to change how I feel.

In a nutshell, the tattoo that I wanted and the tattoo that I got are two different things. Looking at it only makes me think of all of the "what if's" that I can't do anything about.

I'm EMBARRASSED that the tattoo that I've been talking about for years ended up nowhere near the way I had envisioned it. I'm ashamed to admit this to my family, the person I was with when I got the tattoo, and to the rest of my friends.

So, with my mind set, I booked a consultation with Jessica Krant in NYC to see about possibly getting picosure to start fading this sucker... I'm not sure if I'm going to tell anyone about this until I have my first treatment, but I know that I want to get 1-2 treatments before the summer and use the summer to work on naturally fading it.

My current dilemmas are:

1) Do I get an outline around the heart before starting treatment in my last attempt to try to make it look better, or stop adding on to it? Even though I'm certain I want this thing zapped, I'd rather "complete" the tattoo before starting treatment so I can be less self conscious when/if it's out in the open in between sessions.

2) Do I aim for a complete removal, or just fade it for a cover up? Placement is a big factor in why I regret my tattoo... Would I really like something else in its place? I'm just antsy to get rid of it.

Anyways, I'll keep you all posted on what I decide to do, but in the meantime, I THANK YOU for reading my story and telling yours. I'll be a regular on these boards for the next few months, so please do not be a stranger -- drop a note to say hello and reassure me that I'm not alone :)

anchor_regret's provider

Jessica J. Krant, MD, MPH

Jessica J. Krant, MD, MPH

Dermatologic Surgeon, Board Certified in Dermatology

Replies (1)

User Avatar
February 1, 2015

Thanks for sharing your story with everyone...it takes a lot of courage :) If I were you, I'd definitely stop adding to it right away. As far as your lasered tattoo being out in the open between treatments, there are ways around it. There are amazing cosmetics you can use once the area is healed to hide your lasered tattoo. As far as getting a cover up, yes...a lot of people get a few laser sessions to lighten the initial tattoo and get more options for a cover up. You could get a design that flatters your body's curves better and that would resolve the bad placement issue. Good luck..please keep everyone posted!

Tania Barbe ***3rd party link removed***

UPDATED FROM anchor_regret

Close Up of Tattoo

User Avatar
anchor_regret
I know it's not a TERRIBLE tattoo by any means (and I'm sure so many would rather have my tattoo than the one they currently have), but it's just not me and it's not something I think I can get used to.

Replies (9)

User Avatar
March 13, 2014
Hey! Really enjoyed reading your story. It's cool to hear how everyone got to where they are with their tattoos with their own individual back stories! Your tattoo should respond well to laser treatment - it's black ink on white skin, which is pretty much the ideal setup, as far as removal goes. With the right laser the red heart should be fairly removable too. I look forward to seeing how you get on.. Keep us posted! :)
User Avatar
March 13, 2014
Thank you! I love reading everyone's backstory... it gives me a sense of comfort about my own :)
March 13, 2014
Hi. :) It's a lovely tattoo, really. Your feelings are what matter though. As wilks said, black ink on white skin will repond really well, especially with picosure. There are loads of us on here who have made big tattoo mistakes so don't best yourself up about it. Let us know how you get on!
March 13, 2014
Whoops - meant to say don't beat yourself up about it!
User Avatar
March 13, 2014
Thanks Chad! I sometimes feel foolish for hating my tattoo so much because it really isn't all that bad, but my additions to it, as well as the placement, has really taken a toll on me. Some days I look at it and I'm like "hey, it's not that bad... maybe once I put a black outline around the heart, it'll look good", but then there are other days where I'm just like "I WANT A DO-OVER!" It'll be a painful and expensive do-over... but I'm ready (I hope).
User Avatar
March 14, 2014
Hello :-) Sweet post! I completely understand your situation. Just stay positive!
March 16, 2014
Hey, I think your tattoo is really cute, but obviously your the one that has to be happy with. I have the same placement as you and I totally hate it too, and the "artist" did a terrible job. Try not to stress over it to much, one day you will laugh at this :)
March 16, 2014
hey welcome i saw you on the other forum,this should respond good to laser,
UPDATED FROM anchor_regret

I decided to tell two people...

