Smart Lipo: Stories

Write a Review

Horrific Experience - Extremely Painful - Too New to See Results but Would Not Recommend to Worst Enemy

  • posted 5 years ago
  • updated 1 year ago

I went into my procedure 5'6", 120lbs, age 44 with...

  • 10 Dec 2007

I went into my procedure 5'6", 120lbs, age 44 with a few trouble areas: outer thighs, upper/lower tummy, back rolls, mozilla side boobs. I am very fit for my age - no kids. However, I suffered life-altering injuries 20 yrs ago and I was in a wheelchair for 1.5 yrs. Due to the difficult recovery from that accident, I developed problem areas of fat that won't go away and now have significant cellulite issues.

I am very modest but in the Summer like to wear a midriff which I have not done in 20 yrs since my accident because I hated my stomach appearance. I thought SmartLipo was the answer - I have done mesotherapy, countless workout routines including personal fitness training etc and nothing worked. I only wanted my tummy done but after consulting with a prominent La Jolla doc, who said SmartLipo is a piece of cake and urged me to do the other areas...gee, I am already under anaesthesia..., off I went to surgery.

I had five areas done in Nov 2007. My outer thighs are smooth as a baby's butt!!! My stomach is ruined with lumps and sagging skin - I cannot believe I ruined my nice body over a little protruding tummy...it hurts like hell too. I take Vicodin every couple hours just to get through the day.

Recovery wise, I could not get dressed for 6 days. My crotch is bigger than my dog's head. My back boobs and love handles are slightly improved but I am still horribly swollen and bruised so only time will tell. One side of my waistlibe is more sculpted than the other and on my small frame it really is obvious.

It was the most painful thing I have experienced in my life - I have been through a lot and am a "tough" girl when it comes to pain - this was awful. despite the results, I would never have willingly gone through the recovery - I was not well-informed.

[Editor's note: this review was originally published under Liposuction and was moved to the Smart Lipo reviews in May 2008.]


  • 11 Feb 2011

Four years later and it's better but horrific. I...

  • 15 Dec 2011
Four years later and it's better but horrific. I am finally willing to add some pictures. I have tried just about everything - now whats left is a tummy tuck with a huge ugly scar.

Great review?

My Doctor:

My rating:

Doctor's Bedside Manner
Answered My Questions
After Care Follow-Up
Time Spent With Me
Phone or Email Responsiveness
Staff Professionalism & Courtesy
Payment Process
Wait Times

dr. stuart b. kincaid is a dangerous doctor - he never saw me after my procedure despite my three attempts to see him with terrible pain and suffering - do not go to this doctor. i am starting a support group about him.

Comments (12)

Sort by
2037anon 30 Apr 2013
What treatments have you tried to smooth this out? And please let me know which treatments seemed to help! Thank you,
sweetdreams34 20 Jan 2012
I want to say I'm sorry about your results. I know you don't want to have a tummy tuck but at this point I think it will solve your issues. Tara Reid got her botched tummy lipo fixed beautifully with a tummy tuck. She looks so great now.
threezn7s 20 Jan 2012
Tara Reid did not have a tummy tuck.
threezn7s 22 Jun 2009
My stomach appears to be permanently disfigured from the initial procedure. I have tried everything to fix my initial results which were horrible. It does look better but I cannot look at myself naked in the mirror or in the shower. The skin is taught or loose in areas and there are many lumps. Believe me, I have tried everything and spent a lot of hope filled dollars on Thermage, Lipodissolve, 3 rounds of Smartlipo with another doctor, and exercise. I figure now I am permanently disfigured from the above-named doctor. My best advice to anyone small in size who is considering this procedure is to simply not do it -
Houston4138 19 Dec 2011

I had smart lipo done a year ago and your stomach looks just like mine. I am small too but just wanted to get rid of my pooch without losing my boobs. My stomach now looks terrible. It's soooo depressing. I feel deformed. :-((

smile75 1 Jun 2009
Wow, I hear of horror stories but, yours scared me. I have been looking into getting the smart lipo with Dr. Schafer he is known as Dr. smart lipo. I actually looked at Dr. Kincaid first... go figure. Glad, I chose to check out other doctors. How are you doing now?
Lara San Diego 5 Mar 2010
Did you ever get it done by Dr Shafer. I am considering going him to him and appreciate if you can share your experience. thanks,
Michell Anne (unregistered guest) 24 Feb 2008
How are you progessing and how far out are you from your surgery? Is there any real hope that my stomach will smooth out in the end? Still very bumpy and uneven. Michell Anne
Bev Jean 24 Feb 2008
My experience was very much like yours.
threezn7s 1 Feb 2008
I am now 9 weeks out and can say that I am much better now but my stomach is still very lumpy and uneven - perhaps gross looking with puffy rolled areas . . . my belly button feels stuck to my spine. Occassionally I can still feel spots that had been worked on that are mildly painful to the touch. I am happy with the inch-loss reduction but not the skin appearance. I cannot bare to see myself naked - it is not a nice feeling since I seem to have let vanity take over and I had a really descent bod before the surgery. I did smart lipo with the suction . . . I have noticed a huge difference in the way my clothing fits and looks for the better. I still would not recommend this procedure to anyone - I have injuries that impede my ability to work out some areas and was left with no choice after trying to improve the areas over two decades. I had no idea it would hurt so much.
jamiedb 22 Sep 2008
I would never have any liposuction procedure that wasn't "ultrasound" assisted. This melts the fat so that you have an even look. I had it done to my stomach, inner thighs, and hips and it turned out great! Unfortunately, it was years ago and I could use it on my stomach again, but I would no way have any other type of lipo done and it seems that not many dr.s offer it. I saw a before and after of your type of lipo and it was also a bumpy result. Search for a dr. who does ultrasound assisted. It'll be much better results.My dr. was in Michigan and does an excellent job for great prices. {doctor information edited} I also had a saline implant through the navel job done by him (also with great results). I don't understand why other dr.s don't do the ultrasound lipo which is the best! --- Editor note: If you would like to review your experience with a particular provider or clinic, please write your treatment review and enter the provider or clinic name in the field provided.
kthnx bye (unregistered guest) 25 Jan 2008
I am sorry your doctor didn't give you the "real deal" on how much it hurts to have lipo. Out of curiousity - you wrote this when you were only six weeks out - the lumps and swelling can last for six months. Are you feeling better? Did the "ken doll" swelling go down (that is very comon, by the way)? Also, did you get smart lipo with suction or without?

More Smart Lipo Reviews

Have my First Consultation May 17 - Chevy Chase, MD 3 days ago

I am a 53 yo with 2 teenagers. I always had an average to slim body; even after having my...

Got my LIPO Today :) - Westchester, NY 3 days ago

Procedure was completely Painless - Staff was awesome ! Dr was fun -all of the nurses &...

Smart Lipo on Arms, Bra Area,and Flanks - San Ramon, CA 5 days ago

Hello Everyone, I had smart lipo performed on my arms, bra area, and flanks on Friday May...

View more Smart Lipo reviews

Welcome Back

Sign in with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Forgot your password?

Don't have an account? Create one now.

Join RealSelf

Join with Facebook

Your information remains private and will not be posted without your permission.

Please enter a valid email address
 Did you mean ?

By creating an account, you are indicating that you have read and accept the RealSelf Terms of Use.

Already a member? Sign In.

Retrieve your password

Enter your username or email address and we will send you a link to login.

Check your email

Check your email. We've sent you a link to reset your password.

Ok