Get the real deal on beauty treatments—real doctors, real reviews, and real photos with real results.Here's how we earn your trust.

POSTED UNDER Rhinoplasty REVIEWS

Almost 2 years Post op- New York, NY

ORIGINAL POST

Hey everyone, I found this website about 6 months...

User Avatar
ErinDee
WORTH IT$10,000

Hey everyone, I found this website about 6 months ago when I started actively looking into the procedure, and all of your experiences have helped me greatly. I've always hated my nose and my mom and sister used to make fun of me growing up saying I needed to get my nose done. When I bring it up now they both say "your beautiful just the way you are" I mean its no secret that I have a big Italian nose. I have a bump and the projection of my nose is a little big for my face especially because all my other features are smaller. I had my first consultation last week and it was very overwhelming for me. All these people examining my nose. I have my second consultation this upcoming week and I'm curious to see how this one goes, hopefully i'll be less overwhelmed. I'm scared of the actual procedure, and the recovery time and the possibility of it coming out bad. I know i'll feel soo much better about myself after, but its bee a tough journey so far. The doctor I saw last week specialized more in reconstructive surgery, more than traditional rhinoplasties. He re-buildes noses and stuff for people who only have half a nose. The doctor i'm seeing this week specializes in noses. He markets himself a lot and i'm not sure if thats a bad thing or not. Anyways, if you guys have any advice for me or tips or anything i'd love to hear from you.

ErinDee's provider

Mark L Smith

ErinDee

ErinDee ratings

Overall rating
Doctor's bedside manner
Answered my questions
Time spent with me

He's wonderful. Took the time to see me before surgery was super nice and caring in the OR and checked in on my 3 times after the surgery.

Replies (2)

User Avatar
April 24, 2013

Hi there,

Your story really resonates with me. I'm so sorry you were teased about your nose by your family. I truly do not understand why parents do that.

Choosing a doctor is the most important decision in this journey and I'm glad you're doing your research. Here's a list of questions to ask your prospective rhinoplasty surgeon. And here's what doctors say about choosing the right surgeon for you. I hope you find this helpful and that you'll keep us in the loop as you progress. I have never regretted my rhinoplasty for one second.

User Avatar
April 24, 2013
Thanks for your help. I had my second consultation today and I feel more confused. Maybe because the price for this doctor was like 20 grand. I like both doctors I met. I actually have been on this website so much I had a copy of the 15 questions to ask your doctor in my pocket and I look forward to reading the how to pick a doctor thing. Thank you for responding it means a lot to me. Ill keep posting!
UPDATED FROM ErinDee
3 months pre

So, I've had 2 consultations so far. I liked both...

User Avatar
ErinDee
So, I've had 2 consultations so far. I liked both doctors. The one I had a consultation with today was was more commercial, had the big fancy office on park avenue with his own operating room, etc... The other doctor held his consultation at beth isreal, so there was a generic doctors office and generic waiting room, both very different experiences. The one to day specializes in noses and has his own procedure patented and whatnot, And is double board certified in facial, and an ENT. The other doctor is just board certified in plastic surgery but does more reconstructive work, like people who are missing half their nose and re-building it. He supposedly also is an ENT but not board certified. He was also recommended by a close family-friend of my boyfriends who was also a plastic surgeon. I haven't gotten a price quote back from him yet. Todays doctor wants 19,000... Both doctors agreed that they'd do a closed surgery and do the same things to my nose, but the one today also said that I need a septioplasty (forgive my spelling) as well because of the way it sits at the top? and the other doctor said it looked straight. My boyfriend seems to be convinced I should choose the recommendation, because he was recommended by his close family friend, and he seems like he's in it to actual help people and he rebuilds faces and such for cancer patients and people who were in accidents, to where as the other guy seems like a nose factory. He also has a point to say this guy would get bored limiting himself to just one speciality when he enjoys all of them (mind you he's a brainiac). So I definitely feel more confused. Any advice would be helpful.