User Avatar
anchor_regret
It's very hard for me to keep my feelings all pent up inside of me (hence why I turned to this forum for comfort and support), but as ashamed as I am about the situation that I'm in, I just know that I am going to need the support of at least a couple of friends while I go through this process.

I decided to tell my best friend and the guy I'm seeing. These two are the ones I see frequently (aside from my family) and I'd rather answer questions now than later.

My best friend thought I was overreacting and recommended that I keep myself busy with other things to get my mind off the tattoo... Easier said than done. When I'm out and about, I keep it hidden and don't even give it much thought, but that's just one of the problems... I don't want to keep concealing this tattoo. I want to be proud of it... and I'm not.

The guy that I'm seeing was also the person who went with me to get the tattoo in the first place. I was hesitant to tell him for many reasons. 1) He always tells me I'm an over-thinker and I should just let things go and stop worrying so much (he has several tattoos, some that weren't executed the way he had hoped, but he doesn't mind), and 2) I didn't want him to feel any inkling of guilt. He had nothing to do with it. It was my choice to get the tattoo. It was my choice to get it where I got it. It was all my choice and I'm not putting the blame on anyone but myself.

He was actually very supportive and told me that perhaps tattoos are just not for me since they'll never be as perfect as I want them to be (I forgot to mention: I got a 2nd tattoo a few weeks ago -- it's a hamsa design on my back, which I can't really see well enough to dwell on, so perhaps tattoos that are VISIBLE are just not for me lol).

Well, in any case, I'm glad there will be at least two people who now know what I'm going through and I trust that they will be there for me during this process :)

Replies (22)

