Hair Transplant: Stories
Write a ReviewWhy Hair Transplants Are a Bad Idea - Miami, FL
- Not Worth It
- Cost: $45,000
- Miami, FL
Hair Transplants are a bad idea. I am a hair...
- 2 Jun 2012
Hair Transplants are a bad idea. I am a hair transplant veteran/victim (4 procedures) and I am writing this post to help anyone who is considering this procedure to think twice before doing it. In particular, I am addressing the young men around 30, who don't know what they are getting themselves into. My goal is to get a newbie to NOT rush into this as I did and consider the long-term implications of what they are doing.
These following points should all be considered:
1. There isn't enough hair. If you pour about $40,000 into it, you can get back maximum 25% of your original density. That's it. About 7,500 grafts. It's nothing. Trust me. All you'll be able to do is have a real nice combover. That's about it.
2. The hairs are going to thin and age. This will render the cosmetically insignificant. If you transplant them at 30 years of age, they will not have the same cosmetic impact when you are older. They will look like unmanageable weeds.
3. The donor area will thin over time. This is the horrible truth hair transplant doctors don't tell you. The hairs in the back of your head will start thinning, too. Eventually, you will have the head of any regular old man - except for the giant strip scar or pock-mark dots of the hair transplants.
4. Propecia and other medicines don't work. Don't let the doctors lie to you. Propecia eventually stops working (Merck only ran their studies for five years - the point when they knew it stopped working) and your hair loss will continue. Minoxidil is absolutely worthless. Those are the only "proven" weapons in the arsenal and neither works.
5. New procedures like FUE have lower yields than strip and a host of other risks associated with them. You will never get your old hair back, so don't be fooled by the so-called advances in hair restoration surgery.
Take these five points, add them together and you'll get the simple fact. There is nothing you can really do about your hair loss. Better to shave your head and accept it.
The only qualifier? Hair transplants are excellent for very insecure individuals that want weeds on their head and a giant scar in the back when they become old men. If that fits your profile, then by all means have a hair transplant. If, on the other hand, you want to age like Bruce Willis or Andre Agassi, bald and handsome, let Mother Nature take her course and work on other parts of your life.
The truth is coming out about hair transplants. The number of transplants has come down since the heyday of 2000. (Real Self conveniently provides these stats so check them out) Please don't become another victim like me. There isn't a day that goes by that I don't regret what I did and wish I could just shave my head down.
Great review?
My counsel to you as a victim/veteran is to start where the hair transplant doctor starts when he wakes up in the morning: cold hard cash. Make no mistake, money is why they got into the business and they care much more about the almighty $$$ than they do your physical or cosmetic well-being. So you have to reason the same way.
How much money do you have to pour into this enterprise? Most men think they only need to go in once or twice. Trust me. You will need to go in much more than that as your hair loss progresses. I've been in five times for surgeries and once for scar revision. I'm up to $45,000 and will probably pour another $20,000 in FUE surgeries before it's all said and done. The back of my head is completely scarred. The hairs all over have turned thin, wiry, and are getting white. I'm 36. I have no idea where this story will end. I wake up every morning just hoping the donor region itself doesn't thin further over time. I keep making compromises and asking for less and less as time goes on. In the end, I know that I'll be in a good place if the scar isn't visible when I am your age.
So the question you have to ask yourself is how far and how much money you are willing to put into this journey (knowing full well that it has a high probability of ending in failure). If you have north of $50,000 to pour into it, then at least you have the cash at hand. Trust me. You don't want to end up having to keep saving up for the next procedure and the one after that and the one after that. It's demoralizing to work all year just to give a part of it away to a hair transplant doctor. Last year, I gave up about $8,000 to have my head butchered one more time. I'm so tired of hair, hair transplants, medicines that mess with my hormones, scam treatments like PRP, shampoos, and (more than anything) dealing with hair transplant doctors, their staff, and the industry in general. Think about it before you do it. A hair transplant won't just be a one-off event.
It will keep going and going as your hair loss progresses.
Beyond this, I wanted to address your statement that you say you are thinning. That word "thinning" can mean two things: (1) there is less hair on your head; (2) the hairs are actually becoming thin, grey, and dead looking. The two events are related and both affect how your hair looks. If you hair is already starting to look thin and wiry in addition to falling out, then it is most likely that you are progressing at a fast rate. You could lose it in the next 2-3 years or hold out a bit longer, but it's going to go no matter what. Look at Agassi, it took him just a few years in the late 90's to go NW5. Trust me. When it really starts to go, it doesn't take long.