Replies (9)

User Avatar
April 24, 2013
You picked a great place to share your story and seek advice. Most of us can kind of relate in one way or another, and everyone here is very welcoming and open. I am pretty sure you have a slue of doctors to choose from in your area; that is great. The process can be pretty overwhelming at first. What helped me was to research the doctor's credentials beforehand and study what they actually meant; this made me more comfortable with the person's ability while talking to them. Seeing someone who specializes in rhinoplasties and revisions for rhinoplasties seems to be the 'safest' choice. There are PLENTY of great surgeons out there, but there are some who have gotten a bad rep from a few bad cases. You seem to be a good candidate for rhinoplasty. Just remember that IMPROVEMENT is realistic, not perfection. Also, you need to be very clear about what it is you want done by your surgeon and what you do NOT want. Ask if he or she has another case like yours that he can show you; sometimes they do sometimes they don't. In the end you have to find someone you can put complete confidence in: someone who will care for you before, during, and after the procedure. That was one of my biggest concerns. I wanted to make sure my surgeon had a genuine interest in my case. The only way you can find out is to try and build a professional relationship between the two of you. Ask lots of ?s here too! There are a lot of intelligent people who have gone through what you are about to! Best of luck!!!
April 25, 2013
I am in the same boat as you right now so not sure I have any advice for you but I will be following this post and all the answers. I went on my 3rd consult today and have one more on Monday. I liked the 1st dr who has many good reviews on this site....the 2nd dr I think I am pretty much ruling out as he does not have as much experience and I did really liked the 3rd today. I am a very indecisive person by nature so I know this will be a hard decision for me but I plan on making it soon! good luck to you as well!
User Avatar
April 25, 2013
Thanks! Good luck too you too, I look forward to see what you decide!
User Avatar
June 5, 2013
Hey, did you pick a surgeon yet?
User Avatar
June 5, 2013
I'm 9 days post op but still all taped up as soon as I can take everything off I will be posting my experience:-) I did mine in Mexico;)
April 29, 2013
Have you seen and compared their before and after photos? Rebuilding noses takes a lot of skill, I think he sounds like he would be good????? Hwever, It takes a while to work out what you are really looking for and to read between the lines with surgeons, to whittle out the truth from the not so true... I am seeing forth surgeon in a few weeks, I just haven't found one I feel is genuinely interested in my concerns. You get good advice by reading other people's posts. I have learnt ALOT!! Good luck. Remember to Give yourself plenty of searching and thinking time. What seems good at first, after a few weeks of digesting how the consultation went, you often will feel very different, on what you initially thought seemed good. Just listen to your conscience.
May 1, 2013
Hi, thanks for sharing your story here. By any chance is one of the plastic surgeons you consulted with Dr. Rizk? Whichever your choice, much luck in your surgery:)
User Avatar
May 1, 2013
Haha yeah one of them was Rizk, what was the giveaway, the price LOL
May 5, 2013
I have seen Dr Rizks work and it always leaves me in complete ahh he seem to be a true talented artist. While his prices are just extremely high if money is not an option this is the doc I would select hands down!!!!!!!
UPDATED FROM ErinDee
2 months pre

Hey everyone. I've picked a doctor! Based on the...

User Avatar
ErinDee
Hey everyone. I've picked a doctor! Based on the recommendation of a close family friend, it will be the surgeon he suggested. I also have my surgery booked for July 18th. I'm kinda getting freaked out by the healing process, I hope its not as bad as I'm anticipating. I can't wait until my pre-op because I just want to pick his brain before we go in for surgery, especially because he was my first consult so I was a bit flustered. I'm not excited yet, I feel like i'm just neutral about it at the moment. Anyways, I'll update soon to see if i'm feeling the same way.

Replies (3)

May 7, 2013
Hey good luck with surgery! Mine is July 2nd! pretty close to yours. I'll be checking in on you and I hope the best for you. :)
May 7, 2013
Well done on choosing a surgeon and picking a date. You won't regret having this done. To have a nose that is more delicate and in keeping with your other features will transform your life. The surgery and recovery is generally fairly easy, we just need lots of patience, particularly waiting for swelling to slowly subside. All the best!!
May 11, 2013
Omg that price is outrageous! Makes me feel really good about how much I paid! Who did you both end up choosing?