User Avatar
March 16, 2014
I am glad you opened up to some people close to you, it feels good to let it out. You know...your tattoo is very cute, I had to really really look close to try and see the flaws you explain but I just don't see them....I am a perfectionist too, and it bugs me when something doesn't look just right so I understand how you feel, especially being a tattoo. I am going through removal as well because the end result was not at all what I expected, but I plan on a cover up and learned a very big lesson. 
User Avatar
March 16, 2014
Hi Eva, thanks so much for your comment! If you look closely, the top handles are different sizes as well as the bottom arms and flukes; there's also a curve at the bottom on the right side that the other side doesn't have.... With that said, the asymmetry is just one of many things that irks me about the tattoo. I sometimes feel like I'm just being overly dramatic, which is why I feel so ashamed for the way I feel. Good luck with your removal! I assume you're just going to fade yours until it's light enough for a cover up?
User Avatar
March 16, 2014
Yep, I orignally wanted it gone, but then I calmed down, and because I wanted a back piece I just decided that I would be patient with the removal and when I was ready move forward with a cover up. 
User Avatar
March 18, 2014
Welcome and thanks for sharing your story. I like your tattoo. But I know all too well about placement. Mine is in the exact same place as yours and that was my #1 regret. For me, just the physical presence of my tattoo bothers me. I too am someone who probably would do best with tattoos they are not visible all the time. I have another tattoo but it's on my chest and I don't always see it as it's mostly always covered with clothing. Now, with this new tattoo, unless I wear long sleeves, it shows. I got my tattoo in August and after several back and forth decisions about laser, I decided against it. I'll keep the tattoo for now. Honestly, I'm getting used to the tattoo over time. I'm not saying that I'll never get laser removal, just not now. Do you think that if you just allowed yourself more time to get used to the physical presence of it, you may change your mind? Anyway, my tattoo has many flaws as well and so I also know how that can irk you! Good luck and we are all here for you. Long speech over lol....
User Avatar
March 18, 2014
Hi Canadagirl! Thank you so much for your "long speech" - i appreciate lengthy messages as I am quite wordy myself lol I admire your decision to keep your tattoo for now. As much as I would love to have the same mindset, I'm just too bitter... I envy people with beautiful ink that they're proud to show off. I want to eventually get to that point.... I'm just not sure I can ever to there with this tattoo in particular. *sigh*
User Avatar
March 19, 2014
I'm not in love with my tattoo and I'm not proud to show it off. In fact, I'm not even comfortable exposing it at home by myself. I just did research and really have not found enough solid proof that a tattoo can be removed completely. I'm worried about having a really faded tattoo and having to get a cover up to fix it. If I have to be stuck with a tattoo, if rather be stuck with this one. I totally 1000000% know what you're feeling right now. I just also know that making an important and permanent decision as this when you are so deeply emotional can open a new can of worms. It's ultimately your decision and we will all be here to support you along the way! :) I think that undergoing tattoo removal is a very courageous thing to do. :) just make sure you're doing it for the right reasons and under the right circumstances.
User Avatar
March 19, 2014
Oh, I know... Going forward with tattoo removal is both inconvenient and unfortunate. I keep beating myself up over everything leading up to this. So many "what if's", but at this point, all I can do is go to my consultation next week and hear what the doctor recommends. I'm very curious to know what her estimate will be for both the cost as well as how many sessions I may need. My main concern now is whether I want a cover up, or to pursue a full removal. This tattoo has gotten me so antsy that I don't want to make another brash decision like getting a cover up and then hating THAT even more. Patience, patience, patience... blah!
User Avatar
March 19, 2014
I think the best thing to do is go for a consultation and get informed on what you'll be up against. It doesn't look like your tattoo is very dense and aside from the red heart, it's all black so I'm sure removal is possible as black is said to be the easiest to remove. Just take it one step at a time and you'll be ok. I think that anyone who decided to undergo removal must accept that it may not work and a cover up may be necessary. The laser breaks up the ink but it's your body that carries the ink away and individual results can vary with that depending on a lot of factors. I'm sure the person you see will discuss that with you. Again, good luck and we are here for any support or advice you may need/want
March 21, 2014
I read your article without looking at pics first. I then look at them expecting to see a terrible tattoo (going off your expression of distress). I really like it. I believe it would look really cool to just put a black line around the heart and then it would be complete/set. If you want to venture down the removal process I can tell you my story. I've got been in the process for the pass couple of years removing thigh, ankle, fore arm , and chest tattoos. I've had professional treatments with a q switched yag laser. the tattoo on my fore arm resulted in keloid scarring which is excess collagen production and it can keep growing beyond the skin surface categorising it as a benign tumour. I have now had half the tattoo/keloid scarring cut out in an operation that involved local anaesthetic and a scalpel cutting 3 inch long by 1 inch wide of skin and fat. in a few months I will have the extact same surgery to take out the other half of my tattoo and the final result will be one single scar. During the procedure I was allowed to record it. sadly I have deleted footage by mistake. But I will be certain to get new footage of the second operation which will be the same. feel free to contact me via email motv8@hotmail.com
March 21, 2014
I read your article without looking at pics first. I then look at them expecting to see a terrible tattoo (going off your expression of distress). I really like it. I believe it would look really cool to just put a black line around the heart and then it would be complete/set. If you want to venture down the removal process I can tell you my story. I've got been in the process for the pass couple of years removing thigh, ankle, fore arm , and chest tattoos. I've had professional treatments with a q switched yag laser. the tattoo on my fore arm resulted in keloid scarring which is excess collagen production and it can keep growing beyond the skin surface categorising it as a benign tumour. I have now had half the tattoo/keloid scarring cut out in an operation that involved local anaesthetic and a scalpel cutting 3 inch long by 1 inch wide of skin and fat. in a few months I will have the extact same surgery to take out the other half of my tattoo and the final result will be one single scar. During the procedure I was allowed to record it. sadly I have deleted footage by mistake. But I will be certain to get new footage of the second operation which will be the same. feel free to contact me
User Avatar
March 21, 2014
Hello motv8, I am so glad you found us! I am really sorry to hear you had the experience of Keloid scarring and I am glad you bring it up. Do you mind if I ask why you decided to remove your tattoos? Also would love for you to write a review for the community and would be thrilled if you would add your video footage once recorded, would be interesting for everyone to see. 
User Avatar
March 21, 2014
Thanks for sharing your experience motv8. I'm curious, do you find the laser removal process worth it even with the keloid scarring? How did your other removals go? My tattoo is on my forearm and I'm curious if it was the location that caused the scarring? Do forearms scar more easily?