If that's the case, I recommend you don't get a hair transplant. The next 10 years of your life will be a living hell trying to catch up to it. I speak from experience. The last 8 years of my youth have been spent fighting a losing war. These are my peak earning years and I've been emotionally, psychologically, and financially distracted by this story. Obviously, I wish I had known better. I really fell for all the lies. I absolutely do not want anyone else to walk into those clinics as blind as I was to the truth.
The Dustateride has neither helped nor hurt me after 2 months of use. I'm grateful it has not led to erectile dysfunction. I'm not sure it's an improvement over finasteride. I can tell you it's much more expensive. Remember you take a risk with either. Merck claims only 2% of those taking Propecia will experience erectile dysfunction. Based on what I've read, I;m sure that number is higher - probably between 5-10%. Scary stuff.
Honestly, I would say just leave it alone. It's all in your head - the insecurity, the constant worrying about your hair, the constant looking in the mirror. Hair transplants won't get rid of it. In fact, it will make it worse. You'll still be looking in the mirror and combing your hair over. Only you'll be doing it with a lot less money in your pocket.
Just a quick ironic story before I wrap this up. For years, I used to look at Sean Connery's hair in the 60's Bond movies and ask myself how he ended up looking like he did in the 3rd Indiana Jones movie. I used to tell myself, "Well, at least he had a full head of hair in his 30's." It was only last year that I found out that he wore a wig in all those Bond movies. He once commented that he didn't care because it was just a character anyway. I was so shocked and then it hit me - Connery was never insecure about how he looked. As he lost his hair, he never cared or worried. Maybe that is why he's aged so well. Maybe the same thing applies to Bruce Willis and so many others. The good looks comes from the confidence which comes from inside. That is all any of us really need. Our minds will be free to build our wealth, health and happiness.
It took me 8 years to realize it was all in my head. It was just me being insecure and letting this crooked industry exploit me and empty my bank account repeatedly.
It's cruel to offer false hope and deceive people the way the hair transplant industry does. These doctors are butchers who are getting rich by ruining the lives of so many of their patients. They are the medical equivalent of Wall Street brokers. Some of them like Bernstein in N.Y. or Umar in CA are completely bald. The irony is incredible. These men are bald but are performing transplants on others. Ridiculous. Just like Wall Street brokers that won't buy the stocks they recommend, they don't believe in the product they sell to go under the knife themselves.
I hope all of this helps. In the end, you may get results from a hair transplant. However, the insecurity that is driving you (and not Bruce Willis or Jason Statham) to get one will not be solved by a hair transplant. Think about that before you pour a ton of money and make a huge emotional commitment to a war against Father Time that in the end you cannot win.
It has worked for me to a reasonable extent, compared to my brother who is pretty bald whereas I just have a high hairline. I know of one friend who ceased taking it because of sexual dysfunction concerns. I've never experienced that personally myself. I can't compare myself to any other men as it's not something we men talk about much.
I'm sure Finasteride does lose its effectiveness over time. As it almost never works on the forehead, most men's hair will continue to naturally recede in that area, and ithat eventually that will clinch it. It's unfortunate, but it's in the same ballpark as 99% of the treatments in RealSelf. They all cease to work over time.
I have to say I'm one of the ones who is a bit disappointed that medical science hasn't found a cure by now. They've managed to fix so many other things, like ulcers and short sightedness. It would be great to finally put all these hair transplant charlatans out of business. Just wishful thinking...
Once your locked into this nightmare it's impossible to get out. If you started going through hair loss at an older age, then you got lucky. I'm 36 and it's been a nightmare. The crazy thing is that I no longer look at a guy with a full head of hair with envy. I look at the guy with his head shaved and wonder what could have been.
Hair transplants are pure evil as far I'm concerned.
Once again, it proves that pictures are completely deceiving when it comes to hair. Hair looks different from different angles and under different lighting. Hair transplant doctors/butchers continually exploit this reality when they market their scam to the public.
I find reading your last comments thought provoking, all pretty valid except I believe the Finasteride (aka Propecia) does work on some people, and there is scientific evidence for that. Admittedly it only works on the crown not the front of the head, some people have unwanted side effects, it's unconfirmed on men over 40, but it works often enough to be worthwhile taking for a lot of people. I know personally that it works because I ran out several months back, didn't have time to get a new script, and had a noticeable deterioration.
The biggest negative used to be the expense, at about $100 a month, but with generic brands of the 5mg version, and the pill cutting technique, it's cheap enough to be at least worth maintaining a few years to see if it works.
I'm not saying it's for everyone, but it's not a con.
For the record, I never said that Propecia doesn't work at all. What I did say is that it stops working over time. It won't give what a young man wants to hear: that it will hold the hair (both hair count and quality) he has and that the transplants will fill in the rest so that the war against hair loss can be truly won.
Follow the links if you don't believe me. Here is a simple search under "Propecia Stops Working Over Time" run on Yahoo:
http://search.yahoo.com/search;_ylt=A0oGdSUdLDJQqBkAiaNXNyoA?p=propecia%20stops%20working%20over%20time&fr2=sb-top&fr=yfp-t-701-s
This one is from William Rassman's Balding Blog. I love how he disclaims that he ever said that Propecia stops hair loss. Hair transplant doctors leave enough grey areas in their statements to extract themselves later on. But in this post he says the truth: there is no cure for hair loss and the balding will continue. Again, it goes back to what I wrote above on how unrealistic these so-called doctors are and how they are taken chances with our long-term cosmetic appearance.
http://www.baldingblog.com/2009/07/13/if-propecia-doesnt-stop-working-why-am-i-thinning-after-10-years/
The final point you said is that it is not a con. Depends on how you look at that if you are in the unfortunate minority that suffers from erectile dysfunction because of it. I could post a bunch of links up but this one from a legal website will do the trick. Propecia is getting sued by people that have had adverse side effects.
http://www.lawyersandsettlements.com/articles/propecia/propecia-help-finasteride-lawsuit-9-17163.html
How long have you been on Propecia? More than 10 years? If you have managed to maintain your hair on Propecia for more than 10 years then you are in the minority.
Overall, Propecia is a lot of money and significant risk ("Great! I have my hair to attract to get the girls, but my equipment doesn't work!) to try to preserve a few crown hairs and the donor region in the back for just a little while longer from their inevitable death.
First, I'd like to thank all of those that commented in reply to my main post. I appreciate it. I'm here on Real Self to help clarify the misconceptions and factual inaccuracies (shall I just call them flat-out lies?) promoted by the hair transplant industry. The hair transplant industry is a fraud and disgrace. I wish for my posts to act a reality check, that anyone can cash. A few minutes of reading can potentially save another victim years of physical, financial and emotional suffering.
Fortunately, Real Self is a truly reputable website that will allow an open and honest discussion of different cosmetic surgeries. I recently read my posts and I'm quite sure I would have been booted off a lot of the pro-hair transplant sites a long time ago. At the end of the day, they are interested in $$$ and don't want any dissenting opinions. Here on Real Self, I'm grateful for the chance to speak freely about hair transplants.
So what is the truth about hair transplants?
Look, I will say it again and again until the proverbial cows come home...
Hair transplants are at best a semi-permanent and ultimately ineffective solution to a long-term cosmetic problem. The reason for this is simple: 1. there just isn't enough hair; 2. the hair that is transplanted will continue to thin, whiten and die till it is cosmetically worthless. These realities cannot be avoided and there is no medication or treatment that will stop it. With a hair transplant you are fighting a losing war that you will NOT win in the long term.
This is where one will hear a lot of "But..." statements come in. I will comment on a couple of them in this post and then on others in later posts.
Some of the biggest misconceptions include:
- "But what about the pictures on the websites of hair transplant doctors. The patients seem to have a full head of hair. If a doctor can get results like that, then I want a hair transplant."
-- Pictures on hair transplant doctor websites cannot be trusted. Pictures are taken from particular angles and in controlled lighting with the hair styled in a particular way. Beyond this, you are seeing the doctor's very best results, not the ordinary results. In short, you are not getting a realistic idea of a likely outcome of your surgery. This applies to ALL hair transplant doctors. No hair transplant doctor will take a picture of results in bright sunlight with the hair tussled about instead of combed over. None.
- "But what about Propecia and minoxidil? I'm taking those. They'll hold my hair and the transplants will fill in the rest."
-- Yep. That might be the biggest lie of all. That's the one I fell for 8 years ago. Now the doctors have added lasers, PRP, A-cell, and possibly Latisse to the armory of worthless snake oil that will not stop your hair loss in the long-run. Propecia even carries a risk of impotence (erectile dysfunction) with it.
Think about it. If these medicines worked, then there would be no bald people. Young men would just take them and - "Presto!" - baldness would be a thing of the past. Not happening. Propecia has been around for more than a decade now and men are still going bald. Propecia may work for a little while (5 years or so) but then your hair will continue to die. Minoxidil might help to keep it thick and dark for a little while, but eventually they will turn thin and old. The other junk is experimental and have no proven cosmetic benefits. Nothing is going to stop the progression of your hair loss. A potential hair transplant patient needs to accept and understand this fundamental reality.
- "But what about the surgical skill of the doctor. I'm planning on going to a top doctor in the field. I know he will give me good results. I just know it."
-- With hair transplants, the bad doctor is always the other guy's doctor. What I mean is that most men are ashamed or embarrassed to comment on their hair transplants if they are not satisfied (so you won't hear them comment). I know this because it took me years to accept the truth and then have the courage to tell the world about it. If I had to guess, I would imagine that 80% of hair transplant patients will regret their surgeries in the long run (10-20 years) after the baldness has run its course. Also, there are many men who will claim to be satisfied with their hair transplants even if the cosmetic results are terrible (but they won't post pics). These poor men represent the saddest and most extreme cases of male insecurity (hair transplant doctors love them as patients) and even a few weeds on their domes will make them happy. Next, you do have those legitimately good results (the top 5%) that sell the product for the industry. Mostly, these are younger guys that have poured their life savings (often in excess of $50,000) into hair transplants. Of course, they are still young so we don't know the long term results of their hair transplants when the hairs age and thin. Finally, you have all the patient reps (shall we call them paid shills?) posting bogus stories all over the Internet promoting either a specific doctor, the industry at large, or both. It's a common industry practice and hair transplant clinics do it regularly. This is how shameless and unethical this industry is. They need to lie constantly to reel in another batch of suckers.
- "But my doctor tells me I have great donor hair. He mapped my hair our for minituarization, and he says I'm an excellent candidate for a hair transplant."
- Yep. I fell for that one, too. My first doctor told me the same bull manure. It is next to impossible to look at the back of a man's head and predict where the baldness is going to go. Not only can you not tell where the hair will stop falling out, but you also can't tell what the color and quality of the hair will look like long term. In addition, you may suffer from diffuse balding which means all of your hair will start to thin out in the donor region.
These so-called doctors are nothing but snake oil salesmen who are lying to you. They cannot predict what will happen to your hair. No one can. Only your genes and DNA will be the ultimate arbiter of how your hair will thin and die out.
Don't believe me? Let's take a look at a potential patient. His name is Steve Jobs.
The link below shows you many pictures of Steve Jobs when was a young man with long thick black hair at about age 25.
http://images.search.yahoo.com/search/images;_ylt=AgPz7bEqBKQBTppQbGukqUebvZx4?p=steve+jobs+young&toggle=1&cop=mss&ei=UTF-8&fr=yfp-t-701
This link shows you Steve Jobs as an older man at 50 years old.
http://images.search.yahoo.com/search/images;_ylt=A2KJkP3VGi9QuXcAto2JzbkF?p=steve%20jobs%20pictures&fr=yfp-t-701&ei=utf-8&n=30&x=wrt&fr2=sg-gac&sado=1
Look at the quality of the hair. It's completely changed. It's not thick, it's not long, it's not black and it's not straight. It's thin, wiry, see through and cosmetically worthless. What kind of hair (and how much?) do you think you could get out of the back of Steve Jobs head that would make a major cosmetic difference on the top of his head? Be realistic and think clearly. The end result of multiple hair transplants would at best make Steve Jobs look the same but with a few weeds on his head. Plain and simple.
I'll stop here. I think I've made my point clear enough for now. However, I am painfully aware (as a victim myself) that I will have to keep repeating it to reach even a fraction of the readers reading these posts. I was also once so insecure that almost nothing would have dissuased me from going under the knife. I now realize I was a pathetic and vain loser, emptying out my bank account for a pipe dream sold to me by the most disreputable industry in cosmetic surgery.
Think about it all of this before you do the same. If Steve Jobs, with his billions of dollars, never felt the need to get a hair transplant, then ask yourself why you, with limited funds, need one. In the long run it's not going to make any real difference in your life. It won't stop the passage of time or your aging. You're going grow old and go bald. Face it. Accept it. You can be bald naturally or bald with the back of your head all scarred up (even with FUE).
Sorry to run on. Hope this helps some of the fence sitters. If you go under the knife, there is no turning back. Hair loss will become your life and a financial and emotional drain that will follow you the rest of your life. Trust me. You don't want that.
Good luck to all. And feel free to comment (even if you disagree). The more we talk about it, the more we can get at the truth. The truth - that is and will always remain the most important thing when dealing with an industry that survives on deceptive business practices.